“Do you condemn?”
Negotiating power relations through (in)direct questions and answers design
in ethno-political interviews
This chapter discusses a specific type of interactional ritual in ethno-political
interviews, one that hinders their conciliatory potential. The ritual is performed
by two types of participants: Jewish-Israeli interviewers demanding the condemnation
of transgressions committed by others, and the respective response by Arab-Israeli
political representatives in the role of interviewees. Negotiation over
condemnations is examined, as this speech act is considered crucial to setting up
models for civic behavior. The chapter demonstrates how interviewers’ efforts to
exercise interactional and social power through pushing their interviewees to adopt
a consensual stance are rejected by resorting to indirect answer designs. It
concludes by discussing the extent to which “do you condemn” questions may be
perceived as a legitimate professional journalistic practice.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Political condemnations and moral scripts
- 3.Calls to condemn as rituals of loyalty in political interviews
- 4.Interviewers’ self-positioning through a “do you condemn” question
- 5.Interviewees’ responses to “Do you condemn” questions
- Direct refusal to condemn
- Direct agreement to condemn
- “I don’t want to be seen as someone who came here today to justify
anything”: Overt resistance to answering
- “I wouldn’t do it”: Shifting from the general to the personal
- “I express my deep condolences”: Replacing condemnation with a different speech act
- “We have already condemned”: Referring to previous action
- “I oppose violence but the real violence is the occupation”: Shifting the blame
- 6.Conclusion
-
Acknowledgments
-
Note
-
References
References
Al-Haj, Majid
2000 “
Identity
and Orientation among Israeli Arabs: A Situation of Double
Periphery.” In
The
Jewish-Arab Rift in Israel: A Reader, ed.
by
Ruth Gavison, and
Dafna Hacker, 13–33. Jerusalem, Israel: The Israel Democracy Institute.
Antaki., Charles
1994 Explaining
and Arguing: The Social Organization of
Accounts. London: Sage.
Austin, John L.
1975 How
to Do Things with Words, 2nd
edition. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Bavelas, Janet Beavin, Alex Black, Nicole Chovil, and Jennifer Mullett
1990 Equivocal
Communication. London: Sage.
Benoit, William L.
1995 Accounts,
Excuses, and Apologies: A Theory of Image Restoration
Strategies. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.
Blum-Kulka, Shoshana
1983 “
The
Dynamics of Political
Interviews.”
Text 3 (2): 131–153.
Blum-Kulka, Shoshana, and Elda Weizman
2003 “
Misunderstandings
in Political
Interviews.” In
Misunderstanding
in Social Life: Discourse Approaches to Problematic
Talk, ed. by
Juliane House,
Gabriele Kasper, and
Steven Ross, 107–128. London: Routledge.
Blum-Kulka, Shoshana, Zohar Kampf, and Tamar Liebes
2003 “
‘Talking
with the Enemy?’: Interviews with Palestinians during the Second
Intifada.” In
Lamed le
ILASH [
Studies in modern
Hebrew], ed. by
Shlesinger Yitzchak, and
Malka Muchnik, 61–77. Jerusalem: Tzivonim Publishing (in Hebrew).
Bull, Peter
1998 “
Equivocation
Theory and News Interviews.”
Journal of Language
and Social
Psychology 17 (1): 36–51.
Butler, Judith
2005 Giving
an Account of Oneself. New York: Fordham University Press.
Chouliaraki, Lilie
2000 “
Political
Discourse in the News: Democratizing Responsibility or Aestheticizing
Politics?”
Discourse and
Society 11 (3): 293–314.
Clayman, Steven E.
1992 “
Footing
in the Achievement of Neutrality: The Case of News Interview
Discourse.” In
Talk at
Work: Interaction in Institutional Settings, ed.
by
Paul Drew, and
John Heritage, 163–198. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Clayman, Steven E.
1995 “
Defining
Moments, Presidential Debates, and the Dynamics of
Quotability.”
Journal of
Communication 45 (3): 118–147.
Clayman, Steven E.
2015 “
Broadcast
News
Interviews.” In
The
International Encyclopedia of Language and Social
Interaction, ed. by
Karen Tracy,
Cornelia Ilie, and
Todd Sandel. Hobeken, NJ: Wiley and Sons.
.
Clayman, Steven, and John Heritage
2002a The
News Interview: Journalists and Public Figures on the
Air. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Clayman, Steven. E., and John Heritage
2002b “
Questioning
Presidents: Journalistic Deference and Adversarialness in the Press Conferences
of US Presidents Eisenhower and Reagan.”
Journal
of
Communication 52 (4): 749–775.
Ekström, Mats
2001 “
Politicians
Interviewed on Television News.”
Discourse and
Society 12 (5): 563–584.
Ekström, Mats
2009 “
Announced
Refusal to Answer: A Study of Norms and Accountability in Broadcast Political
Interviews.”
Discourse
Studies 11 (6): 681–702.
Fetzer, Anita, Elda Weizman, and Lawrence N. Berlin
Goffman, Erving
1974 Frame
Analysis: An Essay on the Organization of
Experience. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Grice, Herbert P.
