Categories and gradience in intonation
A functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging study
The Autosegmental-Metrical framework (AM) assumes that a distinction needs to be made between linguistic phonological information (categorical) and paralinguistic phonetic information (gradient) in intonation. However, empirical evidence supporting this assumption has proved to be elusive so far. In this study we analysed whether the theoretical distinction is reflected in perceptual biases and neural activation in the brain. The results of a combined behavioural and neuroimaging study demonstrate that intonational function indeed activates different but overlapping neural networks with more widespread activation for categorical phonological stimuli, especially in middle temporal gyrus bilaterally and left supramarginal and inferior parietal areas. In contrast, for paralinguistic gradient stimuli activation is restricted to right inferior frontal gyrus. These neural differences mirror differences in response times in a listening experiment testing categorical perception for the same stimuli. These findings support a theoretical model of intonation, such as AM, in which linguistic and paralinguistic information are distinguished.
References
Best, Catherine T
2015 “
Devil or Angel in the Details?: Perceiving phonetic variation as information about phonological structure”. This volume.
Binder, Jeffrey R., Rutvik H. Desai, William W. Graves & Lisa L. Conant
2009 “
Where is the Semantic System?: A critical review and meta-analysis of 120 functional neuroimaging studies”.
Cerebral Cortex 19:12.2767-2796.
Boatman, Dana
2004 “
Cortical Bases of Speech Perception: Evidence from functional lesion studies”.
Cognition 92:1-2.47-65.
Boersma, Paul & David Weenink
2010 Praat: Doing phonetics by computer: Version 5.2. (
[URL]) (Retrieved on October 29, 2010).
Bolinger, Dwight
1970 “
Relative Height”.
Prosodic Feature Analysis ed. by
Pierre R. Léon.,
Georges Faure &
André Rigault, 109-125. Paris: Didier.
Bolinger, Dwight
1986 Intonation and its Parts: Melody in spoken English. Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press.
Borràs-Comes, Joan, Jordi Costa-Faidella, Pilar Prieto & Carles Escera
2012 “
Specific Neural Traces for Intonational Discourse Categories as Revealed by Human-Evoked Potentials”.
Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 24:4.843-853.
Brett, Matthew, Alexander P. Leff, Chris Rorden & John Ashburner
2001 “
Spatial Normalization of Brain Images with Focal Lesions Using Cost Function Masking”.
NeuroImage 14:2.486-500.
Burton, Martha W., Steven L. Small & Sheila E. Blumstein
2000 “
The Role of Segmentation in Phonological Processing: An fMRI investigation”.
Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 12:4.679-690.
Chandrasekaran, Bharath, Ananthanarayan Krishnan & Jackson T. Gandour
2007 “
Mismatch Negativity to Pitch Contours is Influenced by Language Experience”.
Brain Research 1128.148-156.
Chandrasekaran, Bharath, Ananthanarayan Krishnan & Jackson T. Gandour
2009 “
Relative Influence of Musical and Linguistic Experience on Early Cortical Processing of Pitch Contours”.
Brain and Language 108:1.1-9.
Chen, Aoju
2005 Universal and Language-Specific Perception of Paralinguistic Intonational Meaning. Ph.D. dissertation, Utrecht: Landelijke Onderzoekschool Taalwetenschap (LOT).
Coleman, John
1998 “
Cognitive Reality and the Phonological Lexicon: A review”.
Journal of Neurolinguistics 11:3.295-320.
Cruttenden, Alan
1986 Intonation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Crystal, David
1969 Prosodic Systems and Intonation in English. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Davis, Matthew H. & Ingrid S. Johnsrude
2003 “
Hierarchical Processing in Spoken Language Comprehension”.
Journal of Neuroscience 23:8.3423-3431.
Davis, Matthew H. & Ingrid S. Johnsrude
2007 “
Hearing Speech Sounds: Top-down influences on the interface between audition and speech perception”.
Hearing Research, 229:1-2.132-147.
Dehaene-Lambertz, Ghislaine
1997 “
Electrophysiological Correlates of Categorical Phoneme Perception in Adults”.
NeuroReport 8:4.919-924.
Dehaene-Lambertz, Ghislaine, Christophe Pallier, Willy Serniclaes, Liliane Sprenger-Charolles, Antoinette Jobert & Stanislas Dehaene
2005 “
Neural Correlates of Switching from Auditory to Speech Perception”.
