Blood, Soil, and Tears
Conceptual Metaphor-based Critical Discourse Analysis of the Legal Debate on US Citizenship
The Fourteenth Amendment to the US Constitution grants citizenship to every child born on US soil. While most Americans think this 150 year old formulation is permanent, it is actually open to change. We explore the legal debate over the current formulation of US citizenship. Using the research design of the exemplar case study, we undertake a conceptual metaphor-based critical discourse analysis of three contending contemporary legal stances regarding US citizenship. In the light of four current court cases, some legal theorists argue that the formulation is both undemocratic and inadequate, and should be amended to address 21st century national concerns. Others argue to retain the current formulation in spite of these concerns. Our study reveals that the rival stances are argued in terms of irreconcilable conceptual metaphors, and each legal stance in itself is deficient to address these current concerns.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction and background
- 2.Conceptual Metaphor Theory
- 3.Metaphor in Legal Thinking
- 4.Our Critical Discourse Analytic Method
- 5.Case study: the Consensualist view of US Citizenship
- 5a.Implications of the Consent principle
- 5b.Adjudication of current legal issues with Consent principle
- 6.Case Study: the Status-Quo view of US Citizenship
- 6a.Adjudication of current legal issues with us as sovereign leading analogy
- 7.Case Study: the view from US Citizenship History
- 7a.Adjudication of current legal issues given the history of US citizenship
- 8.Discussion and Conclusion
- Acknowledgements
- Notes
- US Supreme Court cases cited
- Statutes cited
-
References
This article is currently available as a sample article.
References
Arendt, Hannah
1958 The Origins of Totalitarianism. Orlando, FL: Harcourt Brace.
Barderrama, Francisco E., and Raymond Rodríguez
2006 Decade of Betrayal: Mexican Repartriation in the 1930s. Albuquerque, NM: University of New Mexico Press.
Cunningham-Parmeter, Keith
2011 “
Alien language: Immigration metaphors and the jurispru-dence of Otherness.”
Fordham Law Review 791: 1545–1590.
Epstein, Lee, and Andrew Martin
2012 “
Legal scholarship highlight: Activism and the Roberts Court.” SCOTUSblog,
[URL] (accessed 28 June 2015)
Gardner, Martin
1996 The night is large: Collected essays, 1938–1995. New York: St. Martin’s Griffin.
Gibbs, Raymond Jr.
1994 The Poetics of Mind: Figurative thought, language, and understanding. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Gibbs, Raymond Jr.
2013 “
Conceptual metaphor in thought and social action.” In
The Power of Metaphor: Examining its influence on Social Life, ed. by
Mark J. Landau,
Michael D. Robinson, and
Brian P. Meier, 17–40. Washington DC: American Psychological Association.
Graglia, Lino A.
2009 “
Birthright citizenship for children of illegal aliens: An irrational public policy.”
Texas Review of Law & Politics 141: 1–14.
Hacker, J. David
2011 “
A census-based count of the Civil War dead.”
Civil War History 571: 307–48.
Ing, Matthew
2011 “
Birthright citizenship, illegal aliens, and the original meaning of the Citizenship Clause.”
Akron Law Review 451: 719–68.
Kerber, Linda A.
1992 “
The paradox of women’s citizenship in the early Republic: The case of Martin vs. Massachusetts, 1805.”
The American Historical Review 971: 349–78.
Kim, Victoria, and Frank Shyong
3 March 2015 “
‘Maternity tourism’ raids target California operations catering to Chinese.”
Los Angeles Times, A1.
Krause, Monika
2008 “
Undocumented migrants: An Arendtian perspective.”
European Journal of Political Theory 71: 331–48.
Lakoff, George, and Mark Johnson
1980 Metaphors We Live By. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Landau, Mark, Michael Robinson, and Brian Meier
(eds) 2013 The Power of Metaphor: Examining its Influence on Social Life. Washington DC: American Psychological Association.
Mechaca, Martha
1993 “
Chicano Indianism: A historical account of racial repression in the United States.”
American Ethnologist 201: 583–603.
Ngai, Mae M.
2007 “
Birthright citizenship and the alien citizen.”
Fordham Law Review 751: 2521–2530.
Ngai, Mae M.
