Cover not available
Article published In:
International Journal of Chinese Linguistics
Vol. 10:2 (2023) ► pp.220–283

Problems with universal metrics

Evidence from Chinese recent-style verse (jinti shi) and Japanese haiku

 | Carnegie Mellon University
This paper aims to examine the problem of universal metrics developed with English sonnets by analyzing meter in Japanese haiku and Chinese recent-style verse.
Following Martin (2007), In this study, a haiku is defined as a traditional form of Japanese poetry consisting of three lines, typically with seventeen metrical units per verse arranged in a pattern of five, seven, and five units per line. The data reveals that a system with metrical prominence cannot be applied to Chinese and Japanese metrical verse since linguistic prominence is missing in both languages. The only common feature shared among the metrical systems of the three languages is the existence of a contrast between two types of syllables that belong to opposite classes. However, this contrast only applies in limited situations in the Japanese case. Lastly, instead of a universal metrical structure, the data suggests that the metrical structure in the three languages should be distinguished.
Keywords: universal metrics, Chinese recent-style verse, Japanese haiku, metrical structure, prominence
Article outline
  • 1.Background: Generative metrics and English iambic verse
  • 2.The aim of this paper
  • 3.Methodology and data
    • 3.1Methodology
    • 3.2Data description
  • 4.Case studies
    • 4.1Chinese recent-style verse
      • 4.1.1The structure and canonical patterns
      • 4.1.2Metrical structures from the data
      • 4.1.3Tonal distribution per position
      • 4.1.4The pair-wise contrast and 1-3-5 rule
      • 4.1.5Tonal patterns
    • 4.2Japanese haiku
      • 4.2.1Controversy on the poetic unit: Syllable vs. mora
      • 4.2.2Poetic unit and irregular patterns from the data
      • 4.2.3Syllable structure and distribution of special Moras from the data
  • 5.Discussion and theoretical implication
    • 5.1Comparison between Chinese recent-style verse and English iambic verse
    • 5.2Comparison between Japanese haiku and English iambic verse
    • 5.3Theoretical implication
      • 5.3.1On the metrical pattern of Chinese-recent style
      • 5.3.2On Japanese metrical pattern
      • 5.3.3Metrical structure in the three languages
  • 6.Conclusion
  • Acknowledgments
  • Notes
  • References
Published online: 15 December 2023
DOI logo
https://doi.org/10.1075/ijchl.00016.zha
References (79)
References
Aroui, Jean-Louis. (2009). Towards a Typology of Poetic Forms: From language to metrics and beyond. Philadelphia: John Benjamins Publishing Company. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Asano, Makiko. (2002). “Studies in Japanese prosody.” Ph.D. Diss., Harvard University.
Blumenfeld, Lev. (2016). “Generative Metrics: An Overview.” Language and Linguistics Compass 10/91: 413–430. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Bowers, Faubion. (1996). The Classic Tradition of Haiku: An Anthology. New York: Dover Publications.Google Scholar
Chen, Matthew Y. (1979). “Metrical Structure: Evidence from Chinese Poetry”. Linguistic Inquiry 101, 371–420.Google Scholar
Cole, Deborah, and Miyashita, Mizuki. (2006). “The Function of Pauses in Metrical Studies: Acoustic Evidence from Japanese Verse.” In Formal Approaches to Poetry: Recent Development in Metrics, 173–192. Berlin, Germany: Mouton de Gruyter. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Doi, Kōchi 土居光知. (1949). “Shikeiron” 詩形論. In Bungaku josetsu 文学序説. Tokyo: Iwanami Shoten.Google Scholar
Duanmu, San. (2004). “A corpus study of Chinese regulated verse: phrasal stress and the analysis of variability.” Phonology 21(1): 43–89. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Duanmu, San 端木三. (2016). Yinbu he Zhongyin 音步和重音 [Foot and Stress]. Beijing: Beijing Language and Culture University Press.Google Scholar
Duanmu, San, and Stiennon, Nathan. (2005). “Tonal Patterns in Chinese Regulated Verse: A Corpus Study.” Taiwan Journal of Linguistics 3.1: 1–31.Google Scholar
Fabb, Nigel, and Halle, Morris. (2008). Meter in Poetry: A New Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Frellesvig, Bjarke. (2010). A History of the Japanese language. New York: Cambridge University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Fujikawa, Naoya. (2020). “Bimoraicity and Feet in Japanese.” Ph.D. Diss., University Konstanz.
