The metalinguistic development of the term ‘periphrasis’ in the western grammatical tradition from Antiquity
to the Enlightenment
BeatriceGrieco and EdoardoNardi
Sapienza Università di Roma | Università degli Studi di Palermo
In 1993, Hoffmann published a study on the historical development of the term ‘periphrasis’ in grammars, which
originally indicated a figure of speech, used for stylistic and rhetorical purposes. To date, Hoffmann’s article remains the only
contribution to the question. In this paper, we further investigate the history of the morphosyntactic category of ‘periphrasis’,
with special attention to practical grammars, which are not discussed by Hoffmann. The analysis of grammars dating from Antiquity
to the Enlightenment confirms Hoffmann’s findings with additional data, and sheds new light on the metalinguistic development of
the morphosyntactic category of ‘periphrasis’ over the centuries. From the late 15th to the 18th century, grammars, especially
practical, of many European and non-European languages attest a notable terminological richness to indicate analytic
constructions, understood as morphosyntactic categories (comparative and superlative, compound tenses). These grammars feature not
only periphrasis and circumlocutio, which are already found in the earlier tradition, but also
the verb related to the latter, circumloquor, circumscribo, and language-specific expressions,
such as rodeo in Spanish and Portuguese, and tour in French. Despite the development and
persistence of the grammatical connotation of periphrasis and analogous terms, ‘periphrasis’ also retains its
original rhetorical usage throughout the Modern Age.
Today, the word ‘periphrasis’ (from Greek περίφρασις ‘circumlocution’) has two main meanings — or, rather, nuances — which
bear different connotations (Haspelmath 2000: 654–655). In a loose, non-technical sense,
‘periphrasis’ refers to a multi-word expression used in place of a single word or a shorter phrase. Besides, periphrasis is also
counted among the canonical literary rhetorical figures (Lausberg 1963 [1949]: 69),
consisting in a roundabout expression used for poetic or rhetorical purposes. However, it can be difficult to make a clear-cut
distinction between these two usages.
Primary Bibliography
Adelung, Johann
C.
1798Grammatica theodisca scholis
conscripta. Latine versa a Frederico Gottlob
Born. Leipzig: Schwickert.
Albertus, Laurentius
1573Teutsch
Grammatick oder
Sprachkunst. Augsburg: Manger.
Anchieta
de, José
1595Arte
de grammatica da lingoa mais usada na costa do
Brasil. Coimbra: Antonio de
Mariz.
Arnauld, Antoine & Claude Lancelot
1660Grammaire
générale et raisonnée. Paris: Le
Petit.
Barros
de, João
1540Grammatica
da lingua
portuguesa. Lisboa: Rotorigius.
Barwick, Carolus
ed.1964Charisii
Artis Grammaticae Libri
V. Leipzig: Teubner.
Basnage, Jacques
1716Histoire
des Juifs, depuis Jésus-Christ jusqu’à présent. Pour servir de continuation à l’Histoire de Joseph. Nouvelle édition
augmentée. Tome sixieme, seconde partie. La
Haye: Scheurleer.
Beauzée, Nicolas
1767Grammaire
Générale, ou Exposition raisonnée des éléments nécessaires du langage, pour servir de fondement à l’étude de toutes les
langues. Paris: Barbou.
Beauzée, Nicolas
1782Encyclopédie
méthodique. Grammaire et littérature: tome
premiere. Paris: Panckoucke.
Bertonio, Ludovico
1603Arte
y grammatica muy copiosa de la lengua aymara. Roma: Luis
Zannetti.
Bettetini, Maria
ed.2004Agostino.
Il maestro e la parola: il maestro, la dialettica, la retorica, la
grammatica. Milano: Bompiani.
Bursill-Hall, Geoffrey
L.
ed.1972Thomas of
Erfurt. Grammatica
Speculativa. London: Longman.
Ceporinus, Jacobus
1522Compendium
Grammaticæ Graecæ. Zürich.
Clajus, Johannes
1578Grammatica
Germanicæ
Linguæ. Leipzig: Rhamba.
De
Melo, Wolfgang
D. C.
ed.2019Varro. De
Lingua Latina. Volume 1: Introduction, Text, and
Translation. Oxford: Oxford University
Press.
Diderot, Denis & Jean
Le
Rond D’Alembert
1751–1772Encyclopédie
ou Dictionnaire raisonné des sciences, des arts et des
métiers. Paris: Briasson, David, Le Breton &
Durand.
Dufour, Médéric & André Wartelle
ed.1973Aristote.
Rhétorique. Paris: Les Belles
Lettres.
Fell, John
1784An
Essay Towards an English
Grammar. London: Dilly.