NeuroImage 24:1.21-33.
Doherty, Colin P., W. Caroline West, Laura C. Dilley, Stefanie Shattuck‐Hufnagel & David Caplan
2004 “
Question/statement judgments: an fMRI study of intonation processing”.
Human Brain Mapping 23:2.85-98.
Eulitz, Carsten & Aditi Lahiri
2004 “
Neurobiological Evidence for Abstract Phonological Representations in the Mental Lexicon during Speech Recognition”.
Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 16:4.577-583.
Friston, Karl
1997 “
Imaging Cognitive Anatomy”.
Trends in Cognitive Science 1:1.21-27.
Gandour, Jack, Mario Dzemidzic, Donald Wong, Mark Lowe, Yunxia Tong, Li Hsieh, Nakarin Satthamnuwong & Joseph Lurito
2003a “
Temporal Integration of Speech Prosody is Shaped by Language Experience: An fMRI study”.
Brain and Language 84:4.318-336.
Gandour, Jack, Donald Wong, Mario Dzemidzic, Mark Lowe, Yunxia Tong & Xiaojian Li
2003b “
A Cross-Linguistic fMRI Study of Perception of Intonation and Emotion in Chinese”.
Human Brain Mapping 18:3.149-157.
Gandour, Jack, Yisheng Xu, Donald Wong, Mario Dzemidzic, Mark Lowe, Xiaojian Li & Yunxia Tong
2003c “
Neural Correlates of Segmental and Tonal Information in Speech Perception”.
Human Brain Mapping 20:4.185-200.
Gandour, Jackson, Yunxia Tong, Donald Wong, Thomas Talavage, Mario Dzemidzic, Yisheng Xu, Xiaojian Li & Mark Lowe
2004 “
Hemispheric Roles in the Perception of Speech Prosody”.
NeuroImage 23:1.344-357.
Grabe, Esther, Brechtje Post, Francis Nolan & Kimberley Farrar
2000 “
Pitch Accent Realisation in Four Varieties of British English”.
Journal of Phonetics 28:2.161-185.
Grandjean, Didier & Klaus R. Scherer
2006 “
Examining the Neural Mechanisms Involved in the Affective and Pragmatic Coding of Prosody”.
Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Speech Prosody, Dresden, 2-5 May 2006 ed. by
Rüdiger Hoffmann &
Hansjörg Mixdorff, paper 268. Dresden: TUD Press.
Gussenhoven, Carlos
1984 On the Grammar and Semantics of Sentence Accents. Dordrecht: Foris.
Gussenhoven, Carlos
2004 The Phonology of Tone and Intonation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hall, Deborah A., Ingrid S. Johnsrude, Mark P. Haggard, Alan R. Palmer, Michael A. Akeroyd & A. Quentin Summerfield
2002 “
Spectral and Temporal Processing in Human Auditory Cortex”.
Cerebral Cortex 12:2.140-149.
Henson, Richard
2006 “
Forward Inference Using Functional Neuroimaging: Dissociations versus associations”.
Trends in Cognitive Sciences 10:2.64-69.
Hickok, Gregory & David Poeppel
2000 “
Towards a Functional Neuroanatomy of Speech Perception”.
Trends in Cognitive Sciences 4:4.131-138.
Hickok, Gregory & David Poeppel
2007 “
The Cortical Organization of Speech Processing”.
Nature Reviews Neuroscience 8:5.393-402.
Indefrey, Peter & Willem J. M. Levelt
2004 “
The Spatial and Temporal Signatures of Word Production Components”.
Cognition 92:1-2.101-144.
Jun, Sun-Ah
ed. 2005 Prosodic Typology. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Kaas, Jon H., Troy A. Hackett & Mark Jude Tramo
1999 “
Auditory Processing in Primate Cerebral Cortex”.
Current Opinion in Neurobiology 9:2.164-170.
Krishnan, Ananthanarayan, Jackson T. Gandour & Gavin M. Bidelman
2010 “
The Effects of Tone Language Experience on Pitch Processing in the Brainstem”.
Journal of Neurolinguistics 23:1.81-95.
Ladd, D. Robert
1981 “
A First Look at the Semantics and Pragmatics of Negative Questions and Tag Questions”.
Proceedings of Chicago Linguistics Society (CLS), vol. 17, 164-171. Chicago, Ill.: Chicago Linguistics Society.
