The pragmatics of advice-giving in the media discourse: The interplay of speaker gender and hearer gender

Chihsia Tang
National Kaohsiung University of Science and Technology
Abstract

This study investigated how the gender of the contestants in TV talent competitions affects male and female judges’ management of their advice, exemplified by evaluative talks in two Taiwan-based talent contests. In addition to the pragmatic configuration of the advising acts, the internal and external modifiers of the advising speech events were also analyzed in an attempt to gain insights into whether and how the advice messages are instrumental in the construction of gender identities. Results showed that deviating from the stereotypical gendered style of communication, the female judges utilized significantly fewer politeness mechanisms than did their male counterparts to moderate their advice. Besides, the psychological needs and face want of the male and female advice-receivers remarkably influenced the discursive moves of the given advice comments. These findings suggested that in the public media discourse, the speech context outweighs the socially prescribed gendered styles of communication on one’s advice-giving behavior.

Keywords:
Publication history
Table of contents

The advice-giving linguistic behavior is defined as an utterance where an idea is put forward as a possibility for the addressee’s future action (Li 2010). Bach and Harnish (1979) maintained that the force of the advising illocution is for the recipient to embrace an evaluation or idea which is beneficial to himself/herself. Namely, β€œwhat the speaker expresses is not the desire that H does a certain action but the belief that doing it is a good idea, that is in H’s interest” (Bach and Harnish 1979, 50).

Full-text access is restricted to subscribers. Log in to obtain additional credentials. For subscription information see Subscription & Price. Direct PDF access to this article can be purchased through our e-platform.