Gonzáles
Holguín, Diego
1607Gramatica
y arte nueva de la lengua general de todo el Peru llamada lengua Qquichua, o lengua del
Inca. Ciudad de los Reyes del Peru: Francisco del
Canto.
Gough, James
1760A
Practical Grammar of the English
Tongue. Dublin: Jackson.
Greaves, Paul
1594Grammatica
Anglicana. Cambridge: Legatt.
Hickes, George
1689Institutiones
Grammaticae Anglo-Saxonicæ et
Mœso-Gothicæ. Oxford: Sheldon
Theatre.
Hornsey, John
1793A
Short English Grammar in Two Parts. York: Wilson, Spence
& Mawman.
Hunt, Richard
William
1980The history of grammar in the
Middle Ages: collected papers, edited with an introduction, a select bibliography, and indices by G. L.
Bursill-Hall. Amsterdam: J.
Benjamins.
Jones, Hugh
1724An
Accidence to the English
Tongue. London: Clarke.
1640Arte y bocabulario de la lengua
guarani. Madrid: Juan
Sanchez.
Murray, Alexander
1787An
Easy English
Grammar. London: Law.
Nebrija
de, Antonio
1492Gramática
de la lengua castellana. Salamanca.
Newbery, John
1745An
Easy Introduction to the English
Grammar. London: Newbery.
Nolan, Edmond & Samuel
A. Hirsch
ed.1902The
Greek Grammar of Roger Bacon and a Fragment of His Hebrew
Grammar. Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press.
Ölinger, Albert
1573Underricht
der Hoch Teutschen
Sprach. Straßburg: Wyriot.
Oliveira
de, Fernão
1536Grammatica
da lingoagem
portuguesa. Lisboa: Galharde.
Patota, Giuseppe
ed.1996Leon
Battista Alberti. Grammatichetta e altri scritti sul
volgare. Roma: Salerno
Editore.
Perottus, Nicolaus
1490Grammatica
clarissimi poete et oratoris Nicolai
Perotti. Hamburg: Wendelinus de
Wila.
Pinborg, Jan & Heinrich Roos
ed.1969Corpus
Philosophorum Danicorum Medii Aevi. Volume 4: Boethi Daci Opera. Modi Significandi, sive Quaestiones super Priscianum
Maiorem. Copenhagen: G.E.C.
Gad.
Pinborg, Jan
ed.1977Siger
de Coutrai. Summa Modorum Significandi
Sophismata. Amsterdam: Benjamins.
Pinborg, Jan
ed.1982Remigius.
Schleswig 1486. A Latin Grammar in Facsimile Edition with a Postscript by Jan
Pinborg. Copenhagen: Munksgaard.
Pomey, François-Antoine
1717Le
Dictionnaire royal, augmenté de nouveau, et enrichi d’un grand nombre d’expressions élégantes. Dernière édition, nouvellement
augmentée de la plus grande partie des termes de tous les
arts. Lyon: Servant.
Poole, Joshua
1652The
English
Accidence. London: Cotes.
Raillard, Bernard-Michele & Felice Mosca
ed.1714Le
prose di M. Pietro Bembo nelle quali si ragiona della volgar lingua, divise in tre libri. In questa nuova edizione unite
insieme con le giunte di Lodovico Castelvetro. Napoli.
1758Essays
upon the English
Language. London: Ward.
Ward, William
1765An
Essay on Grammar, As It May Be Applied to the English
Language. London: Horsfield.
Wharton, Jeremiah
1654The
English
Grammar. London: Du-Gard.
White, James
1761The
English Verb. A Grammatical
Essay. London: Millar.
Winterbottom, Michael
ed.1970M.
Fabi Quintiliani Institutionis oratoriae libri
duodecim. Oxford: Oxford University
Press.
Wood, James
1777Grammatical
Institutions, or A Practical English Grammar. Newcastle Upon
Tyne: Saint.
Secondary Bibliography
Ackerman, Farrell & Gregory Stump
2004 “Paradigms
and Periphrastic Expressions: A Study in Realization-Based Lexicalism”. Projecting
Morphology ed. by Louisa Sadler & Andrew Spencer, 111–158. Stanford: Center
for the Study of Language and Information Publications.
Aerts, Willem
J.
1965Periphrastica. An Investigation Into
the Use of Εἶναι and Ἔχειν as Auxiliaries and Pseudo-Auxiliaries in Greek from Homer up to the Present
Day. Amsterdam: Hakkert.
Alfieri, Luca
2023 “The
Contribution of the Speculative Grammar to the Identification of the Adjective as an Independent Part of
Speech”. The Meaningful Communicative Exchange in the Middle Ages and in the Modern
Age (edited issue of Beiträge zur Geschichte der Sprachwissenschaft,
33.1), ed. by Paola Cotticelli-Kurras, 9–44. Münster: Nodus.
