Cover not available
Article published In:
International Journal of Chinese Linguistics
Vol. 11:2 (2024) ► pp.190–246

On word stress in Mandarin

Evidence from the differences between qingsheng   轻声 and qingyin 轻音

 | Princeton University
Qingsheng and qingyin have long been a set of confusing concepts in Chinese linguistic studies. In literature scholars usually agree on the use of qingsheng to refer to the neutral tone in Mandarin. However, some scholars believe that qingsheng is the same as qingyin and use them interchangeably. Furthermore, the term qingyin is used to prove that Mandarin has word stress, since word stress, or zhongyin in Chinese is the counterpart of qingyin. Therefore, it is important to clarify the relationship between the two concepts, namely qingsheng and qingyin to determine the linguistic and typological nature of Mandarin. This study tried to differentiate these two concepts both phonetically and phonologically and proved that qingsheng is a result of a set of tonal processes, such as tone sandhi, tone neutralization, tone spreading, while qingyin is a result of a series of metrical process, such as clash and lapse. It also compared qingsheng and qingyin on their functions, classifications, origins, and did a quantitative study on the distribution of the qingsheng words in Mandarin to further prove that qingsheng and qingyin are two completely different concepts, and hence proved that it is invalid to claim Mandarin has word stress because of the existence of qingsheng.
Keywords: qingsheng , qingyin , stress language, tonal process, qingsheng distribution
Article outline
  • 1.Introduction
    • 1.1 Qingsheng vs. qingyin: Two essential concepts in the study of word stress in Mandarin
    • 1.2Contributions of the study on qingsheng vs. qingyin to the study of language typology and language evolution
    • 1.3Difficulties: The confusion between qingsheng and qingyin
    • 1.4Goals and methods
  • 2. Qingsheng theoretical analysis
    • 2.1The nature of qingsheng (acoustic, perceptual)
      • 2.1.1Acoustic characteristics of qingsheng
        • 2.1.1.1On intensity
        • 2.1.1.2On length
        • 2.1.1.3On pitch and contour
        • 2.1.1.4On segmental level: Vowel reduction, vowel eclipsis, and voiced consonant
      • 2.1.2The dominant features in the perception of qingsheng
    • 2.2The tonal process of qingsheng
      • 2.2.1Tone sandhi
      • 2.2.2Spreading rule
      • 2.2.3Tone neutralization
    • 2.3The phonological differences between qingsheng and qingyin
    • 2.4The functions of qingsheng
      • 2.4.1The function of distinguishing part of speech and lexical meanings
      • 2.4.2The authenticity of the pronunciation
      • 2.4.3The colloquial nature of the pronunciation
    • 2.5The classification of qingsheng
      • 2.5.1Classified by internal structure
      • 2.5.2Classified by function
      • 2.5.3Classified by the original tone of the qingsheng words
    • 2.6The origin of qingsheng
    • 2.7Cause of qingsheng
  • 3.The quantity of qingsheng
    • 3.1Previous statistics
    • 3.2The distribution of qingsheng words in Modern Chinese
      • 3.2.1Disyllabic words in Xiandai Hanyu Cidian
      • 3.2.2Disyllabic qingsheng words in Modern Chinese Dictionary
      • 3.2.3 Qingsheng and T4
    • 3.3The frequency of qingsheng
    • 3.4The changes of qingsheng
  • 4.Conclusions and further discussions
  • Notes
  • References
Published online: 5 December 2024
DOI logo
https://doi.org/10.1075/ijchl.00015.yan
References (61)
References
Cao, Jianfen. (1986). The properties of neutral-syllables in Standard Chinese. Journal of Applied Acoustics, 41, 3–8.Google Scholar
