Competence vs. performance; theoretical vs. applied
The development and interplay of two dichotomies in modern linguistics
The past 30 years have seen marked shifts in the generative grammarians’ view of the nature of linguistic competence. The rule-oriented period of early Transformational Grammar, which was ushered in by the publication of Chomsky’s Syntactic Structures in 1957, gave way a decade later to the principle-oriented period of Generative Semantics. By the mid-1970s, the rule-oriented Lexicalist framework had replaced Generative Semantics. Since around 1981, the principle-oriented Principles & Parameters approach is the one to which a majority of generative syntacticians hold allegiance. Each shift in the generativists’ view of the nature of competence has been accompanied by a revised view of how concepts derived from generative syntax might be applied to second language teaching. Since 1957, three different strategies for applying the theory have been propounded: the ‘mechanical’, the ‘terminological’, and the ‘implicational’, each of which has been instantiated during each period in the development of generative syntax. The paper closes with some speculative remarks about the feasibility of applying generativist theory to second language teaching.
References
Banathy, Bela, Edith Trager & Carl Waddle
1966 “
The Use of Contrastive Data in Foreign Language Course Development”.
Trends in Language Teaching ed. by
Albert Valdman, 35–56. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Belasco, Simon
1985 “
Toward the Identification of a Core Grammar in L2 Acquisition”.
Studies in Second Language Acquisition 71.91–98.
Bloomfield, Leonard
1914 Introduction to the Study of Language. New York: Henry Holt & Co. (New ed., with an introduction by
Joseph F. Kess, Amsterdam: John Benjamins 1983.)
Brown, H. Douglas
1972 “
The Next 25 Years: Shaping the revolution”.
TESOL Quarterly 61.80–85.
Brown, T. Grant
1971 “
Pedagogical Implications of a Case Grammar of French”.
IRAL 91.229–244.
Chomsky, Noam
1957 Syntactic Structures. The Hague: Mouton.
Chomsky, Noam
1964 Current Issues in Linguistic Theory. Ibid.
Chomsky, Noam
1970a “
Remarks on Nominalization”.
Readings in English Transformational Grammar ed. by
Roderick Jacobs &
Peter Rosenbaum, 184–221. Waltham, Mass.: Ginn & Co.
Chomsky, Noam
1970b “
Noam Chomsky’s View of Language”.
Readings in Applied Transformational Grammar ed. by
Mark Lester, 96–113. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston. [Interview with
Stuart Hampshire, edited with an introduction by
Alasdair McIntyre.]
Chomsky, Noam
1981 Lectures on Government and Binding. Dordrecht: Foris.
Diller, Karl
1971 Generative Grammar, Structural Linguistics, and Language Teaching. Rowley, Mass.: Newbury House.
Di Pietro, Robert
1968 “
Contrastive Anlaysis and the Notions of Deep and Surface Grammar”.
Report of the Nineteenth Annual Round Table Meeting on Linguistics and Language Studies ed. by
James Alatis, 65–82. Washington: Georgetown University Press.
Dirven, René
1974 “
The Relevance of Generative Semantics for Language Teaching”.
Linguistic Insights in Applied Linguistics ed. by
S. Pit Corder &
Eddy Roulet, 27–44. Brussels: AIMAV.
Flynn, Suzanne & Wayne O’Neil
eds. 1988 Linguistic Theory in Second Language Acquisition. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Gefen, Raphael
1966 “
Theoretical Prerequisites for Second-Language Teaching”.
IRAL 41.227–243.
Gefen, Raphael
1967 “
‘Sentence Patterns’ in the Light of Language Theories and Classroom Needs”.
IRAL 51.185–192.
Gouin, François
1892 The Art of Teaching and Studying Languages. London: Philip.
Harris, James
1973 “
Linguistics and Language Teaching: Applications versus Implications”.
Georgetown University Round Table on Languages and Linguistics 1973 ed. by
Kurt R. Jankowsky, 11–18. Washington: Georgetown Univ. Press.
Harris, Zellig S.