Baratin, Marc
2005 “Priscianus
Caesariensis (5./6. Jahrhundert n. Chr.)”. Lateinische Lehrer Europas: fünfzehn Portraits von
Varro bis Erasmus von Rotterdam ed. by Wolfram Ax, 247–272. Köln
& Wien: Böhlau.
Benedetti, Marina
2006 “Ausiliazione
aspettuale in Greco antico: i costrutti con λήγειν”. Studi linguistici in onore di Roberto
Gusmani. Volume I ed. by Raffaella Bombi, Guido Cifoletti, Fabiana Fusco, Lucia Innocente & Vincenzo Orioles, 121–132. Alessandria: Dell’Orso.
Benedetti, Marina
2010 “Forme
del finire in greco antico: appunti su παύειν/παύεσθαι”. La morfologia del greco tra tipologia
e diacronia ed. by Ignazio Putzu, Giulio Paulis, Gian
Franco Nieddu & Pierluigi Cuzzolin, 80–96. Milano: Franco
Angeli.
Benedetti, Marina
2018 “Review
to “Signes Codoñer, Juan. 2016. La quimera de los gramáticos. Historia de la voz media del verbo griego en la
tradición gramatical desde Apolonio Díscolo hasta Ludolf Küster y Philipp Buttmann”. Salamanca: Ediciones
Universidad de Salamanca”. Studi e Saggi
Linguistici 56:2.119–128.
Benedetti, Marina
2022 “Απολλώνιος
γράϕω, Priscianus scribo: sugli exempla ficta nel discorso
grammaticale”. Ubi homo, ibi lingua. Studi in onore di Maria Patrizia Bologna. Volume
1 ed. by Laura Biondi, Francesco Dedè & Andrea Scala, 65–77. Alessandria: Dell’Orso.
Bentein, Klaas
2016Verbal
Periphrasis in Ancient Greek. Have- and Be-
Constructions. Oxford: Oxford University
Press.
Bonami, Olivier
2015 “Periphrasis
as
Collocation”. Morphology 25:1.63–110.
Bonami, Olivier & Pollet Samvelian
2015 “The
Diversity of Inflectional Periphrasis in Persian”. Journal of
Linguistics 51:2.327–382.
2000 “On
the Semantic Interpretation of Passive Imperative Sentences: A Case of ‘Voluntary’ Interference between Ancient Greek and
Latin in Latin Grammarians”. Syntaxis. An International Journal of Syntactic
Research 3.111–143.
Díaz
Villalba, Alejandro
2017Le
participe dans les grammaires des langues romanes (XVe-XVIIIe siècles). Histoire comparée d’une classe
grammaticale. PhD dissertation: Université Sorbonne
Nouvelle.
Díaz
Villalba, Alejandro
2020 “Les
options de catégorisation du participe des temps composés dans les grammaires des langues romanes
(XVe-XVIIIe siècles)”. Histoire Épistémologie
Langage 42:1.135–154.
Díaz
Villalba, Alejandro
2023 “A
Contribution to the History of Missionary Grammars and Romance Languages Grammars: The Commensurability of Metalanguage and
Categories in the Sixteenth Century”. Language Learning and Teaching in Missionary and Colonial
Contexts ed. by Dan Savatovsky, Mariangela Albano, Thi
Kieu
Ly Pham & Valérie Spaëth, 143–166. Amsterdam: Amsterdam
University Press.
Drinka, Bridget
2017Language
Contact in Europe. The Periphrastic Perfect through
History. Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press.
Fente, Rafael, Jesús Fernandez & Lope
G. Feijoo
1987
[1972]Perífrasis
verbales. Madrid: Edi
6.
Fortes, Fábio
2019 “Prisciano
y el bilingüismo grecorromano: un ejemplo de análisis interlingüístico en las De constructione
(Inst. gramm. XVII) de Prisciano”. Revista de Estudios
Clássicos 47.25–35.
Fournier, Jean-Marie & Valérie Raby
2014 “Retour
sur la grammatisation: l’extension de la grammaire latine et la description des langues
vulgaires”. Penser l’histoire des savoirs linguistiques. Hommage à Sylvain
Auroux ed. by Sylvie Archaimbault, Jean-Marie Fournier & Valérie Raby, 337–350. Lyon: ENS
Éditions.
Gómez
Asensio, José
L.
2013 “Terminología gramatical
española de los principios. Principios de la terminología gramatical española”. La terminología
gramatical del español y del francés. Emergencias y transposiciones, traducciones y
contextualizaciones ed. by Cécile Bruley & Javier
Suso López, 25–74. Berlin: Peter
Lang.
Grieco, Beatrice
2024Perifrasi
aspettuali in indiano antico. Diacronia e processi di
grammaticalizzazione. Alessandria: Dell’Orso.