Gasparov, Mikhail L. (1987). “A probability model of verse (English, Latin, French, Italian, Spanish, Portuguese).” Style 21(3). 322–58.Google Scholar
Golston, Chris, and Tomas Riad. (2000). “The phonology of Classical Greek meter.” Linguistics 381: 99–167. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Halle, Morris, and Keyser, Samuel. J. (1971). English stress: its form, its growth, and its role in verse. New York: Harper & Row.Google Scholar
Hammond, Michael. (1991). “Poetic Meter and the Arboreal Grid.” Language 67(2): 240–259. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Haraguchi, Shosuke. (1996). Syllable, Mora, and Accent. In Otake, Takashi and Cutler, Anne (eds.), Phonological Structure and Language Processing: Cross-Linguistic Studies, 45–76. New York: Mouton de Gruyter. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Hayes, Bruce. (1983). A grid-based theory of English meter. Linguistic Inquiry 131: 227–276.Google Scholar
. (1988). “Metrics and phonological theory” In Newmeyer, Frederick J. (ed.), Linguistics: The Cambridge Survey, 220–249. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Hsieh, Daniel. (1998). The Origin and Nature of the “Nineteen Old Poems.” Sino-platonic Papers 771.1–49.Google Scholar
Ito, Junko, and Mester, Armin. (1992). Weak Layering and Word Binarity. In Honma, Takeru, Okazaki Masao, Tabata, Toshiyuki, and Tanaka, Shin-ichi (eds.), A New Century of Phonology and Phonological Theory. A Festschrift for Professor Shosuke Haraguchi on the Occasion of His Sixtieth Birthday, 26–65. Tokyo: Kaitakusha.Google Scholar
. (1995). Japanese phonology. In Japanese phonology. The handbook of phonological theory, 818–838. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell.Google Scholar
. (1996). Stem and word in Sino-Japanese. In Phonological structure and language processing: Cross-linguistic studies, 13–44. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
. (2003). “Japanese morphophonemics: Markedness and word structure.” Linguistic Inquiry Monograph 411, xii+303. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Jakobson, Roman. (1960). “Linguistics and Poetics.” In T. Sebeok (ed.), Style in Language, 350–377. Cambridge: Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press.Google Scholar
. (1970). “The Modular Design of Chinese Regulated Verse.” In Échanges et communications. The Hague and Paris: Mouton. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Jespersen, Otto. (1933). “Notes on meter.” Linguistica, 249–74. Copenhagen: Levin & Munksgaard.Google Scholar
Kawamoto, Kōji. (2000). The Poetics of Japanese Verse: Imagery, Structure, Meter (Collington, Stephen & Collins, Kevin & Heldt, Gustav trans.). Tokyo: University of Tokyo Press.Google Scholar
Kiang, Kang-Hu. (1929). The Jade Mountain: A Chinese Anthology, Being Three Hundred Poems of the T’ang Dynasty, 618–906. (Bynner, Witter trans.). New York: Knopf.Google Scholar
Kern, Adam L. (2018). The Penguin Book of Haiku. London: Penguin Random House.Google Scholar
Kiparsky, Paul. (1973). “The Role of Linguistics in a Theory of Poetry.” Language as a Human Problem 102 (3): 231–244.Google Scholar
. (1975). “Stress, Syntax, and Meter.” Language 51 (3): 576–616. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
. (1977). “The Rhythmic Structure of English Verse.” Linguistic Inquiry 8 (2): 189–247.Google Scholar
. (2020). Stress, meter, and text-setting. In Chen Aoju and Carlos Gussenhoven (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Language Prosody, 657–675. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Kirikoshi, Mai 桐越舞. (2011). “Inbun no gengo rizumi ni kansuru jikken onseigaku teki kenky ū” 韻文の言語リズムにみられる韻律フレーム型 [An Experimental Phonetic Study regarding the Rhythm of Poetic Language]. Hokkaidō gengo bunka kenkyū 北海道言語文化研究 91: 31–45.Google Scholar
