Article In: Review of Cognitive Linguistics: Online-First Articles
Hybridity and linguistic adaptability of Tibetan Buddhism in Taiwan
This content is being prepared for publication; it may be subject to changes.
Abstract
This paper examines the hybridity and linguistic adaptability of Tibetan
Buddhism in Taiwan, highlighting how preservation and innovation are negotiated in a
predominantly Chinese-speaking environment. It traces how Tibetan Buddhism has been
introduced, localised, and sustained, demonstrating that contemporary practices in Taiwan
are neither direct reproductions of Tibetan ritual traditions nor fully assimilated into
local religious culture. Instead, they constitute a distinctive form of practice that is
simultaneously Taiwanese and deeply rooted in Tibetan Buddhist tradition. Drawing on three
case studies, the paper illustrates how hybridity is enacted in lived religious contexts.
Using mixed methods — including ethnographic observation, surveys, and interviews — the
research identifies the trilateral hybrid prayer format as a key strategy of linguistic
translation, ritual adaptation, and cultural negotiation. This format operates across
institutional, domestic, and household settings, revealing hybridity as a flexible
strategy that maintains doctrinal continuity while enabling participation and lay
empowerment. The study contributes to cognitive linguistics by showing how meaning is
constructed in ritual contexts and advances research on religious transnationalism by
demonstrating how multilayered linguistic practices mediate cultural negotiation in
diasporic settings.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Hybridity and linguistic adaptation
- 3.Overview: Tibetan Buddhism in Taiwan
- 4.Hybridity in practice
- 4.1Case 1: Prayer books: Accessibility with ritual authority
- 4.2Case 2: The 5th Guru Bumtsok Ceremony — Institutional negotiation of authority and inclusion
- 4.3Case 3: Linguistic innovation and lay empowerment in household rituals
- 5.Conclusion
- Notes
- Author queries
References
References (41)
Bostic, Joy R. (2018). Plurals, hybrids, and nomads:
Spirituality and religious practice at the intersections. In William B. Parsons (Ed.), Being
spiritual but not religious: Past, present, future(s) (1st
ed., pp. 72–85). Routledge.
Cibei Zhihui: Lama Wang
[慈悲智慧 :喇嘛網]. (2025). 尊貴格賴仁波切 [His Holiness Gelai Rinpoche]. [URL]
Dalton, Jacob P. (2016). The gathering of intentions: A
history of a Tibetan tantra. Columbia University Press.
Dolker, Tsering. (2022). A
reflection upon the practices of a bodhisattva through the traditional smoke offering (Sur) in
Ladakh. The Tibet
Journal, 47(1), 21–30.
Duanmu, San, & Stiennon, Nicholas. (2005). Tonal
patterns in Chinese regulated verse: A corpus study. Taiwan Journal of
Linguistics, 3(1), 1–31.
Ferrer, Antonio. (2024). Internal
orientalism on Taiwan: The ROC’s Mongolian and Tibetan Affairs Commission and its portrayal of Tibetan
Buddhism. Comparative
Education, 60(1), 159–176.
Fraser, Sarah E. (2018). Tibetan Buddhist temples in
Taiwan. An exploration of transnational religious
architecture. In Jagou, Fabienne (Ed.), The
hybridity of Buddhism: Contemporary encounters between Tibetan and Chinese traditions in Taiwan and the
mainland (pp. 41–65). École française d’Extrême-Orient.
Gharwang, Zangpo. (2021). A
comparative analysis of the transmission and “translation” of Tibetan Buddhist teachings in the American
context [Master’s thesis, Harvard University Division of Continuing Education]. [URL]
Gray, Karen M., Namgyal, Dadul, Purcell, John, Samphel, Thupten, Sonam, Tenzin, Tenzin, Kesang, Tsering, Dawa, Worthman, Carol M., & Eisen, Arri. (2020). Found
in translation: Collaborative contemplations of Tibetan Buddhism and Western science. Frontiers
in Communication, 4, 76. [URL].
Harvey, Peter. (2012). An
introduction to Buddhism: Teachings, history and practices. Cambridge University Press.
Hyer, Paul, & Jagchid, Sechin. (1983). A
Mongolian living Buddha: Biography of the Kanjurwa Khutughtu. State University of New York Press.
Jagou, Fabienne. (Ed.). (2018). The
hybridity of Buddhism: Contemporary encounters between Tibetan and Chinese traditions in Taiwan and the
mainland. École française d’Extrême-Orient.
Karmay, Samten Gyaltsen. (2003). The fifth Dalai Lama
and his reunification of Tibet. In Pommaret, Françoise (Ed.), Lhasa
in the seventeenth century: The capital of the Dalai Lamas (Heather Solverson, Trans., pp. 65–80). Brill.
Kellner, Birgit. (2018). Vernacular
literacy in Tibet: Present debates and historical
beginnings. In Krotz, Eva, Stephan Müller, Norbert Kössinger & Pavlína Rychterová (Eds.), Anfangsgeschichten/Origin
Stories (pp. 381–402). Brill | Fink.
Kraidy, Marwan M. (2002). Hybridity in cultural
globalization. Communication
Theory, 12(3), 316–339.
Kyabje Lama Zopa
Rinpoche. (2015, April 2). Sur commentary:
Practicing aroma charity for spirits. Lamayeshe.com. [URL]
Langacker, Ronald W. (1987). Foundations of cognitive grammar.
