US voter rights in translation
Semantic shifts in Spanish renderings of “felony”
Felons’ voting rights have featured prominently in debates over voter suppression in the
United States, particularly in Florida, where a 2018 state constitutional amendment reinstated voting rights to the
state’s 1.4 million former felons (
Robles 2018). Florida also has a high concentration of
Spanish-speaking voters with Limited English Proficiency (LEP), making Spanish-language voting information crucial. Inadequate translations
of voter information may misrepresent voter eligibility for LEP Spanish-speaking former felons in Florida. Using a parallel corpus, this
article’s central research question investigates how semantic shifts occur in Spanish translations of “felony” and “felon” in online voter
information for seven Florida counties. The results reveal a number of misrepresentative semantic shifts in both human- and
machine-translated Spanish voter information. Such shifts may impinge on individuals’ constitutional rights.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Related work
- 3.Methods
- 3.1Text selection
- 3.2Corpus compilation
- 3.3Corpus analysis
- 4.Legal comparative analysis of potential renderings
- 5.Results
- 5.1Semantic shifts by term and county
- 5.2Semantic shifts in human vs. machine translation
- 6.Discussion
- 7.Conclusion
- Notes
-
References
-
Legislation
References (65)
References
Abrajano, Marisa, and Costas Panagopoulos. 2011. “Does
Language Matter? The Impact of Spanish Versus English-Language GOTV Efforts on Latino Turnout.” American
Politics
Research 39 (4): 643–63. 

Alvarez, Norma L., and M Catherine McCabe. n.d. “Georgia
Administrative Office of the Courts English-Spanish Glossary.” National Center for State Courts. Accessed June 28,
2022. [URL]
Becerra, Javier F. 2022. Legal Dictionary
English-Spanish. Accessed June 28,
2022. [URL]
Behrens, Angela, Christopher Uggen, and Jeff Manza. 2003. “Ballot
Manipulation and the ‘Menace of Negro Domination’: Racial Threat and Felon Disenfranchisement in the United States,
1850–2002.” American Journal of
Sociology 109 (3): 559–605. 

Bentele, Keith G., and Erin E. O’Brien. 2013. “Jim
Crow 2.0? Why States Consider and Adopt Restrictive Voter Access Policies.” Perspectives on
Politics 11 (4): 1088–1116. 

Bergad, Laird. 2018. “The
2018 Mid-Term Election: Estimated Voter Participation Rates by Race and Age in Arizona, Florida, Georgia and
Texas.” New York: Center for Latin American, Caribbean, and Latino Studies at the CUNY Graduate Center. Accessed June 28, 2022. [URL]
Biber, Douglas. 1993. “Representativeness
in Corpus Design.” Literary and Linguistic
Computing 8 (4): 243–57. 

Biel, Łucja. 2018. “Corpora
in Institutional Legal Translation: Small Steps and the Big
Picture.” In Institutional Translation for International Governance: Enhancing
Quality in Multilingual Legal Communication, edited by Fernando Prieto Ramos, 25–36. London: Bloomsbury Publishing.
Bowker, Lynne, and Jennifer Pearson. 2002. Working
with Specialized Language: A Practical Guide to Using
Corpora. London: Routledge. 

Burmila, Edward M. 2017. “Voter Turnout, Felon Disenfranchisement and
Partisan Outcomes in Presidential Elections, 1988–2012.” Social Justice
Research 30 (1): 72–88. 

Epperly, Brad, Christopher Witko, Ryan Strickler, and Paul White. 2020. “Rule
by Violence, Rule by Law: Lynching, Jim Crow, and the Continuing Evolution of Voter Suppression in the
U.S.” Perspectives on
Politics 18 (3): 756–69. 

Flood, Sarah, Miriam King, Renae Rodgers, Steven Ruggles, and J. Robert Warren. 2020. “Immigrants
in Florida.” Washington DC: American Immigration Council. 

Florida Division of
Elections. 2021. “Constitutional Amendment 4/Felon Voting Rights – Division of
Elections – Florida Department of State.” Florida Department of State. Accessed June 28,
2021. [URL]
Gallegos, Cuauhtémoc. 2014. Bilingual
Criminal Law Dictionary. Bellingham: Merl Publications.
Gonzalez, Carol. 2019. “Is
the Rising Trend of Voter Restoration Leading to Permanent Disenfranchisement of Felons? Florida Joins the Voter Restoration
Trend.” Nova Law
Review 44 (2): 195–224.
Goux, Darshan J., and David A. Hopkins. 2008. “The
Empirical Implications of Electoral College Reform.” American Politics
Research 36 (6): 857–79. 