Kubozono, Haruo. (1998). “On the Universality of Mora and Syllable.” Journal of the Phonetic Society of Japan 2 (1): 5–15.Google Scholar
. (1999). Mora and syllable. In Tsujimura, Natsuko. (2014). An Introduction to Japanese Linguistics, 31–61. Hoboken: Wiley- Blackwell.Google Scholar
. (2009). The Syllable as a Unit of Prosodic Organization in Japanese. In Féry, Caroline and Vijver, ven de Ruben (eds.), The Syllable in Optimality Theory, 99–122. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Labrune, Laurence. (2012). “Questioning the university of the syllable: evidence from Japanese.” Phonology 29 1, 113–152. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Levý, Jiří. (1971). “The Development of Rhyme-Scheme and of Syntactic Pattern in the English Renaissance Sonnet.” [URL]
Liberman, Mark. (1975). “The Intonational System of English.” PhD diss., Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
Liberman, Mark, and Prince, Alan. (1977). “On Stress and Linguistic Rhythm.” Linguistic Inquiry 8 (2): 249–336.Google Scholar
Martin, Gore. (2007). “Vowel Sequences in Poetry – Occurrence in Japanese–.” Bulletin of the Faculty of Education, Kagoshima University, Cultural and social science 591: 155–159.Google Scholar
McCawley, James D. (1965). “The Accentual System of Standard Japanese.” PhD. Diss., Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
(1968). The phonological component of a grammar of Japanese. The Hague: Mouton.Google Scholar
Mehl, Scott. (2022). The End of Meter in Modern Japanese Poetry. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Google Scholar
Mōri, Masamori 毛利正守. (1998). “Kodai nihongo ni okeru jiamari datsuraku o ronjite onsetsukōzō ni oyobu: Manyō (waka) to senmyo o tōshite ” 古代日本語に於ける字余り・脱落を論じて音節構造に及ぶ-萬葉(和歌)と宣命を通して- [On Jiamari and Jitarazu and the Syllable Structure of Old Japanese through Waka and Imperial Edict]. Kokugo to Kokubungaku 国語と国文学 75(5):119–130.Google Scholar
Ozawa, Minoru. (2021). Well-Versed: Exploring Modern Japanese Haiku. Tokyo: Japan Publishing Industry Foundation for Culture.Google Scholar
Prince, Alan, and Smolensky, Paul. (1993). Optimality Theory: Constraint Interaction in Generative Grammar (Technical Report no. RuCCS-TR-2). New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Center for Cognitive Science.Google Scholar
Ripley, Stephen. (1980). “Some findings on tone patterns in Tang regulated verse.” Journal of Chinese Linguistics 8.1: 126–148.Google Scholar
Ryan, Kevin M. (2019). Prosodic Weight: Categories and Continua. Oxford: Oxford University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Sagara, Moriji 相良守次. (1931). Nohon Shika no Rizumu 日本詩歌のリズム [The Rhythm of Japanese Poetry]. Tokyo: Kyoiku Kenkyukai.Google Scholar
Sakano, Nobuhiko 坂野信彦. (1978). “Naze goon shichionka: onsūkitei no nazo wo toku ” なぜ五音・七音か音数規定の謎を解く [Principles of Syllabic Regularity in Japanese Poetry]. Chukyo University Bulletin of the Faculty of Liberal Arts 19(2): 396–406.Google Scholar
. (1992). “Waka keishiki no seiritsu ni tsuite no shiron” 和歌形式の成立についての試論. [A Theory of the Waka Form]. Gakkai 学海 81: 17–26.Google Scholar
. (1998). Shichigo chō no nazo wo toku- Nihongo rizumu ganron 七五調の謎を解くー日本語リズム原論 [Solve the mystery of seven ad five sounds- a theory of the rhythm of Japanese language]. Tokyo: Taishūkan Shoten.Google Scholar
Sato, Yasushi. (2013). “The Syllable is Not a Universal Prosodic Unit-a case of Japanese.” The MGU Journal of Liberal Arts Studies: Karuchuru 7 (1): 39–51.Google Scholar
Shibata, Chikako 柴田知薫子. (2018). “Predictable Evolution of Japanese Phonology” 日本語の音韻変化を予測する. Annual report of the Faculty of Education, Gunma University, Cultural science series 671: 129–137.Google Scholar
Song, Chengqing, and Zhang, Hongming. (2013). “A New Approach to Chinese Poetic Prosody: The Case of Pair-wise Tonal Contrasts in Three Yongming Collections.” Chinese Literature: Essays, Articles, Reviews 371: 67–112.
