Incels, in-groups, and ideologies
The representation of gendered social actors in a sexuality-based online community
We present a study of the online forum Reddit, specifically a sub-forum for (typically heterosexual) men who identify as
involuntary celibates or incels. Incels are an online imagined community/community of practice who wish
to, but do not, have sexual relations with women. Owing to this identity, they view themselves as non-normative within broader society and
see women and societal standards of masculinity as the cause of their problems. In this paper, we take a small corpus of 67,000 words
generated from 50 threads created, and commented on, by incels. We analyse keywords, word frequencies, and concordance lines to explore the
representation of gendered social actors. Keyword analysis reveals that references to gendered social actors are particularly salient within
this community, leading to an analysis of all such social actors in the corpus. The findings suggest that incels position different groups
of men in a hierarchy in which conventionally attractive men occupy the top position. Notably, we find that female social actors are not
placed in a similar hierarchy. An additional appraisal analysis of the most frequently occurring male and female social actors shows that
men are judged as incapacitated while women are seen as immoral, dishonest and capable of hurting men. Members of the online community also
seem preoccupied with physical attractiveness. The study opens up a number of avenues for future research, especially into the complexities
with which members of non-normative heterosexual groups simultaneously orient to and reject social norms.
Article outline
-
1.Introduction
- 2.Theoretical positioning and previous work
- 3.Data and methods
- 4.Analysis
- 4.1Keywords
- 4.2Word frequencies for gendered social actors
- 4.3Appraisal analysis of frequent gendered social actors
- 5.Discussion and conclusion
- Notes
-
References
References
Al-ghamdi, Hanan Ali Kabbas & Al-ghamdi, Azzah Ali Kabbas
2015 The role of virtual communities of practice in knowledge management using Web 2.0.
Procedia Computer Science 651: 406–411.
Anderson, Benedict
1983 Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism. London: Verso.
Baker, Paul
2004 Querying keywords: Questions of difference, frequency, and sense in keywords analysis.
Journal of English Linguistics 32(4): 346–359.
Baker, Paul
2011 Discourse and gender. In
The Bloomsbury Companion to Discourse Analysis,
Ken Hyland &
Brian Paltridge (eds), 199–212. London: Bloomsbury.
Baker, Paul
2012 Acceptable bias? Using corpus linguistics methods with critical discourse analysis.
Critical Discourse Studies 9(3): 247–256.
Baker, Paul
2014 Using Corpora to Analyze Gender. London: Bloomsbury
Banet-Weiser, Sarah & Miltner, Kate
2016 #MasculinitySoFragile: Culture, structure, and networked misogyny.
Feminist Media Studies 16(1): 171–174.
Braincels
2019 r/braincels.
Reddit.
[URL] (July 15, 2019)
Cameron, Deborah & Kulick, Don
2006 Heteronorms. In
The Language and Sexuality Reader,
Deborah Cameron &
Don Kulick (eds), 165–168. London: Routledge.
Coimbra-Gomes, Elvis & Motschenbacher, Heiko
2019 Language, normativity, and sexual orientation obsessive-compulsive disorder (SO-OCD): A corpus-assisted discourse analysis.
Language in Society 48(4): 565–584.
Davies, Mark
2008–onwards The Corpus of Contemporary American English (COCA): 560 million words, 1990-present.
[URL] (September 29, 2019)
Davies, Mark
2013 Corpus of News on the Web (NOW): 3+ Billion Words from 20 Countries, Updated Every Day.
[URL] (September 29, 2019)
Del-Teso-Craviotto, Marisol
2008 Gender and sexual identity authentication in language use: The case of chat rooms.
Discourse Studies 10(2): 251–270.
Eckert, Penelope & McConnell-Ginet, Sally
2007 Putting communities of practice in their place.
Gender & Language 1(1): 27–37.
Ging, Deborah
2017 Alphas, betas, and incels: Theorizing the masculinities of the manosphere.
Men and Masculinities 20(1): 1–20.
Hall, Kira, Levon, Erez & Milani, Tommaso
2019 Navigating normativities: Gender and sexuality in text and talk.
Language in Society 48(4): 481–489.
Hardaker, Claire & McGlashan, Mark
2016 “Real men don’t hate women”: Twitter rape threats and group identity.
Journal of Pragmatics 91(1): 80–93.
Hawtin, Abigail
2018 Construction of male and female identities in the ‘new misogyny’: A corpus-based discourse comparison of a misogynistic murderer’s manifesto and misogynistic online forums. (Paper presented at the 4th Corpora and Discourse International Conference, Lancaster University, Lancaster, UK).
Hinderliter, Andrew
2016 The evolution of online asexual discourse. (Unpublished) PhD thesis, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaigne.
[URL] (October 1, 2019)
Hughes, Jennifer
2018 The psychological validity of collocation: Evidence from event-related brain potentials. (Unpublished) PhD thesis, Lancaster University.