Groot, Gerard-René de, and Conrad J. P. van Laer. 2006. “The
Dubious Quality of Legal Dictionaries.” International Journal of Legal
Information 34 (1): 65–86. 

Gutman, David. 2016a. “Green
Party: Inexact Translation in State’s Spanish Voter Pamphlet Amounts to Voter Suppression.” The Seattle
Times, October 27, 2016, sec. Local Politics.
Accessed June 28, 2022. [URL]
Gutman, David. 2016b. “Wyman
to Clarify Info in Spanish Voter Pamphlet after Dems Threaten Suit.” The Seattle
Times, October 31, 2016, sec. Local Politics.
Accessed June 28, 2022. [URL]
Hajnal, Zoltan, Nazita Lajevardi, and Lindsay Nielson. 2017. “Voter
Identification Laws and the Suppression of Minority Votes.” The Journal of
Politics 79 (2): 363–79. 

Hopkins, Daniel J. 2011. “Translating into Votes: The Electoral
Impacts of Spanish-Language Ballots.” American Journal of Political
Science 55 (4): 814–30. 

Killman, Jeffrey. 2014. “Vocabulary
Accuracy of Statistical Machine Translation in the Legal Context.” In Proceedings
of the 11th Conference of the Association for Machine Translation in the
Americas, 85–98. Vancouver, Canada: Association for Machine Translation in the Americas. [URL]
Killman, Jeffrey. 2021. “Translation
in the Shadows of Interpreting in US Court Systems: Standards, Guidelines and
Practice.” In Institutional Translation and Interpreting: Assessing Practices and
Managing for Quality, edited by Fernando Prieto Ramos, 62–83. New York: Routledge.
Laguarda, Ignacio. 2018. “Voting
Info in Spanish Often Lost in
Translation.” WhoWhatWhy. May 17, 2018. Accessed June 28, 2022. [URL]
[URL]. 2015. “2015 Language Map App Accessible
Version.” [URL]. 2015. Accessed June 28,
2022. [URL]
LF Aligner. Version 4.21. [URL]
Lombardi, John. n.d. “Glossary
of Legal Terminology – English to Spanish.” Connecticut: State of Connecticut Judicial Branch Superior
Court Operations Division. Accessed June 28,
2022. [URL]
McCahon, David S. 2016. “Combating Misinformation in the Ex-Felon
Population: The Role Probation and Parole Agencies Can Play to Facilitate Civic Reintegration in the United
States.” Probation
Journal 63 (1): 9–22. 

Mellinger, Christopher D. 2017. “Equal Access to the Courts in Translation:
A Corpus-Driven Study on Translation Shifts in Waivers of
Counsel.” Perspectives 25 (2): 308–22. 

Morín, Jason L., Yoshira Macías Mejía, and Gabriel R. Sanchez. 2021. “Is
the Bridge Broken? Increasing Ethnic Attachments and Declining Party Influence among Latino
Voters.” Political Research
Quarterly 74 (1): 182–98. 

Morse, Michael. 2021. “The
Future of Felon Disenfranchisement Reform: Evidence from the Campaign to Restore Voting Rights in Florida Democracy Reform
Symposium.” California Law
Review 109 (3): 1143–98.
Munday, Jeremy. 1998. “A
Computer-Assisted Approach to the Analysis of Translation Shifts.” Meta: Translators’
Journal 43 (4): 542–56. 

Nunes Vieira, Lucas, Minako O’Hagan, and Carol O’Sullivan. 2020. “Understanding
the Societal Impacts of Machine Translation: A Critical Review of the Literature on Medical and Legal Use
Cases.” Information, Communication &
Society 24 (11): 1–18. 

Parkin, Michael, and Frances Zlotnick. 2011. “English
Proficiency and Latino Participation in U.S. Elections.” Politics &
Policy 39 (4): 515–37. 

Pettit, Becky, and Carmen Gutierrez. 2018. “Mass
Incarceration and Racial Inequality.” The American Journal of Economics and
Sociology 77 (3–4): 1153–82. 

Porter, Nicole. 2020. “Voting
in Jails.” Washington, DC: The Sentencing Project. Accessed June 28,
2022. [URL]
Prieto Ramos, Fernando. 2021. “Translating
Legal Terminology and Phraseology: Between Inter-Systemic Incongruity and Multilingual
Harmonization.” Perspectives 29 (2): 175–83. 