Song, Chenqing, and Zhang, Hongming. (2015). Tonal Prosody in Yongming Style Poems. Tianjin: Nankai University Press.Google Scholar
Starr, Rebecca Lurie, and Shih, Stephanie S. (2017). “The syllable as a prosodic unit in Japanese lexical strata: Evidence from text-setting.” Glossa: a journal of general linguistics 2 (1): 931.1–34. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Takayama, Michiaki 高山倫明. (2006). “Onsetsukōzō to jiamariron” 音節構造と字余り論 [The Structure of Syllable and the Theory of Jiamari]. Gobun kenkyū 語文研究 (100–101): 203–217.Google Scholar
. (2018). “Jiamari hōsoku shōkō.” 字余り法則小考 [Research about the rule of Jiamari Lines]. Gobun Kenkyū 語文研究 1261: 18–32.Google Scholar
Tarlinskaja, Marina, and L. M. Teterina. (1974). Verse – prose – metre. Linguistics 1291. 63–86. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Tawara, Takumi 俵匠見. (2021). “Poetry Rhythm with Excess Syllables in Modern Tanka” 現代短歌の字余りとリズムについての考察. Proceedings of Language Resources Workshop 61: 2–14.Google Scholar
Wang, Li 王力. (1958). Hanyu shilüxue 漢語詩律學. [Study on Chinese poetic prosody]. Shanghai: Shanghai Education Publishing House.Google Scholar
. (2009). Shici gelü 詩詞格律 [Meter of Poetry]. Beijing: Zhonghua Shuju.Google Scholar
Xue, Ping. (1989). “Prosodic Constituents and the Tonal Structure of Chinese Regulated Verse.” Linguistic Inquiry 20(4): 688–696.Google Scholar
Yip, Moira J. (1980). The Tonal Phonology of Chinese, PhD diss., MIT, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Zhang, Hongming 張洪明. (1987a). “Hanyu jinti shi shenglü moshi de wuzhi jichu” 漢語近體詩聲律模式的物質基礎 [The Property of Tonal Prosody in Recent Style Poetry]. Social Sciences in China 41: 185–196.Google Scholar
. (1987b). “Yuyan de duibi yu shilü de bijiao” 語言的對比與詩律的比較 [A Comparison of Languages and Their Poetic Meters]. Fudan xuebao 復旦學報 41: 51–56.Google Scholar
. (2014). “Yunlü yinxixue yu hanyu yunlü yanjiu zhong de ruogan wenti” 韻律音系學與漢語韻律研究中的若干問題 [Some Issues on Prosodic Phonology and Chinese Prosodic Studies]. Dangdai Yuyanxue 當代語言學 31: 303–327.Google Scholar
Zhang, Hongming. (2015). “On the Origin of Chinese Tonal Prosody: Argumentation from a Case Study of Shen Yue’s Poems.” Journal of Chinese Literature and Culture 2 ( 2 ): 347–379. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
. (2017a). Syntax-Phonology Interface: Argumentation from Tone Sandhi in Chinese Dialects. London & New York, NY: Routledge.Google Scholar
. (2017b). E ASIAN 741 Chinese Syntax and Morphology. Sring 2017, University of Wisconsin-Madison. Class handout.Google Scholar
. (2018). E ASIAN 932 Seminar in Chinese Linguistics. Fall 2018, University of Wisconsin-Madison. Class handout.Google Scholar
Zhang, Hongming 張洪明. (2019). “Shiwen yinsong de kuayuyan liju” 詩文吟誦的跨語言理據 [Reciting and Chanting of Versification from a Cross-linguistic Perspective] In Shi, Zhongmou 施仲謀 and Liao Xian 廖先 (eds.), Langsong yu Langsong jiaoxue xintan 朗誦與朗誦教學新探 1–21, Hongkong: Shangwu Yinshuguan.Google Scholar
Zhang, Hongming 張洪明 and Li, Wenjing 李雯靜. (2011). “Yu Xin wuyan shi shenglü kaocha: erxiang jianyan zai hanyu shilü zhong de anli yanjiu“ 庾信五言詩聲律考察: 二項檢驗在漢語詩律中的案例研究 [The Tonal Prosody in Yu Xin’s Pentasyllabic Poems: the Application of the Binomial Test in a Case Study of Chinese Poetic Prosody]. Wenxue yu wenhua 41: 66–76.Google Scholar
Zhang, Hongming and Song, Chenqing. (2013). “Some Issues in the Study of Chinese Poetic Prosody.” Breaking Down the Barriers: Interdisciplinary Studies in Chinese Linguistics and Beyond (Special issue): 1149–1171.Google Scholar