Chapter 5
The uncertainty principle in second language acquisition
This chapter presents three themes that I have discussed with Mike Long on different occasions in recent years: The Discontinuity Hypothesis, the necessity to study the ‘intra-language’ (in addition to the ‘interlanguage’) and the uncertainty principle. The latter is the idea that abstract rules and statistical regularities are entangled states of mind in a L2 learner’s competence, to the extent that researchers can never know whether learners are recognizing a morphosyntactic form (due to its frequency) or they are generating that form by a rule (due to abstract ‘labels that predate the input’). Uncertainty implies that what we can uncover about a learner’s implicit competence depends on how such competence is measured.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction: Mike and science
- 2.Rationalism continued
- 3.Second language development could be twofold
- 4.Second language acquisition research could benefit from the study of intra-language
- 5.Language competence could be permanently re-assembled and rehearsed during online performance
- 6.The knowability issue
- 7.The uncertainly principle and second language development
- 8.Arrivederci
-
Notes
-
References