Every time a scientist hears an idea and passes it on to somebody else, he is likely to change it somewhat.(Dawkins 1976 [1989]: 194)
(Dawkins 1976 [1989]: 194)
In this contribution I assess some mainstream approaches to functional changes of grammatical expressions with a focus on two concepts – ‘(secondary) grammaticalization’ and ‘exaptation’. As to the former, I argue that the most influential definition of ‘grammaticalization’ by Kuryłowicz’s (1965) results from a terminological accident rather than from a systematic observation or analysis of linguistic changes. The consequence is that various heterogeneous properties are nowadays associated with one and the same concept. Generally, ‘grammaticalization’ as well as other functional changes discussed in the literature are defined by the status of an expression before and after a change, not by the process itself. On this basis, I will argue that ‘exaptation’ is a concept distinct from other mainstream notions of language change, provided that the context of ‘evolution’ as a principle of variation and change, out of which ‘exaptation’ was brought into linguistics, is taken seriously.
Article outline
1.Linguistic metalanguage
Part I.Secondary grammaticalization
2.How ‘grammaticalization’ came to be what it is
2.1From lexical to grammatical – Antoine Meillet
2.2From grammatical to more grammatical – Jerzy Kuryłowicz
2.3Subsequent thoughts about grammaticalization – Christian Lehmann
2.4More about ‘more grammatical’ – “Secondary grammaticalization”
3.How grammaticalization and grammaticalization (do not) connect with each other
1995 “Regrammaticalization and degrammaticalization of the inchoative suffix.” Historical Linguistics 1993: Selected Papers from the 11th International Conference on Historical Linguistics, Los Angeles, 16–20 August 1993 ed. by Henning Andersen. (= Amsterdam Studies in the Theory and history of Linguistic Science. Series IV: Current Issues in Linguistic Theory, 124), 1–8. Amsterdam; Philadelphia, Pa.: Benjamins.
2008 “Grammaticalization in a speaker-oriented theory of change.” Historical Linguistics and the Theory of Grammar. The Rosendal Papers, ed. by Thórhallur Eythórsson. (= Linguistics Today, 113), 11–44. Amsterdam; Philadelphia, Pa.: Benjamins. .
2014 “What is secondary grammaticalization? Trying to see the wood for the trees in a confusion of interpretations.” Folia Linguistica 48.469–502.
Breban, Tine
2015 “Refining secondary grammaticalization by looking at subprocesses of change.” Language Sciences 47.161–171.
Brinton, Laurel J. & Dieter Stein
1995 “Functional renewal.” Historical Linguistics 1993: Selected Papers from the 11th International Conference on Historical Linguistics, Los Angeles, 16–20 August 1993, ed. by Henning Andersen. (= Amsterdam Studies in the Theory and history of Linguistic Science. Series IV: Current Issues in Linguistic Theory, 174), 33–47.Amsterdam; Philadelphia, Pa.: Benjamins.
Bybee, Joan L., William Pagliuca & Revere D. Perkins
1991 “Back to the Future.” Approaches to Grammaticalization. Volume II: Focus on Types of Grammatical Markers, ed. by Elizabeth Closs Traugott & Bernd Heine. (= Typological Studies in Language, 19.2), 17–58. Amsterdam; Philadelphia, Pa.: Benjamins.
Bybee, Joan L., Revere Perkins & William Pagliuca
1994The Evolution of Grammar: Tense, Aspect, and Modality in the Languages of the World. Chicago, Il.; London: University of Chicago Press.
Campbell, Lyle
1991 “Some Grammaticalization Changes in Estonian and their Implications.” Approaches to Grammaticalization. Volume I: Focus on Theoretical and Methodological Issues, ed. by Elizabeth Closs Traugott & Bernd Heine. (= Typological Studies in Language, 19.1), 285–299. Amsterdam; Philadelphia, Pa.: Benjamins.
Croft, William
2000Explaining Language Change: An Evolutionary Approach. Longman Linguistics Library. Harlow: Pearson.
Croft, William
2003Typology and Universals. Second edition. Cambridge Textbooks in Linguistics. Cambridge: CUP.