Cao, Jianfen 曹剑芬. (1995). Liandu biandiao yu qingzhong duili 连读变调与轻重对立 [Tone sandhi and the contrast between stressed and unstressed]. Studies of the Chinese Language 中国语文, 41, 312–320.Google Scholar
Chao, Yuen Ren. (1979). A Grammar of Spoken Chinese 汉语口语语法. (Shuxiang Lü, Trans.). The Commercial Press. (Original work published 1968)Google Scholar
. (2002). Zhao Yuanren Yuyanxue Lunwen Ji 赵元任语言学论文集 [Y.R Chao’s Essays on Linguistics]. The Commercial Press.Google Scholar
Chen, Xiaoyan 陈小燕. (2004). On the necessity and consistency principals of Qingsheng Words: metric research on Qingsheng Words in Modern Chinese Dictionary. Applied Linguistics 语言文字应用, 11, 112–119.Google Scholar
Cihai Editorial Committee. (1979). Cihai 辞海. Shanghai Lexicographical Publishing House.Google Scholar
Csongor, Barnabás. (1959). A contribution to the history of chi’ing yin. Acta Orient. Hung. IX1. 78.Google Scholar
Deng, Dan 邓丹, Chen, Ming 陈明 , & Lyu, Shinan 吕士楠. (2004). Hanyu qusheng he qingsheng yinjie de yunlyu tezheng yanjiu 汉语去声和轻声音节的韵律特征研究 [Studies on the prosodic features of the Tone 4 and the neutral tone syllables in Mandarin]. Language Science 语言科学, 3(2), 20–28.Google Scholar
Deng, Dan 邓丹. (2019). Reanalysis of neutral tone perception in Standard Chinese. Applied Linguistics 语言文字应用, 11, 66–75.Google Scholar
Dictionary Editing Office, Institute of Linguistics, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences. (2016). Xiandai Hanyu Cidian 现代汉语词典 [Modern Chinese Dictionary], 7th edition. The Commercial Press.Google Scholar
Ding, Dimeng 丁迪蒙. (1990). Cong duiwaihanyu jiaoxue kan hanyu de yinbian wenti 从对外汉语教学看汉语的音变问题 [On the Issue of Chinese Phonetic Change from the Perspective of Teaching Chinese as a Foreign Language]. Journal of Shanghai University. 上海大学学报, 41, 97–102.Google Scholar
Duanmu, San. (2014). Stress theory and stress phenomena in Chinese. Contemporary Linguistics, 31, 288–302.Google Scholar
Feng, Shengli 冯胜利. (2016). Beijinghua shi yige zhongyin yuyan 北京话是一个重音语言 [Mandarin Chinese is a stress language]. Yuyan Kexue 语言科学, 15(5), 449–473.Google Scholar
Gao, Jingcheng 高景成. (1959). You xuduo cihui li kan qingsheng shuaitui de qushi 由许多词汇里看轻声衰颓的趋势 [The trend of neutral tone decay from many words]. Wenzi gaige 文字改革 [Language Reform], 2, 5.Google Scholar
Huang, Jingwen 黄婧雯 & Shi, Feng 石锋. (2019). Diversity of prosodic expressions on Chinese neutral tones. Applied Linguistics 语言文字应用, 11, 76–85.Google Scholar
Jin, Song 劲松. (2002). Xiandai Hanyu Qingsheng Dongtai Yanjiu 现代汉语轻声动态研究 [A Dynamic Study of Modern Chinese Neutral Tone]. The Ethnic Publishing House.Google Scholar
Jin, Youjing 金有景. (1984). Beijing hua shangsheng jia qingsheng de biandiao guil ü 北京话“上声+轻声”的变调规律 [The tone sandhi rules for the combination of the third tone and neutral tone in Beijing Mandarin]. Yu Hai Xin Tan 语海新探 [New Exploration of Languages], 1, 36.Google Scholar
Kenstowicz, Michael. (1994). Phonology in Generative Grammar. Blackwell Publishers.Google Scholar
Kratochvil, Paul. (1987). Beijing hua zhengchang huayu li de qingsheng 北京话正常话语里的轻声 [The neutral tone in normal speech in Beijing Mandarin] (Yi Xu, Trans). Studies of the Chinese Language 中国语文, 51, 330–345. (Original work published 1968)Google Scholar
Li, Aijun 李爱军. (2017). Phonetic correlates of neutral tone in different information structures. Contemporary Linguistics 当代语言学, 19(3), 348–378.Google Scholar
Li, Sha 李莎. (2006). A study of the application of neutral tone in Mandarin from the perspective of linguistics. Journal of Yunan Normal University (Teaching and Research on Chinese as a Foreign Language Edition), 4(1), 65–70.Google Scholar