Robles, Frances. 2018. “1.4
Million Floridians With Felonies Win Long-Denied Right to Vote.” New York
Times, November 7, 2018. Accessed June 28, 2022. [URL]
Šarčević, Susan. 2012. “Challenges
to the Legal Translator.” In The Oxford Handbook of Language and
Law, edited by Peter Meijes Tiersma, Peter Tiersma, and Lawrence Solan, 187–99. New York: Oxford University Press.
Schmid, Carol L. 2001. The Politics of Language: Conflict, Identity, and
Cultural Pluralism in Comparative Perspective. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Sesin, Carmen. 2021. “Settlement
Reached in Lawsuit over Lack of Spanish-Language Voting Materials in Florida Counties.” NBC
News, February 1, 2021. Accessed June 28, 2022. [URL]
Sinclair, John. 2005. “Corpus
and Text – Basic Principles.” In Developing Linguistic Corpora: A Guide to Good
Practice, edited by Martin Wynne, 1–16. Oxford: Oxbow Books.
Sketch Engine. 2021. [URL]
Tein, Joseph. 2008. “Glossary
of Legal Terms (English–Spanish).” Edited by Claudia A’Zar and Kenneth Barger. Washington Courts Administrative Office of the Courts. Accessed June 28, 2022. [URL]
Tomasi, Sandro. 2012. Tomasi’s
Law Dictionary. 2nd ed. New York: BilingualLawDictionary.com.
United States. United States House of Representatives. 48 U.S. Code §
734 – United States laws extended to Puerto Rico; internal revenue receipts covered into
treasury. Adopted 2 March
1917. Modified 1 August
1955. Accessed 28 June
2022. [URL]
US Election Assistance
Commission. 2007. “Glossary of Key Election Terminology in English to
Spanish.” Accessed June 28,
2022. [URL]
Veera Institute of
Justice. 2007. “Translating Justice: A Spanish Glossary for New York
City.” [URL]. Accessed June 28,
2022. [URL]
Legislation
LexisNexis. 2022. “Leyes de Puerto Rico sin
anotación.” LexisNexis. Accessed 28 June 2022. [URL]
LexisNexis. 2022. “Laws of Puerto Rico
without annotation.” LexisNexis. Accessed 28 June 2022. [URL]
Puerto Rico. Asamblea Legislativa de Puerto
Rico. 4 L.P.R.A. § 536. Definiciones. Adopted 9 September 2004. Modified 2 February 2015.
Puerto Rico. Asamblea Legislativa de Puerto
Rico. 4 L.P.R.A. § 536. Definitions. Adopted 9 September 2004. Modified 14 December 2011.
Puerto Rico. Asamblea Legislativa de Puerto
Rico. 4 L.P.R.A. § 663. Estadísticas judiciales; delitos graves, menos graves, y
otros. Adopted 11 March
1909.
Puerto Rico. Asamblea Legislativa de Puerto
Rico. 4 L.P.R.A. § 663. Judicial statistics; felonies, misdemeanors,
etc. Adopted 11 March
1909.
Puerto Rico. Asamblea Legislativa de Puerto
Rico. 34 L.P.R.A. § 1042. Sentencias suspendidas en delitos graves y en ciertos delitos menos graves cuando
el convicto es menor de 21 años de edad. Adopted 29
June 1955. Modified 17 January
1995.
Puerto Rico. Asamblea Legislativa de Puerto
Rico. 34 L.P.R.A. § 1042. Suspended sentences in felony cases and certain cases of misdemeanor when
defendant is under 21 years old. Adopted 29 June
1955. Modified 17 January
1995.
Puerto Rico. Asamblea Legislativa de Puerto
Rico. 34 L.P.R.A. § 1735c. Elegibilidad para
servir. Adopted 27 September
2003.
Puerto Rico. Asamblea Legislativa de Puerto
Rico. 34 L.P.R.A. § 1735c. Eligibility to
serve. Adopted 27 September
2003.
Puerto Rico. Asamblea Legislativa de Puerto
Rico. 34 L.P.R.A. § 1757. Procedimiento sobre arresto por
delito. Adopted 1935.
Puerto Rico. Asamblea Legislativa de Puerto
Rico. 34 L.P.R.A. § 1757. Procedure on commitment for criminal
offense. Adopted 1935.
Puerto Rico. Asamblea Legislativa de Puerto
Rico. 34A L.P.R.A. Ap. II, Regla 146. Jurado; veredicto; forma.
Puerto Rico. Asamblea Legislativa de Puerto
Rico. 34A L.P.R.A. App. II, Rule 146. Jury; verdict; form.
Cited by (1)
Cited by one other publication
Mellinger, Christopher D., Teresa C. Salazar & Aimee K. Benavides
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 5 july 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.