References

Ainsworth-Vaughn, Nancy
1998 Claiming Power in Doctor-Patient Talk. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Bach, Kent, and Robert M. Harnish
1979 Linguistic Communication and Speech Acts. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Google Scholar
Bahrami, Fatemeh, and Naser Yousefi
2011β€‚β€œFemales Are More Anxious Than Males: A Metacognitive Perspective.” Iranian Journal of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences 5 (2): 83–90.Google Scholar
Barbee, Anita P., Michael R. Cunningham, Barbara A. Winstead, Valerian J. Derlega, Mary R. Gulley, Pamela A. Yankeelov, and Perri B. Druen
1993β€‚β€œEffects of Gender-Role Expectations on the Social Support Process.” Journal of Social Issues 49 (3): 175–190. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Bitsika, Vicki, Christopher F. Sharpley, and Kylie Peters
2010β€‚β€œHow Is Resilience Associated with Anxiety and Depression? Analysis of Factor Score Interactions within a Homogeneous Sample.” German Journal of Psychiatry 13 (1): 9–16.Google Scholar
Blum-Kulka, Shoshana, Juliane House, and Gabriel Kasper
1989 Cross-Cultural Pragmatics: Requests and Apologies. Norwood, NJ: Ablex.Google Scholar
Boatman, Dana
1987β€‚β€œA Study of Unsolicited Advice.” Working Papers in Educational Linguistics 3 (1): 35–60.Google Scholar
Brown, Penelope, and Stephen C. Levinson
1987 Politeness: Some Universals in Language Use. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Bushman, Brad J., and L. Rowell Huesmann
2010β€‚β€œAggression.” In Handbook of Social Psychology, ed. by Susan T. Fiske, Daniel T. Gilbert, and Gardner Lindzey, vol. 2, 833–863. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Butler, Judith
1988β€‚β€œPerformative Acts and Gender Constitution: An Essay in Phenomenology and Feminist Theory.” Theatre Journal 40 (4): 519–531. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
1990 Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity. New York, NY and London: Routledge.Google Scholar
Cameron, Deborah
1997β€‚β€œPerforming Gender Identity: Young Men’s Talk and the Construction of Heterosexual Masculinity.” In Language and Masculinity, ed. by Sally A. Johnson, and Ulrike Hanna Meinhof, 47–64. Oxford: Blackwell.Google Scholar
Cameron, Deborah, and Don Kulick
2003 Language and Sexuality. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Carlin, Barbara A., Betsy D. Gelb, Jamie K. Belinne, and Latha Ramchand
2018β€‚β€œBridging the Gender Gap in Confidence.” Business Horizons 61: 765–774. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Chaplin, Tara M., Kwangik Hong, Keri Bergquist, and Rajita Sinha
2008β€‚β€œGender Differences in Response to Emotional Stress: An Assessment across Subjective, Behavioral, and Physiological Domains and Relations to Alcohol Craving.” Alcoholism 32 (7): 1242–1250. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Chen, Gina Masullo, and Zainul Abedin
2014β€‚β€œExploring Differences in How Men and Women Respond to Threats to Positive Face on Social Media.” Computers in Human Behavior 38: 118–126. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Chen, Tzu-Chin Jill
2002β€‚β€œSuggestion in Chinese: Its Use in Group Counseling.” MA thesis, National Tsing-Hua University.
Clark, Cal, and Janet Clark
2002β€‚β€œThe Social and Political Bases for Women’s Growing Political Power in Taiwan.” Maryland Series in Contemporary Asian Studies 3: 1–39.Google Scholar
Cold, Alice Ross, Lorelei R. Brush, and Eve R. Sprotzer
1980β€‚β€œDevelopmental Changes in Self-Perceptions of Intelligence and Self-Confidence.” Psychology of Women Quarterly 5 (2): 231–239. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Corbin, Charles B., and Daniel M. Landers
1983β€‚β€œSex Differences in Performance Estimates: Female Lack of Confidence vs. Male Boastfulness.” Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport 54 (4): 407–410. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Daubman, Kimberly A., Laurie Heatherington, and Alicia Ahn
1992β€‚β€œGender and the Self-Presentation of Academic Achievement.” Sex Roles 27 (3/4): 187–204. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Deaux, Kay
1979β€‚β€œSelf-Evaluations of Male and Female Managers.” Sex Roles 5: 571–581. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Edmondson, Willis
1981 Spoken Discourse: A Model for Analysis. London: Longman.Google Scholar
Fang, Zhi-Ying
2005β€‚β€œOn the Speech Act of Suggestions in Chinese: A Study on the Speech Act of Suggestions Made by Chinese University Students.” MA thesis, Anhui University.
Fisher, Sue
1993β€‚β€œGender, Power, Resistance: Is Care the Remedy?” In Negotiating at the Margins: The Gendered Discourse of Power and Resistance, ed. by Sue Fisher, and Kathy Davis, 87–121. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press.Google Scholar
Frey, Karin S., and Diane N. Ruble
1987β€‚β€œWhat Children Say about Classroom Performance: Sex and Grade Differences in Perceived Competence.” Child Development 58: 1066–1078. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Holmes, Janet