1941 Review of N. Trubetzkoy,
Grundzüge der Phonologie (Prague 1939)
Language 171.345–349.
Hockett, Charles F.
1952 Review of Travaux du Cercle Linguistique de Copenhague V: Recherches structurales
(Copenhagen 1949)
IJAL 181.86–89.
Hunt, Kellogg W.
1970 “
How Little Sentences Grow into Big Ones”.
Readings in Applied Transformational Grammar ed. by
Mark Lester, 170–186. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
Jacobson, Rudolfo
1966 “
The Role of Deep Structure in Language Teaching”.
Language Learning 161.153–160.
Jakobovits, Leon
1970 “
Implications of Recent Psycholinguistic Developments for the Teaching of a Second Language”.
Readings in Applied Transformational Grammar ed. by
Mark Lester, 253–275. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
Jespersen, Otto
1924 The Philosophy of Grammar. London: Allen & Unwin.
Katz, Jerrold & Paul Postal
1964 An Integrated Theory of Linguistic Descriptions. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
Lado, Robert
1968 “
Contrastive Linguistics in a Mentalistic Theory of Language Learning”.
Report of the Nineteenth Annual Round Table Meeting on Linguistics and Language Studies ed. by
James Alatis, 123–135. Washington: Georgetown Univ. Press.
Lakoff, Robin
1969 “
Transformational Grammar and Language Teaching”.
Language Learning 191.117–140.
Lakoff, Robin
1975 “
Linguistic Theory and the Real World”.
Language Learning 251.309–339.
Lamendella, John
1969 “
On the Irrelevance of Transformational Grammar to Second Language Pedagogy”.
Language Learning 191.255–270.
Lenneberg, Eric H.
1967 Biological Foundations of Language. New York: Wiley & Sons.
Newmark, Leonard & David Reibel
1970 “
Necessity and Sufficiency in Language Learning”.
Readings in Applied Transformational Grammar ed. by
Mark Lester, 228–252. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
Newmeyer, Frederick
1983 Grammatical Theory: Its limits and its possibilities. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press.
Newmeyer, Frederick
1986 Linguistic Theory in America. Second Edition. New York: Academic Press.
Newmeyer, Frederick
1987 “
Current Convergences in Grammatical Theory: Some implications for second language acquisition research”.
Second Language Research 31.1–19.
Newmeyer, Frederick
In press. “
Rules and Principles in the Development of Generative Syntax”.
The Chomskyan Turn: Generative linguistics, mathematics, philosophy, and psychology ed. by
Asa Kasher Oxford Blackwell
Nilsen, Don
1971 “
The Use of Case Grammar in Teaching English as a Foreign Language”.
TESOL Quarterly 51.293–300.
Ohmann, Richard
1964 “
Generative Grammars and the Concept of Literary Style”.
Word 201.423–439.
Palmer, Harold E.
1917 The Scientific Teaching and Study of Languages. Yonkers, N.Y.: World.
Rutherford, William
1968 Modern English. New York: Harcourt, Brace & World.
Rutherford, William
1987 Second Language Grammar: Learning and Teaching. London: Longman.
Rutherford, William & Michael Sharwood Smith
eds. 1988 Grammar and Second Language Teaching. Rowley, Mass.: Newbury House.
Saporta, Sol, Arthur Blumenthal & Donald Reiff
1963 “
Grammatical Models and Language Learning”.
Report of the Fourteenth Annual Round Table Meeting on Linguistics and Language Studies ed. by
Robert Di Pietro, 133–142. Washington: Georgetown Univ. Press.
Saussure, Ferdinand de
1916 Cours de linguistique générale. Lausanne & Paris: Payot. (3rd corrected ed. 1931.)
Spolsky, Bernard
1970 “
Linguistics and Language Pedagogy – Applications or Implications?”.
Georgetown University Round Table on Languages and Linguistics 1969 ed. by
James Alatis, 143–155. Washington: Georgetown Univ. Press.
Cited by
Cited by 1 other publications
Barbe, Katharina
2001.
The dilemma with dichotomies.
Language & Communication 21:1
► pp. 89 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 28 february 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.