Cats and categories — reply to Teubert
This paper is a response to the discussion article in Language and Dialogue 3:2 by Wolfgang Teubert, “Was there a cat in the garden? Knowledge between discourse and the monadic self.” Teubert deals there with a number of themes, including a discussion of some philosophical issues raised by Roy Harris and Martin Heidegger. In my response, I am less concerned with those aspects of the article than with the claims made by Teubert about the contrasts between humans and other animals. I respond to Teubert’s position on the status and origins of categories of animals from a realist perspective, with reference to evidence from the natural sciences and anthropology. I suggest that Teubert’s thesis rests on a number of errors, including an over-estimation of the power of discourse, an under-estimation of the range of sensory and semiotic perception available to different kinds of creatures, and a lack of attention to contemporary developments in relevant ethological research.
References (69)
Adams, Mike. 2012. “Genius Female Chimpanzee Found to be Smarter than U.S. High School Students.” Natural News. [URL]. Accessed 13/12/13.
Anon. 2012. “Birds Smarter than Seven Year Old Kids: Study.” The Indian Express. [URL]. Accessed 13/12/13.
Atran, Scott, Douglas Medin, and Norbert Ross. 2004. “Evolution and Devolution of Knowledge: A Tale of Two Biologies.” Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 101: 395–420. 

Barbieri, Marcello. 2010. “On the Origin of Language: A Bridge between Biolinguistics and Biosemiotics.” Biosemiotics 31: 201–223. 

Bates, Lucy A., Katito N. Sayialel, Norah W. Njiraini, Cynthia J. Moss, Joyce H. Poole, and Richard W. Byrne. 2007. “Elephants Classify Human Ethnic Groups by Odor and Garment Color.” Current Biology 171: 1938–42. 

Berlin, Brent. 1973. “Folk Systematics in Relation to Biological Classification and Nomenclature.” Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 41: 259–271. 

Berlin, Brent, Dennis E. Breedlove, and Peter H. Raven. 1973. “General Principles of Classification and Nomenclature in Folk Biology.” American Anthropologist 751: 214–242. 

Bhaskar, Roy. 1997. “On the Ontological Status of Ideas.” Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour 271: 139–147. 

Boyle, Rebecca. 2010. “Bees Solve Hard Computing Problems Faster than Supercomputers.” Popular Science. [URL]. Accessed 13/12/13.
Boysen, Sarah T. 1997. “Representation of Quantities by Apes.” Advances in the Study of Behavior 261: 435–462. 

Bradshaw, J.W.S., G.F. Horsfield, J.A. Allen, and I.H. Robinson. 1999. “Feral Cats: Their Role in the Population Dynamics of Felis catus.” Applied Animal Behaviour Science 651: 273–283. 

Brown, Cecil H. 1983. Language and Living Things: Uniformities in Folk Classification and Naming. New Brunswick, N.J.: Rutgers University Press.
Christiansen, Morten H., and Simon Kirby (eds). 2003. Language Evolution. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 

Döring, Martin, Hermine Penz, and Wilhelm Trampe (eds). 2008. Language, Signs and Nature: Ecolinguistic Dimensions of Environmental Discourse. Túbingen: Stauffenberg Verlag.
Döring, Thomas F., and Lars Chittka. 2011. “How Human Are Insects, and Does It Matter?” Formosan Entomol 311: 85–99.
Dupré, John. 2001. “In Defence of Classification.” Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 321: 203–19. 

Dupré, John. 2012. Processes of Life. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Dupré, John, and Maureen A. O’Malley. 2007. “Metagenomics and Biological Ontology.” Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 381: 834–846. 

Durrell, Gerald. 2011. The Stationary Ark. Pan Macmillan.
Emery, Nathan J., and Nicola S. Clayton. 2004. “The Mentality of Crows: Convergent Evolution of Intelligence in Corvids and Apes.” Science 3061: 1903–1907. 

Frisch, Karl von. 2011. “Decoding the Language of the Bee.” In Readings in Zoosemiotics, ed. by Timo Maran, Dario Martinelli, and Aleksei Turovski, 141–155. Walter de Gruyter. 

Gluck, Jonathan. 2012. “NLP analysis of Folksonomies: An Examination of the Matukar Language.” In Swarthmore College Dept. Linguistics Senior Colloquiem.
Gould, James L. 1980. “Navigation by Honeybees.” In Genes, Cells, and Behavior, ed. by Norman H. Horovitz and Edward Jr. Hutchings, 135–141. San Francisco: W.H. Freeman.
Halliday, M.A.K. 2004. “Representing the Child as a Semiotic Being (One Who Means).” In Language, Education and Discourse: Functional Approaches, ed. by Joseph Foley, 19–42. London: Continuum.
Harley, Heidi E. 2013. “Consciousness in Dolphins? A Review of Recent Evidence.” Journal of Comparative Physiology 1991: 565–582. 