Haspelmath, Martin
2000 “Periphrasis”. Morphology.
An International Handbook on Inflection and Word-Formation. Volume I ed. by Geert Booij, Christian Lehmann & Joachim Mugdan, 654–664. Berlin: De
Gruyter.
Hoffmann, Roland
1993 “ ‘Periphrase’
(‘periphrastich’): zu Herkunft und Geschichte eines sprachwissenschaftlichen
Begriffs”. Glotta 71:3–4.223–242.
Kelly, Louis
G.
1990 “Composition and the Verb in
Grammatica Speculativa”. De Ortu Grammaticae. Studies in Medieval Grammar
and Linguistic Theory in Memory of Jan Pinborg ed. by Geoffrey
L. Bursill-Hall, Stan Ebbesen & Konrad
E. F. Koerner, 147–160. Amsterdam
& Philadelphia: Benjamins.
Lausberg, Heinrich
1963
[1949]Handbuch der literarischen Rhetorik. Eine Grundlegung der
Literaturwissenschaft. München: Hueber.
Logozzo, Felicia & Liana Tronci
2020 “Les
constructions à verbe εἶναι ‘être’ et participe présent: status quaestionis et nouvelles
propositions”. Bulletin de la Société de Linguistique de
Paris 115:1.191–239.
Lowe, John
J.
2017 “The Sanskrit
(Pseudo)Periphrastic Future”. Transactions of the Philological
Society 115:2.263–294.
Nardi, Edoardo
2025The
‘Εἶναι + Participle’ Periphrasis and Related Participial Constructions in Biblical Greek. Prototype Categorization,
Morphosyntax-Semantics Interface, and Semitic
Interference. Roma: Edi Press
Unimarconi.
Peetermans, Andy
2020The
Art of Transforming Traditions. Conceptual Developments in Early Modern American Missionary Grammar
Writing. PhD dissertation: Katholieke Universiteit
Leuven.
Regard, Paul
F.
1919La phrase nominale dans la langue du
Nouveau
Testament. Paris: Leroux.
Rosén, Haiim
B.
1992Die Periphrase. Wesen und
Entstehung. Innsbruck: Institut für Sprachwissenschaft
der Universität Innsbruck.
Schad, Samantha
2007A
Lexicon of Latin Grammatical Terminology. Pisa &
Roma: Fabrizio Serra.
Smith, John
C.
2022 “The Boundaries of Inflexion and
Periphrasis”. Periphrasis and Inflexion in Diachrony ed.
by Adam Ledgeway, John
C. Smith & Nigel Vincent, 61–90. Oxford: Oxford
University Press.
Spencer, Andrew
2006 “Periphrasis”. The
Encyclopedia of Language and Linguistics ed. by Keith Brown, 287–293. Oxford: Elsevier.
Spencer, Andrew & Gergana Popova
2015 “Periphrasis
and Inflection”. The Oxford Handbook of Inflection ed.
by Matthew Baerman, 197–230. Oxford: Oxford
University Press.
Squartini, Mario
1998Verbal
Periphrasis in Romance. Aspect, Actionality, and
Grammaticalization. Berlin: De
Gruyter.
Tollis, Francis
1986 “A
propos des ‘circunloquios’ du verbe castillan chez Nebrija: le ‘nombre participial
infinito’”. The History of Linguistics in Spain ed.
by Antonio Quilis & Hans
J. Niederehe, 55–76. Amsterdam
& Philadelphia: Benjamins.
Thümmel, Wolf
1966Das
Problem der periphrastischen
Konstruktionen. München: Fink.
Zawadowski, Leon
1959Constructions
grammaticales et formes périphrastiques. Kraków: Zakład
Narodowy imienia Ossolińskich, Wydawnictwo Polskiej Akademii Nauk.
Zimmermann, Klaus
ed.1997La
descripción de las lenguas amerindias en la época colonial. Frankfurt am
Main: Vervuert.
Zwartjes, Otto
ed.2000aLas
gramáticas misioneras de tradición hispánica (siglos XVI-XVII). Amsterdam &
Atlanta: Rodopi.
Zwartjes, Otto
2000b “Modo,
tiempo y aspecto en las gramáticas de las lenguas mapuche, millcayac, y guaraní de Luis Valdivia y António Ruiz de Montoya: la
categoría de los ‘tiempos mixtos’”. Las gramáticas misioneras de tradición hispánica (siglos
XVI-XVII) ed. by Otto Zwartjes, 205–254. Amsterdam
& Atlanta: Rodopi.
Zwartjes, Otto
2011Portuguese
Missionary Grammars in Asia, Africa and Brazil,
1550–1800. Amsterdam: Benjamins.