Liang, Lei 梁磊 & Shi, Feng 石锋. (2007). Putonghua liangzizu qingshengyin de shengxue biaoxian 普通话两字组轻重音的声学表现 [Acoustic studies on lexical stress of bi-syllabic words in Standard Chinese]. In the Proceedings of The 8th China Phonetics Conference and International Symposium on Frontier Issues of Phonetics in Celebrating the 100th Birthday of Wu Zongji, 599–602.Google Scholar
Liao, Guangli 廖广莉 & Teng, Li 滕丽. (2011). Qingshengci yuyong pinlv xiaoyong yanjiu 轻声词语用频率效用研究 [An efficacy study of the semantic frequency of the neutral tone words]. Journal of Changchun University of Technology. 23(5), 102–104.Google Scholar
Lin, Maocan 林茂灿 & Yan, Jingzhu 颜景助. (1980). Beijing hua qingsheng de shengxue xingzhi 北京话轻声的声学性质 [The Acoustic Nature of Beijing Mandarin]. Dialect 方言, 31, 166–178.Google Scholar
Lin, Maocan 林茂灿, Yan, Jingzhu 颜景助 & Sun, Guohua 孙国华. (1984). Beijing hua liangzizu zhengchang zhongyin de chubu shiyan 北京话两字组正常重音的初步实验 [Preliminary experimental research on normal stress in disyllables in Mandarin]. Dialect 方言. 11, 57–73.Google Scholar
Lin, Yuhuan 林瑀欢 & Li, Liyun 李丽云. (2017). Chinese words with a light tone in Modern Chinese Dictionary (6th edition), Journal of Hebei Normal University (Philosophy and Social Sciences Edition), 40(6), 101–106.Google Scholar
Lin, Tao 林焘. (1983). Tantao Beijing hua qingsheng xingzhi de chubu shiyan 探讨北京话轻声性质的初步实验 [A preliminary experiment on the nature of qingsheng in Beijing dialect]. Yuyanxue Luncong 语言学论丛 101, 16–37.Google Scholar
Liu, Hai. (2018). Tone Sandhi in Mandarin Chinese. Ph.D. Dissertation. University of Wisconsin Madison.
Liu, Lili 刘俐李. (2002). Ershi shiji hanyu qingsheng yanjiu zongshu 20 世纪汉语轻声研究综述 [A summary of the research on Chinese neutral tone in the 20th century]. Yuwen Yanjiu 语文研究 [Language Studies], 84(3), 43–47.Google Scholar
Lu, Jilun 路继伦. (2005). On defining “qingsheng”. Contemporary Linguistics 当代语言学, 7(2), 107–112.Google Scholar
Lu, Yunzhong 鲁允中. (1995). Putonghua de Qingsheng he Erhua 普通话的轻声和儿化 [The neutral tone and the retroflexion in Mandarin]. The Commercial Press.Google Scholar
Luo, Changpei 罗常培 & Wang, Jun 王均. (1957). An Introduction to General Linguistics 普通语言学纲要. Science Press.Google Scholar
Luo, Yangtian. (2022). Prosodic Phonology of Chengdu Dialect. Ph.D. Dissertation. University of Wisconsin Madison.
Lyu, Xiang. (2018). Prosodic Phonology of Ningbo Dialect. Ph.D. Dissertation. University of Wisconsin Madison.
Mei, Tsulin. (1977). Tones and tone sandhi in 16th century Mandarin. Journal of Chinese Linguistics, 5(2), 237–260.Google Scholar
Selkirk, Elisabeth O. (1980). The role of prosodic categories in English word stress, Linguistic Inquiry, Summer, 11(3), 563–605.Google Scholar
Shi, Guodong 史国东. (2002). Putonghua yinwei xitong zhong de qingsheng chuli 普通话音位系统中的轻声处理 [The handling of the neutral tone in the phonemic system of Mandarin]. Journal of West Anhui University 皖西学院学报, 18(6), 90–91.Google Scholar
Song, Ziran 宋子然. ed. (2015). Yibainian Hanyu Xinci Xinyu Dacidian 一百年汉语新词新语大辞典 [A dictionary of the new words in Mandarin Chinese in the recent 100 years]. Shanghai Lexicographical Publishing House.Google Scholar
Sun, Heping 孙和平. (2008). Ye tan Putonghua qingshengci chuxian de guil ü 也谈普通话轻声词出现的规律 [Discussion of the emerging of neutral tone in Mandarin]. Journal of Xianning University. 28(5), 129–131.Google Scholar
Sun, Jingtao 孙景涛. (2005). Tone sandhi and the time when neutral tone started. Dialect 方言, 41, 329–336.Google Scholar
Wan, Li 万莉. (2008). Lun Putonghua qingsheng ji qi zuoyong 论普通话轻声及其作用 [On the neutral tone of Mandarin and its function]. Hetian Shifan Zhuanke Xuexiao Xuebao 和田师范专科学校学报(汉文综合版) [Journal of Hotan Teachers College (Comprehensive Chinese Edition)], 28(6), 90–91Google Scholar