Incels.co.
2018 Introduction to incels.
[URL] (September 18, 2019)
Jaki, Sylvia, De Smedt, Tom, Gwóźdź, Maja, Panchal, Rudresh, Rossa, Alexander & De Pauw, Guy
King, Brian
2009 Building and analysing corpora of computer-mediated communication. In
Contemporary Corpus Linguistics,
Paul Baker (ed), 301–320. London: Continuum.
Koller, Veronika
2014 Cognitive linguistics and ideology. In
The Bloomsbury Companion to Cognitive Linguistics,
Jeanette Littlemore &
John R. Smith (eds), 234–252. London: Bloomsbury.
Koller, Veronika, McGlashan, Mark, Heritage, Frazer, Krendel, Alexandra & Aiston, Jessica
2019 MANTRaP: Misogyny online ANd The Red Pill. (Paper presented at the 12th BAAL LGaS SIG event: Intersections of language, gender and sexuality in media and technology, Birmingham City University, Birmingham, UK).
Krendel, Alexandra
2020 The men and women, guys and girls of the ‘manosphere’: A corpus-assisted discourse approach.
Discourse & Society 31(6): 607–630.
Lalor, Therese & Rendle-Short, Johanna
2007 ‘That’s so gay’: A contemporary use of ‘gay’ in Australian English.
Australian Journal of Linguistics 27(2): 147–173.
Lawson, Robert & McGlashan, Mark
2017 Discourses of neoliberal masculinity: A corpus-based discourse study of an online ‘Pick Up Artist’ community. (Paper presented at Language, Gender and Sexuality meeting, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, UK).
Martin, James & White, Peter
2005 The Language of Evaluation: Appraisal in English. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Milani, Tommaso M.
2013 Are ‘queers’ really ‘queer’? Language, identity and same-sex desire in a South African online community.
Discourse & Society 24(5): 615–633.
Motschenbacher, Heiko
2014 Focusing on normativity in language and sexuality studies: Insights from conversations on objectophilia.
Critical Discourse Studies 11(1): 49–70.
Myketiak, Chrystie
2015 The co-construction of cybersex narratives.
Discourse & Society 26(4): 464–479.
Potts, Amanda
2015 ‘LOVE YOU GUYS (NO HOMO)’: How gamers and fans play with sexuality, gender, and Minecraft on YouTube.
Critical Discourse Studies 12(2): 163–186.
Potts, Amanda & Baker, Paul
Rayson, Paul
2019 Log-likelihood and effect size calculator.
UCREL.
[URL] (September 18, 2019).
Russell, Eric
2019 The Discursive Ecology of Homophobia: Unraveling Anti-LGBTQ Speech on the European Far Right. Bristol: Encounters.
Scott, Micheal
2016 WordSmith Tools Manual, Version 7. Lexical Analysis Software Ltd.
Srinivasan, Amia
2018 Does anyone have the right to sex? The London Review of Books 40(6): 5–10.
Tranchese, Alessia
2019 Using corpus analysis to investigate ‘extreme’ Incel misogyny online. (Paper presented at 12th BAAL LGaS SIG Event: Intersections of Language, Gender and Sexuality in Media and Technology, Birmingham City University, Birmingham, UK).
van Dijk, Teun
1993 Principles of critical discourse analysis.
Discourse & Society 4(2): 249–283.
van Leeuwen, Theo
2008 Discourse and Practice: New Tools for Critical Discourse Analysis. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Wirth-Koliba, Victoria
2016 The diverse and dynamic world of’ ‘us’ and ‘them’ in political discourse.
Critical Approaches to Discourse Analysis Across Disciplines 8(1): 23–37.
Wodak, Ruth, De Cillia, Rudolph, Reisigl, Martin & Liebhart, Karin
2009 The Discursive Construction of National Identities (2nd edition). Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
Wright, David
2020 The discursive construction of resistance to sex in an online community.
Discourse, Context & Media 361: Article 100402.
Zappavigna, Michele
2018 Searchable Talk: Hashtags and Social Media Metadiscourse. London: Bloomsbury.
Zimmerman, Shannon, Ryan, Luisa & Duriesmith, David
2018 Recognizing the violent extremist ideology of ‘Incels.’ Women In International Security Policy Brief,
September (11), 1–4.
Cited by
Cited by 3 other publications
Heritage, Frazer
2021.
Corpus Approaches to Ludolinguistics. In
Language, Gender and Videogames,
► pp. 63 ff.
Jones, Lucy, Małgorzata Chałupnik, Jai Mackenzie & Louise Mullany
2022.
‘STFU and start listening to how scared we are’: Resisting misogny on Twitter via #NotAllMen.
Discourse, Context & Media ► pp. 100596 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 22 april 2022. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.