Hauser, Marc D. 1997. “Artifactual Kinds and Functional Design Features: What a Primate Understands without Language.” Cognition 641: 285–308. 

Hauser, Marc D. 2000. “What Do Animals Think About Numbers?” American Scientist 881: 144–151. 

Herzog, Hal. 2010. Some We Love, Some We Hate, Some We Eat: Why It’s So Hard to Think Straight about Animals. Harper Perennial.
Hoffmeyer, Jesper. 2008. “Semiotic Scaffolding of Living Systems.” In Introduction to Biosemiotics, ed. by Marcello Barbieri, 149–166. Dordrecht: Springer.
Hubrecht, Robert, and Anthony C. Buckwell. 2007. “The Welfare of lLboratory Dogs.” In The Welfare of Laboratory Animals, ed. by Eila Kaliste, 245–273. Dordrecht: Springer. 

Ingold, Tim (ed.). 1988. What is an Animal. Unwin Hyman.
Kammoun, H.M., I. Kallel, A.M. Alimi, and J. Casillas. 2010. “An Adaptive Vehicle Guidance System Instigated from Ant Colony Behavior.” In IEEE Systems Man and Cybernetics, 2948-2955. Istanbul.
Layder, Derek. 2004. Emotion in Social Life. London.
Lyn, Heidi. 2007. “Mental Representation of Symbols as Revealed by Vocabulary Errors in Two Bonobos (Pan paniscus).” Animal Cognition 101: 461–475. 

Lyn, Heidi, Patricia M. Greenfield, Sue Savage-Rumbaugh, Kristen Gillespie-Lynch, and William D. Hopkins. 2011. “Nonhuman Primates Do Declare! A Comparison of Declarative Symbol and Gesture use in Two Children, Two Bonobos, and a Chimpanzee.” Language & Communication 311: 63–74. 

Maran, Timo, Dario Martinelli, and Aleksei Turovski. 2011. “Readings in Zoosemiotics.” In Readings in Zoosemiotics, ed. by Timo Maran, Dario Martinelli, and Aleksei Turovski, 1–20. Berlin and Boston: Walter de Gruyter. 

Matsuzawa, Tetsuro. 2010. “The Chimpanzee Mind: Bridging Fieldwork and Laboratory Work.” In The Mind of the Chimpanzee: Ecological and Experimental Perspectives, ed. by Elizabeth V. Lonsdorf, Stephen R. Ross, and Tetsuro Matsuzawa, 1–22. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
McAnulla, Stuart. 2006. “Challenging the New Interpretivist Approach: Towards a Critical Realist Alternative.” British Politics 11: 113–38. 

Munz, Tania. 2005. “The Bee Battles: Karl von Frisch, Adrian Wenner and the Honey Bee Dance Language Controversy.” Journal of the History of Biology 381: 535–570. 

Nagel, Thomas. 1974. “What is it Like to Be a Bat?” The Philosophical Review 831: 435–450. 

Oliveira, Rita, Raquel Godinho, Ettore Randi, Nuno Ferrand, and Paulo Célio Alves. 2008. “Molecular Analysis of Hybridisation between Wild and Domestic Cats (Felis silvestris) in Portugal: Implications for Conservation.” Conservation Genetics 91: 1–11. 

Owren, Michael J., and Drew Rendall. 2001. “Sound on the Rebound: Bringing Form and Function back to the Forefront in Understanding Nonhuman Primate Vocal Signaling.” Evolutionary Anthropology 101: 58–71. 

Pack, Adam A. 2010. “The Synergy of Laboratory and Field Studies of Dolphin Behavior and Cognition.” International Journal of Comparative Psychology 231: 538–565.
Painter, Clare. 2009. “Language Development.” In Continuum Companion to Systemic Functional Linguistics, ed. by M.A.K. Halliday, and Jonathan J. Webster, 87–103. New York: Continuum.
Pepperberg, Irene M. 2002. “In Search of King Solomon’s Ring: Cognitive and Communicative Studies of Grey Parrots (Psittacus erithacus).” Brain Behavior and Evolution 591: 54–67. 

Povinelli, Daniel J., Jesse M. Bering, and Steve Giambrone. 2000. “Toward a Science of Other Minds: Escaping the Argument by Analogy.” Cognitive Science 241: 509–541. 

Rendall, Drew. 2013. “Q&A: Cognitive Ethology - Inside the Minds of Other Species.” BMC Biology 111: 1–5. 

Rendall, Drew, Michael J. Owren, and Michael J. Ryan. 2009. “What Do Animal Signals Mean?” Animal Behaviour 781: 233–40. 