2006 Gendered Talk at Work: Constructing Gender Identity through Workplace Discourse. Malden, MA: Blackwell. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
2008β€‚β€œGendered Discourse at Work.” Language and Linguistics Compass 2, 478–495. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Hong, Gao
1999β€‚β€œFeatures of Request Strategies in Chinese.” Working Papers of Lund University, Department of Linguistics 47: 73–86.Google Scholar
Horikawa, Randy Y., Jeffrey Mickey, and Steven Miura
1991β€‚β€œEffects of Request Legitimacy on the Compliance-Gaining Tactics of Male and Female Managers.” Communication Monographs 58: 421–436. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Hutchby, Ian
1995β€‚β€œAspects of Recipient Design in Expert Advice-Giving on Call-In Radio.” Discourse Processes 19: 219–238. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Instone, Debra, Brenda Major, and Barbara B. Bunker
1983β€‚β€œGender, Self Confidence, and Social Influence Strategies: An Organizational Simulation.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 44 (2): 322–333. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Kamas, Linda, and Anne Preston
2012β€‚β€œThe Importance of Being Confident: Gender, Career Choice, and Willingness to Compete.” Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 83 (1): 82–97. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Kang, Hyunwoo, and Seyong Jang
2018β€‚β€œEffects of Competition Anxiety on Self-Confidence in Soccer Players: Modulation Effects of Home and Away Games.” Journal of Men’s Health 14 (3): 62–68. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Kendall, Shari
2004β€‚β€œFraming Authority: Gender, Face, and Mitigation at a Radio Network.” Discourse and Society 15 (1): 55–79. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Kendall, Shari, and Deborah Tannen
1997β€‚β€œGender and Language in the Workplace.” In Gender and Discourse, ed. by Ruth Wodak, 81–105. London: Sage. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Kim, Youna
2010β€‚β€œFemale Individualization? Transnational Mobility and Media Consumption of Asian Women.” Media, Culture and Society 32 (1): 25–43. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Ku, Yenlin
2008β€‚β€œFeminist Activism within Bureaucracy: Process of Formulating and Implementing Regulations Governing the Protection of Women’s Rights in Taipei.” Women’s Studies International Forum 31: 176–185. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Kuo, Sai-Hua
1995 Gender and Discourse: A Comparative Study of Male-Female Differences in Conversational Style. Final Research Report for Taiwan’s National Science Council.Google Scholar
Lee, John Chi-Kin, Stephen Yam-Wing Yip, and Raymond Ho-Man Kong
2021 Life and Moral Education in Greater China. New York, NY: Routledge. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Lenney, Ellen
1977β€‚β€œWomen’s Self-Confidence in Achievement Settings.” Psychological Bulletin 84 (1): 1–13. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
1981β€‚β€œWhat’s Fine for the Gander Isn’t Always Good for the Goose: Sex Differences in Self-Confidence as a Function of Ability Area and Comparison with Others.” Sex Roles 7: 905–924. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Lenney, Ellen, Joel Gold, and Chris Browning
1983β€‚β€œSex Differences in Self-Confidence: The Influence of Comparison to Others’ Ability Level.” Sex Roles 9 (9): 925–942. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Li, Eden Sum-Hung
2010β€‚β€œMaking Suggestions: A Contrastive Study of Young Hong Kong and Australian Students.” Journal of Pragmatics 42 (3): 598–616. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Liebler, Carolyn A., and Gary D. Sandefur
2002β€‚β€œGender Differences in the Exchange of Social Support with Friends, Neighbors, and Co-Workers at Midlife.” Social Science Research 31: 364–391. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Liu, James H., Mei-Chih Li, and Xiaodong Yue
2010β€‚β€œChinese Social Identity and Intergroup Relations: The Influence of Benevolent Authority.” In The Oxford Handbook of Chinese Psychology, ed. by Michael Harris Bond, 579–598. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Lundeberg, Mary A., Paul W. Fox, and Judith Punćcohaŕ
1994β€‚β€œHighly Confident but Wrong: Gender Differences and Similarities in Confidence Judgments.” Journal of Educational Psychology 86 (1): 114–121. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Maccoby, Eleanor E., and Carol Nagy Jacklin
1974 The Psychology of Sex Differences. Stanford, CA: Stanford California Press.Google Scholar
MartΓ­nez-Flor, Alicia
2010β€‚β€œSuggestion: How Social Norms Affect Pragmatic Behavior.” In Speech Act Performance: Theoretical, Empirical, and Methodological Issues, ed. by Alicia MartΓ­nez Flor, and Esther UsΓ³ Juan, 258–273. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Neubauer, Deane E., and Surinderpal Kaur
2019 Gender and the Changing Face of Higher Education in Asia Pacific. London: Palgrave Macmillan. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Niederle, Muriel, and Lise Vesterlund