1975 “
Logic
and
Conversation.” In
Syntax
and Semantics, vol. 3. Speech Acts, ed.
by
Peter Cole, and
Jerry L. Morgan, 41–58. New York: Academic Press.
Hallin, Daniel C.
1986 The
Uncensored War: The Media and Vietnam. Los Angeles: University of California Press.
Harré, Rom, and Fathali M. Moghaddam
(eds.) 2003 The
Self and Others: Positioning Individuals and Groups in Personal, Political, and
Cultural Contexts. Westport, CT: Greenwood.
Harris, Sandra
1991 “
Evasive
Action: How Politicians Respond to Questions in Political
Interviews.” In
Broadcast
Talk, ed. by
P. Scannell, 76–100. London: Sage.
Hauser, Gerard A.
1999 “
Aristotle
on Epideictic: The Formation of Public
Morality.”
Rhetoric Society
Quarterly 29 (1): 5–23.
Heritage, John
2002 “
The
Limits of Questioning: Negative Interrogatives and Hostile Question
Content.”
Journal of
Pragmatics 34 (10-11): 1427–1446.
Johnstone, Barbara
1986 “
Arguments
with Khomeini: Rhetorical Situation and Persuasive Style in Cross-Cultural
Perspective.”
Text 6 (2): 171–188.
Kampf, Zohar
2009 “
Public
(Non-) Apologies: The Discourse of Minimizing
Responsibility.”
Journal of
Pragmatics 41 (11): 2257–2270.
Kampf, Zohar
2011 “
Journalists
as Actors in Social Dramas of
Apology.”
Journalism 12 (1): 71–87.
Kampf, Zohar
2013 “
Mediated
Performatives.” In
Handbook
of Pragmatics, ed. by
Jef Verschueren, and
Jan-Ola Östman, 1–24. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Kampf, Zohar, and Efrat Daskal
2013 “
Too
Hostile, Too Deferential: Processes of Media Answerability Following Political
Interviews.”
Journalism 14 (4): 522–540.
Kampf, Zohar, and Tamar Katriel
2016 “
Political
Condemnations: Public Speech Acts and the Moralization of
Discourse.” In
The
Handbook of Communication in Cross-Cultural
Perspective, ed. by
Donal Carbaugh, 312–336. New York: Routledge.
Keenan, Thomas
2004 “
Mobilizing
Shame.”
The South Atlantic
Quarterly 103 (2/3): 435–449.
Lakoff, Robin T.
2001 “
Nine
Ways of Looking at Apologies: The Necessity for Interdisciplinary Theory and
Method in Discourse
Analysis.” In
Handbook
of Discourse Analysis, ed. by
Deborah Schiffrin,
Deborah Tannen, and
Heidi Hamilton, 199–214. London: Blackwell.
Lazersfeld, Paul F., and Robert K. Merton
1948 “
Mass
Communication, Popular Taste and Organized Social
Action.” In
The
Communication of Ideas, ed. by
B. Lyman, 95–118. New York: Harper.
Liebes, Tamar, Zohar Kampf, and Shoshana Blum-Kulka
2008 “
Saddam
on CBS and Arafat on IBA: Interviewing the Enemy on
Television.”
Political
Communication 25 (3): 311–329.
.
Meyrowitz, Joshua
1985 No
Sense of Place. The Impact of Electronic Media on Social
Behavior. New York: Oxford University Press.
Montgomery, Martin
2007 The
Discourse of Broadcast
News. London: Routledge.
Rosenberg, Hananel, and Ifat Maoz
2012 “
‘Meeting
the Enemy’: The Reception of a Television Interview with a Female Palestinian
Terrorist among Jewish Youth in Israel.”
The
Communication
Review 15 (1): 45–71.
Scannell, Paddy
1991 Broadcast
Talk. London: Sage.
Schudson, Michael
2002 “
What’s
Unusual about Covering Politics as
Usual.” In
Journalism
After September 11, ed. by
Barbie Zelizer, and
Stuart Allan, 36–47. New York: Routledge.
Searle, John R.
1976 “
A
Classification of Illocutionary Acts.”
Language
in
Society 5 (1): 1–23.
Weizman, Elda
1996 “
Shifting
Roles: A Challenge Strategy in News Interviews on Israeli
Television.” In
Hadassah
Kantor Jubilee Book: Language Research Papers, ed.
by
Ora Schwarzwald, and
Yitzchak Shlezinger, 85–95. Ramat Gan, Israel: Bar Ilan Press. (in
Hebrew).
Weizman, Elda
2006 “
Roles
and Identities in News Interviews: The Israeli
Context.”
Journal of
Pragmatics 38 (2): 154–179.
Weizman, Elda, Irit Levi, and Isaac Schneebaum
Yiftachel, Oren
2006 Ethnocracy:
Land and Identity Politics in
Israel/Palestine. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
Cited by
Cited by 1 other publications
Weizman, Elda & Zohar Livnat
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 27 march 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.