Ladd, D. Robert
1996 Intonational Phonology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Ladd, D. Robert & Rachel Morton
1997 “
The Perception of Intonational Emphasis: Continuous or categorical?”.
Journal of Phonetics 25:3.313-342.
Lancaster, Jack L., Lacy H. Rainey, J. L. Summerlin, Catarina S. Freitas, Peter T. Fox, Alan C. Evans, Arthur W. Toga & John C. Mazziotta
1997 “
Automated Labeling of the Human Brain: A preliminary report on the development and evaluation of a forward-transform method”.
Human Brain Mapping 5:4.238-242.
Lancaster, Jack L., Marty G. Woldorff, Lawrence M. Parsons, Mario Liotti, Catarina S. Freitas, Lacy Rainey, Peter V. Kochunov, Dan Nickerson, Shawn A. Mikiten & Peter T. Fox
2000 “
Automated Talairach Atlas Labels for Functional Brain Mapping”.
Human Brain Mapping 10:3.120-131.
Leitman, David I., Daniel H. Wolf, J. Daniel Ragland, Petri Laukka, James Loughead, Jeffrey N. Valdez, Daniel C. Javitt, Bruce I. Turetsky & Ruben C. Gur
2010 “
It’s not what you Say, but how you Say it: A reciprocal temporo-frontal network for affective prosody”.
Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 4:19.1-13.
Mayer, Jörg, Dirk Wildgruber, Axel Riecker, Grzegorz Dogil, Hermann Ackermann & Wolfgang Grodd
2002 “
Prosody Production and Perception: Converging evidence from fMRI studies”.
Proceedings of the 1st International Conference on Speech Prosody, Aix-en-Provence, 11-13 April 2002 ed. by
Bernard Bel &
Isabelle Marlien, 487-490. Aix-en-Provence: Université de Provence, Laboratoire Parole et Langage.
McLachlan, Neil & Sarah Wilson
2010 “
The Central Role of Recognition in Auditory Perception: A neurobiological model”.
Psychological Review117:1.175-196.
Mitchell, Rachel L. C. & Elliott D. Ross
2008 “
fMRI Evidence for the Effect of Verbal Complexity on Lateralisation of the Neural Response Associated with Decoding Prosodic Emotion”.
Neuropsychologia 46:12.2880-2887.
Obleser, Jonas, Henning Boecker, Alexander Drzezga, Bernhard Haslinger, Andreas Hennenlotter, Michael Roettinger, Carsten Eulitz & Josef P. Rauschecker
2006 “
Vowel Sound Extraction in Anterior Superior Temporal Cortex”.
Human Brain Mapping 27:7.562-571.
Obleser, Jonas & Frank Eisner
2009 “
Pre-Lexical Abstraction of Speech in the Auditory Cortex”.
Trends in Cognitive Sciences 13:1.14-19.
Obleser, Jonas, Aditi Lahiri & Carsten Eulitz
2004 “
Magnetic Brain Response Mirrors Extraction of Phonological Features from Spoken Wowels”.
Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 16:1.31-39.
Phillips, Colin, Thomas Pellathy, Alec Marantz, Elron Yellin, Kenneth Wexler, David Poeppel, Martha McGinnis & Timothy Roberts
2000 “
Auditory Cortex Accesses Phonological Categories: An MEG mismatch study”.
Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 12:6.1038-1055.
Pierrehumbert, Janet
1980 The Phonetics and Phonology of English Intonation. Ph.D. dissertation, Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
Poldrack, Russell A
2006 “
Can Cognitive Processes Be Inferred from Neuroimaging Data?”.
Trends in Cognitive Sciences 10:2.59-63.
Post, Brechtje
2000 Tonal and Phrasal Structures in French Intonation. Ph.D. dissertation, The Hague: Holland Academic Graphics.
Post, Brechtje, Mariapaola D’Imperio & Carlos Gussenhoven
2007 “
Fine Phonetic Detail and Intonational Meaning”.
Proceedings of the 16th International Congress of Phonetic Sciences (ICPhS16), Saarbrücken, 6-10 August 2007 ed. by
Jurgen Trouvain &
William J. Barry, 191-196. Saarbrücken: Universität des Saarlandes.
Price, Cathy J
2010 “
The Anatomy of Language: A review of 100 fMRI studies published in 2009”.
Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 1191.62-88.