2007β€‚β€œDo Women Shy Away from Competition? Do Men Compete Too Much?” The Quarterly Journal of Economics 122 (3): 1067–1101. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Ochs, Elinor
1992β€‚β€œIndexing Gender.” In Rethinking Context: Language as an Interactive Phenomenon, ed. by Alessandro Duranti, and Charles Goodwin, 335–358. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Pearson, Bethyl
1988β€‚β€œPower and Politeness in Conversation: Encoding of Face-Threatening Acts a Church Business Meeting.” Anthropological Linguistics 30 (1): 68–93.Google Scholar
Peng, Tai-Kuang
2006β€‚β€œConstruct Validation of the Bem Sex Role Inventory in Taiwan.” Sex Roles 55: 843–851. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Reck, Corinna, Daniela Noe, Jakob Gerstenlauer, and Eva Stehle
2012β€‚β€œEffects of Postpartum Anxiety Disorders and Depression on Maternal Self-Confidence.” Infant Behavior and Development 35 (2): 264–272. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Reynolds, Katsue Akiba
1985β€‚β€œFemale Speakers of Japanese.” Feminist Issues 5 (2): 13–46. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Rintell, Ellen
1979β€‚β€œGetting Your Speech Act Together: The Pragmatic Ability of Second Language Learners.” Working Papers on Bilingualism 17: 97–106.Google Scholar
Seidel, Eva-Maria, Ute Habel, Michaela Kirschner, Ruben C. Gur, and Birgit Derntl
2010β€‚β€œThe Impact of Facial Emotional Expressions on Behavioral Tendencies in Women and Men.” Journal of Experimental Psychology Human Perception and Performance 36 (2): 500–507. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Shaw, Ping, and Chin-Yi Lin
2012β€‚β€œMove Freely: Single Women and Mobility in Taiwanese TV Advertising,” In Women and the Media in Asia, ed. by Youna Kim, 130–142. London/New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Skewis, Malcolm
2003β€‚β€œMitigated Directness in Honglou Meng: Direct Speech Acts and Politeness in Eighteen Century Chinese.” Journal of Pragmatics 35 (2): 161–189. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Smith-Hefner, Nancy J.
1985β€‚β€œWomen and Politeness: The Javanese Example.” Language in Society 17: 535–554. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Tan, Yue, Ping Shaw, Hong Cheng, and Kwangmi Ko Kim
2013β€‚β€œThe Construction of Masculinity: A Cross-Cultural Analysis of Men’s Lifestyle Magazine Advertisements.” Sex Roles 69: 237–249. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Tannen, Deborah
1990 You Just Don’t Understand: Women and Men in Conversation. New York, NY: William Morrow.Google Scholar
1994 Talking from 9 to 5: Women and Men at Work. New York, NY: Avon Books.Google Scholar
2005 Conversational Style: Analyzing Talk among Friends. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Thoits, Peggy A.
1995β€‚β€œStress, Coping, and Social Support Processes: Where Are We? What Next?” Journal of Health and Social Behavior 10 (2): 57–79. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Thonus, Terese
1999β€‚β€œDominance in Academic Writing Tutorials: Gender, Language Proficiency, and the Offering of Suggestions.” Discourse and Society 10 (2): 225–248. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Tracy, Karen, and Eric Eisenberg
1990β€‚β€œGiving Criticisms: A Multiple Goal Case Study.” Research on Language and Social Interaction 24 (1–4): 37–70. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Tsai, Chiung-Tzu L.
2006β€‚β€œThe Influence of Confucianism on Women’s Leisure in Taiwan.” Leisure Studies 25 (4): 469–476. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
VΓ‘squez, Camilla
2004β€‚β€œβ€œVery Carefully Managed”: Advice and Suggestions in Post-Observation Meetings.” Linguistics and Education 15 (1–2): 33–58. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Vermeulen, Lotte, Elena NΓΊΓ±ez Castellar, and Jan Van Looy
2014β€‚β€œChallenging the Other: Exploring the Role of Opponent Gender in Digital Game Competition for Female Players.” Cyberpsychology, Behavior and Social Networking 17 (5): 303–309. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Verschueren, Jef
1981β€‚β€œThe Semantics of Forgotten Routines.” In Conversational Routines, ed. by Florian Coulmas, 133–153. The Hague: Mouton. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Wang, Jia, Greg G. Wang, Wendy E.β€―A. Ruona, and Jay W. Rojewski
2005β€‚β€œConfucian Values and the Implications for International HRD.” Human Resource Development International 8 (3): 311–326. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
West, Candace
1990β€‚β€œNot Just Doctor’s Orders: Directive-Response Sequences in Patients’ Visits to Women and Men Physicians.” Discourse and Society 1 (1): 85–111. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Woods, Nicola
1989β€‚β€œTalking Shop: Sex and Status as Determinants of Floor Apportionment in a Work Setting.” In Women in Their Speech Communities, ed. by Jennifer Coates, and Deborah Cameron, 141–157. London: Longman.Google Scholar
Zuckerman, Diana M.
1989β€‚β€œStress, Self-Esteem, and Mental Health: How Does Gender Make a Difference?” Sex Roles 20 (7/8): 429–444. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Β