2014 Impossible Subjects: Illegal Aliens and the Making of Modern America. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Olivas, Michael A.
2011 “
The political efficacy of Plyler v. Doe: The danger and the discourse.”
UC Davis Law Review 451: 1–26.
Passel, Jeffrey S., and Mark H. Lopez
2012 “
Up to 1.7 million unauthorized immigrant youth may benefit from new deportation rules.” Pew Research Center. Washington, DC: Pew Research.
Perrez, Julien and Min Reuchamps
2015 The political impact of metaphors, special issue of
Metaphor and the Social World 5(2).
Pragglejaz Group
2007 “
MIP: a method for identifying metaphorically used words in discourse.”
Metaphor and Symbol 22(1): 1–39.
Sageman, Marc
2004 Understanding Terror Networks. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
Santa Ana, Otto, Layza López, and Edgar Munguía
2010 “
Framing peace as violence: U.S. television news depictions of the 2007 Los Angeles police attack on immigrant rights marchers.”
Aztlán 35(1): 69–101.
Santa Ana, Otto, Sandra L. Treviño, Michael Bailey, Kristen Bodossian, and Antonio de Necochea
2007 “
A May to Remember: Adversarial images of immigrants in U.S. newspapers during the 2006 policy debate.”
Du Bois Review: Social Science Research on Race 4(1): 207–232.
Schuck, Peter H., and Rogers M. Smith
1985 Citizenship without Consent: Illegal Aliens in the American Polity. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press
Searle, John R.
1992 The Rediscovery of the Mind. Cambridge MA: M.I.T. Press.
Sengupta, Somini and Hwaida Saad
5 November 2015 “
As Refugees Flee, Thousands of Children Have No Country to Call Their Own.”
New York Times. (retrieved 5 November 2015 from
[URL])
Steen, Gerald J., Aletta G. Dorst, J. Berenike Herrmann, Anna Kaal, Tina Krennmayr, and Trijntje Pasma
Tsai, Robert
2008 Eloquence & Reason: Creating a First Amendment Culture. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division
2013 The number of international migrants worldwide reaches 232 million. Population Facts.
[URL] (accessed on
28 June 2015).
Valencia, Richard R.
2008 Chicano students and the Courts: The Mexican American Legal Struggle for Educational Equality. New York: New York University Press.
Van Besien, Fred
1989 “
Metaphors in scientific language.”
Communication & Cognition 221: 5–22.
Winter, Steven L.
1988 “
The metaphor of ‘standing’ and the problem of self-governance.”
Stanford University Law Review 401: 1371–1516.
Winter, Steven L.
1989 “
Transcendental nonsense, metaphoric reasoning, and the cognitive strikes law.”
University of Pennsylvania Law Review 1371: 1105–1237.
Winter, Steven L.
1990 “
Bull Durham and the uses of theory.”
Stanford University Law Review 421: 639–93.
Wodak, Ruth
2002a “
What CDA is about – a summary of its history, important concepts and its developments.” In
Methods of Critical Discourse Analysis, ed. by
Ruth Wodak and
Michael Meyer, 1–13. London: SAGE Publications.
Wodak, Ruth
2002b “
The discourse-historical approach.” In
Methods of Critical Discourse Analysis, ed. by
Ruth Wodak and
Michael Meyer, 63–94. London: SAGE Publications.
Zong, Jie, and Jeanne Batalova
2016 14 April. “
Frequently requested statistics on immigrant and immigration in the United States.”
Migration Policy Institute On-line Journal. USA: Migration Policy Institute. (retrieved 24 April 2016 from
[URL])
Cited by
Cited by 3 other publications
Edwards, Emily
2021.
Twenty-four hours in the alt-right media ecosystem: analyzing race, space, and labor inBreitbart’scoverage of the Mollie Tibbetts murder.
Critical Studies in Media Communication 38:1
► pp. 32 ff.
Yuan, Guorong & Yi Sun
2023.
A bibliometric study of metaphor research and its implications (2010–2020).
Southern African Linguistics and Applied Language Studies 41:3
► pp. 227 ff.
马, 新
2022.
On the Development of Critical Metaphor Studies.
Modern Linguistics 10:08
► pp. 1589 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 2 april 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.