Ren, Guiqin Q., Yufang Yang & Xiaoqing Li
2009 “
Early Cortical Processing of Linguistic Pitch Patterns as Revealed by the Mismatch Negativity”.
Neuroscience 162:1.87-95.
Scherer, Klaus R., D. Robert Ladd & Kim E. A. Silverman
1984 “
Vocal Cues to Speaker Affect: Testing two models”.
Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 76:5.1346-1356.
Schirmer, Annett & Sonja A. Kotz
2006 “
Beyond the Right Hemisphere: Brain mechanisms mediating vocal emotional processing”.
Trends in Cognitive Sciences 10:1.24-30.
Scott, Sophie K. & Ingrid S. Johnsrude
2003 “
The Neuroanatomical and Functional Organisation of Speech Perception”.
Trends in Neurosciences 26:2.100-107.
Sharma, Anu & Michael F. Dorman
2000 “
Neurophysiologic Correlates of Cross-Language Phonetic Perception”.
Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 107:5.2697-2703.
Shriberg, Elizabeth, D. Robert Ladd, Jacques Terken & Andreas Stolcke
1996 “
Modeling Intra-Speaker Pitch Range Variation: Predicting f0 targets when ‘speaking up’”.
Proceedings of the Fourth International Conference on Spoken Language Processing (ICSLP 96), Philadelphia, Pa., 3-6 October 1996 ed. by
H. Timothy Bunnell,
Alfred I. Delaware &
William Idsardi, vol. 2, 650-653. Philadelphia, Pa.: Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers.
Taylor, John R
2003 Linguistic Categorization (3rd ed.). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Tramo, Mark. J., Peter A. Cariani, Christine K. Koh, Nikos Makris & Louis D. Braida
2005 “
Neurophysiology and Neuroanatomy of Pitch Perception: Auditory cortex”.
Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 1060.148-174.
Tyler, Lorraine K., Emmanuel A. Stamatakis, Brechtje Post, Billi Randall & William Marslen-Wilson
2005 “
Temporal and Frontal Systems in Speech Comprehension: An fMRI study of past tense processing”.
Neuropsychologia 43:13.1963-1974.
Tzourio-Mazoyer, Nathalie, Brigitte Landeau, Dimitri Papathanassiou, Fabrice Crivello, Olivier Etard, Nicolas Delcroix, Bernard Mazoyer & Marc Joliot
2002 “
Automated Anatomical Labeling of Activations in SPM Using a Macroscopic Anatomical Parcellation of the MNI MRI Single-Subject Brain”.
NeuroImage 15:1.273-289.
Uldall, Elizabeth
1964 “
Dimensions of Meaning in Intonation”. In
Honour of Daniel Jones: Papers contributed on the occasion of his eightieth birthday ed. by
David Abercrombie, 271-279. London: Longman.
van Lancker, Diana
1980 “
Cerebral Lateralization of Pitch Cues in the Linguistic Signal”.
International Journal of Human Communication 13:2.201-277.
Wildgruber, Dirk, Ingo Hertrich, Axel Riecker, Michael Erb, Silke Anders, W. Wolfgang Grodd & Hermann Ackermann
2004 “
Distinct Frontal Regions Subserve Evaluation of Linguistic and Emotional Aspects of Speech Intonation”.
Cerebral Cortex 14:12.1384-1389.
Xi, Jie, Linjun Zhang, Hua Shu, Yang Zhang & Ping Li
2010 “
Categorical Perception of Lexical Tones in Chinese Revealed by Mismatch Negativity”.
Neuroscience 170:1.223-231.
Zatorre, Robert J., Alan C. Evans, Ernst Meyer & Albert Gjedde
1992 “
Lateralization of Phonetic and Pitch Discrimination in Speech Processing”.
Science 256.846-849.
Zhang, Linjun, Jie Xi, Guoqing Xu, Hua Shu, Xiaoyi Wang & Ping Li
2011 “
Cortical dynamics of acoustic and phonological processing in speech perception”.
PLoS One 6:6.e20963.
Cited by
Cited by 2 other publications
De Dominicis, Amedeo
2023.
Neurological Evidence of the Phonological Nature of Tones. In
Language Electrified [
Neuromethods, 202],
► pp. 647 ff.
Nolan, Francis
2020.
Intonation. In
The Handbook of English Linguistics,
► pp. 385 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 20 april 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.