Croft, William
2006a “The relevance of an evolutionary model to historical linguistics.” Competing Models of Linguistic Change: Evolution and Beyond, ed. by Ole Nedergaard Thomsen. (= Amsterdam Studies in the Theory and History of Lingusitic science. Series IV: Current Issues in Linguistic Theory, 279), 91–132. Amsterdam; Philadelphia, Pa.: Benjamins.
Croft, William
2006b “Evolutionary Modles and Functional-Typological Theories of Language Change.” The Handbook of the History of English, ed. by Ans van Kemenade & Bettelou Los. (= Blackwell Handbooks in Linguistics), 68–91. Malden, Ma.; Oxford; Carlton: Blackwell.
Darwin, Charles
1859On the Origin of species by means of natural selection: or the preservation of favored races in the struggle for life. London.
Dawkins, Richard
1976 [1989]The Selfish Gene. Oxford: OUP.
De Cuypere, Ludovic
2005 “Exploring exaptation in language change.” Folia Linguistica Historica 26.13–26.
Dennett, Daniel C.
1995Darwin’s Dangerous Idea: Evolution and the Meaning of Life. New York, et al.: Simon & Schuster.
Detges, Ulrich & Richard Waltereit
2002 “Grammaticalization vs. Reanalysis: a Semantic-Pragmatic Account of Functional Change in Grammar.” Zeitschrift für Sprachwissenschaft 21.151–195.
Diewald, Gabriele
2010 “On some problem areas in grammaticalization studies.” Grammaticalization: Current views and issues, ed. by Katerina Stathi, Elke Gehweiler & Ekkerhard König. (= Studies in Language Companion Series, 119), 17–50. Amsterdam; Philadelphia, Pa.: Benjamins.
Giacalone Ramat, Anna
1998 “Testing the boundaries of grammaticalization.” The Limits of Grammaticalization, ed. by Anna Giacalone Ramat & Paul John Hopper. (= Typological Studies in Language, 37), 107–127. Amsterdam: Benjamins.
Giacalone Ramat, Anna & Paul J. Hopper
1998 “Introduction.” The Limits of Grammaticalization, ed. by Anna Giacalone Ramat & Paul J. Hopper. (= Typological Studies in Language, 37), 1–10. Amsterdam: Benjamins.
Givón, Talmy
1991 “The Evolution of Dependent Clause Morpho-syntax in Biblical Hebrew.” Approaches to Grammaticalization. Volume II: Focus on Types of Grammatical Markers, ed. by Elizabeth Closs Traugott & Bernd Heine. (= Typological Studies in Language, 19.2), 257–310. Amsterdam; Philadelphia, Pa.: Benjamins.
Gould, Stephen J.
1997 “The exaptive excellence of spandrels as a term and prototype.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 94.10750–10755.
Gould, Stephen J. & Richard C. Lewontin
1979 “The spandrels of San Marco and the Panglossian paradigm: a critique of the adaptionist programme.” Proceedings of the Royal Society London B 205.581–898.
Gould, Stephen J. & Elisabeth S. Vrba
1982 “Exaptation – a missing term in the science of form.” Paleobiology 8.4–15.
2011 “The gradual coalescence into ‘words’ in grammaticalization.” The Oxford Handbook of Grammaticalization, ed. by Heiko Narrog & Bernd Heine. (= Oxford Handbooks in Linguistics), 342–355. Oxford: OUP.
Heine, Bernd
2003 “On degrammaticalization.” Historical Linguistics 2001: Selected Papers from the 15th International Conference on Historical Linguistics, Melbourne, 13–17 August 2001, ed. by Barry J. Blake & Kate Burridge with the assistance of Jo Taylor. (= Amsterdam Studies in the Theory and History of Linguistic Science. Series IV: Current Issues in Linguistic Theory, 237), 163–179. Amsterdam: Benjamins.
1991Grammaticalization: A Conceptual Framework. Chicago, Il.; London: University of Chicago Press.
Hoenigswald, Henry M.
1963“Are There Universals of Linguistic Change?” Universals of Language: Report of a Conference Held at Dobbs Ferry, New York, April 13–15, 1961, ed. by Joseph H. Greenberg. Cambridge, Ma; London: MIT Press. 30–52.
Hopper, Paul J.