Wan, Xueren 万学仁 & Xiong, Jie 熊杰. (2011). On the words with light tone in A dictionary of Common Words in Contemporary Chinese. Journal of Neijiang Normal University, 26(5), 53–57.Google Scholar
Wang, Hongjun 王洪军. (2004). Shilun Hanyu de jiezou leixing: songjin xing 试论汉语的节奏类型——松紧型 [On the metrical type of modern Standard Chinese – A type based on looseness]. Yuyan Kexue 语言科学 3(3), 21–28.Google Scholar
Wang, Li 王力. (1980). Hanyu Shi Gao 汉语史稿 [Manuscript of Historical Chinese Linguistics]. Zhonghua Book Company.Google Scholar
Wang, Xudong 王旭东. (1992). Beijinghua de qingsheng quhua ji qi yingxiang 北京话的轻声去化及其影响 [The 4th-tonalization and the influence of the neutral tone in Beijing Mandarin]. Studies of the Chinese Language 中国语文, 5(2), 124–128.Google Scholar
Wang, Zhijie 王志洁 & Shengli Feng 冯胜利. (2006). Shengdiao duibifa yu Beijinghua shuangyinzu de zhongyin leixing 声调对比法与北京话双音组的重音类型 [Tonal contrast and disyllabic stress patterns in Beijing Mandarin]. Yuyan Kexue 语言科学 [Linguistic Sciences], 5(1), 3–22.Google Scholar
Wen, Baoying 温宝莹 & Yan, Fang 燕芳. (2020). Why are the three prosodic elements not synchronized? – The prosodic mapping analysis on declarative and interrogative sentences in Mandarin Chinese. Experimental Linguistics. 9(1), 8–16.Google Scholar
Xu, Jieping 许洁萍, Chu, Min 初敏 & He, Lin 贺琳. (2000). The influence of Chinese sentence stress on pitch and duration. Chinese Journal of Acoustics, 25(4), 335–339.Google Scholar
Xu, Shirong 徐世荣. (1982). Shuang yinjie ci de yinliang fenxi 双音节词的音量分析 [The volume analysis of dissyllabic words]. Yuyan Jiaoxue Yu Yanjiu 语言教学与研究 [Language Teaching and Research], 21, 4–19.Google Scholar
. (1995). Guanyu chun qingshengzi wenti 关于纯轻声字问题 [On the issue of the neutral tone]. Language Planning 语文建设, 9, 47.Google Scholar
Yan, Fang. (2021). A study on the word stress of Mandarin disyllabic words (Publication NO. 28773736) [Doctoral dissertation, University of Wisconsin Madison]. ProQuest Dissertation & These Global.
You, Shuxiang. (2020). Prosodic Phonology of the Fuzhou Dialect: Domains and Rule Application. London & New York, NY: Routledge.Google Scholar
Zhang, Hongming. (1992). Topics in Chinese phrasal tonology. Ph.D. Dissertation. UCSD.
. (2013). Course lecture notes. EA932, University of Wisconsin Madison.Google Scholar
Zhang, Hongming 张洪明. (2014). Yunlü yinxixue yu Hanyu yunlü yanjiu zhong de ruogan wenti 韵律音系学与汉语韵律研究中的若干问题 [Some issues on prosodic phonology and Chinese prosodic studies]. Contemporary Linguistics 当代语言学, 16(3), 303–327.Google Scholar
Zhang, Hongming. (2017). Syntax-Phonology interface: Argumentation from tone sandhi in Chinese dialects. London & New York: Routledge.Google Scholar
. (2020). Public lecture “Some issues in prosodic studies”. November 30, 2020, at the department of China Minority Languages Studies, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences. [URL]
Zhang, Xiaoqin 张晓勤. (2003). Research on Soft-sounds of Putonghua 普通话轻声词规律探析. Journal of Guangxi University for Nationalities (Philosophy and Social Science Edition), 25(6), 122–125.Google Scholar
Zhang, Xunru 张洵如. (1957). Beijing Hua Qingsheng Cihui 北京话轻声词汇 [Neutral Tone Words in Beijing Mandarin]. Zhonghua Book Company.Google Scholar
Zhao, Jie 赵杰. (1996). Beijing Hua de Manyu Diceng he Qingsheng Erhua Tanyuan 北京话的满语底层和“轻声”“ 儿化” 探源 [Exploring the Origins of the Manchu language and the Neutral Tone and the Retroflexion in Beijing Mandarin]. Yanshan Publishing House.Google Scholar
Zhu, Hongyi 朱宏一. (2008). Guanyu qingsheng de ruogan yinan wenti 关于轻声的若干疑难问题 [On some issues of the difficulties on the study of the neutral tone]. Language Planning 语文建设, 91, 56–57.Google Scholar