Volume 1: Theoretical prerequisites. Stanford University Press.
Lin, Hsiao-ting [林孝庭]. (2020). 末代國師:第七世章嘉呼圖克圖 [The last preceptor: The 7th Changkya
Khutukhtu]. 中央研究院近代史研究所集刊 [Bulletin of
the Institute of Modern History, Academia
Sinica], 109, 45–90.
Liu, Guo-wei [劉國威]. (2004, November 14). 藏傳佛教經典翻譯在台灣之發展 [The development of Tibetan Buddhist classic
translation in Taiwan]. In 台灣密宗國際學術研討會(第1屆)論文集 [Proceedings of the 1st International Conference on Taiwanese
Esoteric Buddhism] (p. 13). 中國真佛宗密教總會 [True Buddha School Vajrayana Association of ROC].
Majer, Zsófi. (2022). Preliminary
notes on Tibetan after-death rites and their texts in Mongolian Buddhist
practice. In Ágnes Birtalan, Krisztina Teleki, & Judit Adrienn Béres (Eds.), Aspects
of Mongolian Buddhism 3: Tradition and
innovation (pp. 348–375). L’Harmattan Kiadó.
Mills, Martin A. (2013). Identity, ritual and state in Tibetan
Buddhism: The foundations of authority in Gelukpa monasticism. Taylor & Francis.
Nechung Buddhist
Center. (2024, July 21). Maha Guru
Bhumtsok year 2024. Nechungbc.com. [URL]
Ong, Soon-Hock [翁仕傑]. (2018). 格魯派在台灣的發展機制:漢藏政教傳承的界限與交 [The development and mechanism of the Gelug sect in
Taiwan: The boundary and integration of Sino-Tibetan in theocracy inheritance]. 藏傳佛教格魯派與薩迦派-學術研討會論文集 [Academic seminar on Tibetan
Buddhism] (pp. 27–51). Ministry of Culture.
Pan, Mei-Lin [潘美玲], & Kironska, Kristina. (2024). Taiwanese
public opinion on inviting the Dalai Lama to Taiwan: Political or religious
motives? International Journal of Taiwan
Studies, 8(1), 185–211.
Raine, Robert. (2011). Translating
the Buddhist canon: Past strategies, future prospects. Forum: Revue internationale
d’interprétation et de traduction / International Journal of Interpretation and
Translation, 9(2), 157–186.
Sangay, Tenzin, & Kilty, Gavin. (2011). Tibetan
ritual for the dead. The Tibet
Journal, 36(3), 49–59.
Schak, David, & Hsiao, Hsin-Huang Michael. (2005). Taiwan’s
socially engaged Buddhist groups. China
Perspectives, 59.
Shen, Weirong. (2017). Ming
Chinese translations of Tibetan Tantric Buddhist texts and the Buddhist Saṃgha of the Western regions in
Beijing. In Yael Bentor, & Meir Shahar (Eds.), Chinese
and Tibetan esoteric
Buddhism (Vol. 1, pp. 263–299). Brill.
Spolsky, Bernard. (2003). Religion
as a site of language contact. Annual Review of Applied
Linguistics, 23, 81–94.
Taiwan International Tibetan Dharma Tradition Association
[台灣國際藏傳法脈總會]. (n.d.). 薩迦派(花教)在台的發展 [The development of the Sakya School (Flower Sect) in
Taiwan]. Blogspot.com. Retrieved September 30, 2025, from [URL]
Thekchen Choling
(Malaysia). (2025). Connect with Guru Rinpoche: One voice, one prayer, infinite
blessings. Thekchen Choling Singapore Ltd. [URL]
Tsering, Dolma. (2023a). Taiwan
and the exiled Tibetan relations: Exploring historical ties and current challenges and
opportunities. Asian
Ethnicity, 25(2), 1–17.
. (2023b, June 28). Taiwan’s
Tibetan Buddhist monk dilemma and its unintended consequences. Taiwan
Insight. Taiwan Research Hub, University of Nottingham. [URL]
Tsering, Dolma, & Pan, Mei-Lin [潘美玲]. (2025). 難胞/叛賊:
兩蔣時期在臺藏人的政治角色與歷史 [Refugees/Traitors: The political role and history of
Tibetans in Taiwan during the Two Chiang Era]. In Yu-chen Chen & Song-ceng Xu (Eds.), 成為臺灣的我們 [How we become
Taiwanese] (pp. 200–223). National Cheng Kung University Press.
Veterans and Dependents Foundation,
R.O.C. (2023). 甘珠精舍沿革暨重光紀念 [The history of Ganzhu Monastery and the commemoration of
Chongguang]. 榮民榮眷基金會. [URL]
Yao, Li-xiang [姚麗香]. (2000). 藏傳佛教在台灣發展的初步研究 [A preliminary study on the development of Tibetan Buddhism
in Taiwan]. 佛學研究中心學報 [Journal of the
Center for Buddhist
Studies], 5, 313–339. [URL]
Zablocki, Abraham Mark. (2005). The global mandala: The
transnational transformation of Tibetan Buddhism [Doctoral
dissertation, Cornell University].
Zheng, Zhi-ming [鄭志明]. (2004). 藏傳佛教在台發展的現況與省思 [The current development and reflections on Tibetan Buddhism
in Taiwan]. 台灣密宗國際學術研討會(第1屆) [Proceedings of the 1st International Conference on Taiwanese Esoteric
Buddhism], 26. [URL]