Rumbaugh, Duane M., William D. Hopkins, David A. Washburn, and E. Sue Savage-Rumbaugh. 2013. “Comparative Perspectives of Brain, Cognition, and Language.” In Biological and Behavioral Determinants of Language Development, ed. by Norman A. Krasnegor, Duane M. Rumbaugh, Richard L. Schiefelbusch, and Michael Studdert-Kennedy. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Sagan, Dorion. 2010. “Umwelt after Uexküll.” In Foray into the Worlds of Animals and Humans: With a Theory of Meaning, ed. by Jakob von Uexküll, 1–34. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Santos, Laurie R., Cory T. Miller, and Marc D. Hauser. 2003. “Representing Tools: How Two Non-Human Primate Species Distinguish between the Functionally Relevant and Irrelevant Features of a Tool.” Animal Cognition 61: 269–281. 

Savage-Rumbaugh, Sue, William Mintz Fields, and Jared Taglialatela. 2000. “Ape Consciousness-Human Consciousness: A Perspective Informed by Language and Culture.” American Zoology 401: 910–921. 

Schino, Gabriele. 2001. “Grooming, Competition and Social Rank among Female Primates: A Meta-Analysis.” Animal Behaviour 621: 265–271. 

Sealey, Alison, and Lee Oakley. 2014. “Why Did the Canada Goose Cross the Sea? Accounting for the Behaviour of Wildlife in the Documentary Series Life.” International Journal of Applied Linguistics 241: 19–37. 

Sealey, Alison, and Lee Oakley. 2013. “Anthropomorphic Grammar? Some Linguistic Patterns in the Wildlife Documentary Series Life.” Text and Talk 331: 399–420. 

Segerdahl, Par. 2012. “Humanising Non-Humans: Ape Language Research as Critique of Metaphysics.” In Language, Ethics and Animal Life: Wittgenstein and Beyond, ed. by Niklas Forsberg, Mikel Burley, and Nora Hamalainen, 16–31. A&C Black.
Segerdahl, Par, William Fields, and Sue Savage-Rumbaugh. 2005. Kanzi’s Primal Language. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan. 

Seyfarth, Robert M., and Dorothy L. Cheney. 1980. “The Ontogeny of Vervet Monkey Alarm Calling Behavior: A Preliminary Report.” Ethology 541: 37–56.
Spelke, Elizabeth S., and Katherine D. Kinzler. 2007. “Core Knowledge.” Developmental Science 101: 89–96. 

Srinivasan, Mandyam V. 2010. “Honeybee Communication: A Signal for Danger.” Current Biology 201: 366–368. 

Sterelny, Kim. 2004. “Externalism Epistemic Artefacts and the Extended Mind.” In Current Issues in Theoretical Philosophy Vol. 2: The Externalist Challenge, ed. by Richard Schantz, 239–254. Walter de Gruyter.
Teng, Santani, Amrita Puri, and David Whitney. 2012. “Ultrafine Spatial Acuity of Blind Expert Human Echolocators.” Experimental Brain Research 2161: 483–488. 

The Telegraph. no date. “Counting Monkeys”. [URL]. Accessed 12/12/13.
Thibault, Paul J. 2009. “Language and Other Primate Species: Part 2.” In Continuum Companion to Systemic Functional Linguistics, ed. by M.A.K. Halliday, and Jonathan Webster, 107–112. London: Continuum.
Tiddi, B., F. Aureli, and G. Schino. 2012. “Grooming up the Hierarchy: The Exchange of Grooming and Rank-Related Benefits in a New World Primate.” PLoS ONE 71. 

Vaughan, Richard T., Kasper Støy, Gaurav S. Sukhatme, and Maja J. Matarić. 2000. “Blazing a Trail: Insect-Inspired Resource Transportation by a Robot Team.” In Distributed Autonomous Robotic Systems 4, ed. by Lynne E. Parker, George Bekey, and Jacob Barhen, 111–120. Japan DA: Springer. 

von Uexküll, Jakob. 2010 [1934]. Foray into the Worlds of Animals and Humans: With a Theory of Meaning. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Wenner, Adrian M. no date. “Read Me First – A Chronology.” [URL]. Accessed 13/12/13.
Yamaguchi, Nobuyuki, Carlos A. Driscoll, Andrew C. Kitchener, Jennifer M. Ward, and David W. Macdonald. 2004. “Craniological Differentiation between European Wildcats (Felis silvestris silvestris), African Wildcats (F. s. lybica) and Asian Wildcats (F. s. ornata): Implications for their Evolution and Conservation.” Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 831: 47–63. 

Cited by (3)
Cited by three other publications
Sealey, Alison
2018.
Being an English academic: a social domains account.
Language and Intercultural Communication 18:5
► pp. 549 ff.

Sealey, Alison & Chris Pak
2018.
First catch your corpus: methodological challenges in constructing a thematic corpus.
Corpora 13:2
► pp. 229 ff.

This list is based on CrossRef data as of 5 july 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.