1987 “Emergent Grammar.” Berkeley Linguistic Society. Proceedings of the Thirteenth Annual Meeting, February 14–16, 1987: General Session and Parasession on Grammar and Cognition, ed. by Jon Askeet al. , 139–157. Berkeley: Berkeley Linguistic Society.
Hopper, Paul J. & Elizabeth Closs Traugott
2003Grammaticalization. Second edition. Cambridge Textbooks in Linguistics. Cambridge: CUP.
Hull, David L.
1988Science as a progress: an evolutionary account of the social and conceptual development of science. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Jacob, François
1977 “Evolution and Tinkering.” Science 196.1161–1166.
2005 “How Accommodating of Change is Grammaticalization? The Case of ‘Lateral Shifts’.” Logos and Language 6.1–7.
Joseph, Brian D.
2011 “Grammaticalization: a general critique.” The Oxford Handbook of Grammaticalization, ed. by Heiko Narrog & Bernd Heine. (= Oxford Handbooks in Linguistics), 193–205. Oxford: OUP.
1965 “The evolution of grammatical categories.” Diogenes 51.55–71.
Kuryłowicz, Jerzy
ed.1975Esquisses linguistiques II. (= Internationale Bibliothek für allgemeine Linguistik, 37). München: Fink.
Lass, Roger
1988 “How to do things with junk: exaptation in language evolution.” Stellenbosch Papers in Linguistics 17.33–62.
Lass, Roger
1990 “How to do things with junk: exaptation in language evolution.” Journal of Linguistics 26.79–102.
Lass, Roger
1997Historical Linguistics and Language Change. (= Cambridge Studies in Linguistics, 81.) Cambridge: CUP.
Lehmann, Christian
1982Thoughts on Grammaticalization: A programmatic sketch. (= Arbeiten des Kölner Universalien-Projekts, 48.) Köln: Institut für Sprachwissenschaft, Universität zu Köln (Typescript).
Lehmann, Christian
1995Thoughts on Grammaticalization. Revised and expanded version. First published edition. (= LINCOM Studies in Theoretical Linguistics, 1). München; Newcastle: Lincom Europa.
Lehmann, Christian
2015Thoughts on Grammaticalization. 3rd edition. (=Classics in Linguistics, 1). Berlin: Language Science Press.
Lévi-Strauss, Claude
1962La pensée sauvage. Paris: Plon.
Meillet, A[ntoine]
1912 “L’évolution des formes grammaticales.” Scientia (Rivista di Scienza) 6/12.384–400.
von Mengden, Ferdinand & Horst J. Simon
2014 “What is it then, this Grammaticalization?” Folia Linguistica 48.347–60.
Nørgård-Sørensen, Jens, Lars Heltoft & Lene Schøsler
2011Connecting Grammaticalisation. (= Studies in Functional and Structural Linguistics, 65). Amsterdam; Philadelphia, Pa.: Benjamins. .
Norde, Muriel
2009Degrammaticalization. Oxford: OUP.
Norde, Muriel
2001 “Deflexion as a counterdirectional factor in grammatical change.” Language Sciences 23.231–264.
Sapir, Edward
1921Language: An Introduction to the Study of Speech. New York: Harcourt, Brace & Company.
Simon, Horst J.
2010 “ ‘Exaptation’ in der Sprachwandeltheorie: Eine Begriffpräzisierung.” Prozesse sprachlicher Verstärkung: Typen formaler Resegmentierung und semantischer Remotivierung, hg. von Rüdiger Harnisch. (= Linguistik – Impulse & Tendenzen, 37), 41–57. Berlin; New York: de Gruyter.
Tauli, Valter
1958The Structural Tendencies of Languages. I: General Tendencies. (= Suomalaisen tiedeakatemian toimituksia. Sarja B 115,1). Helsinki: Akateeminen kirjakauppa.
Traugott, Elizabeth
2001 “Legitimate counterexamples to unidirectionality.” Paper presented at the University of Freiburg, 17 October 2001. See [URL]. Last access26 April 2015.
Traugott, Elizabeth Closs
2002 “From etymology to historical pragmatics.” Studies in the History of the English Language: A Millenial Perspective, ed. by Donka Minkova & Robert Stockwell. (= Topics in English Linguistics, 39), 19–49. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Traugott, Elizabeth C. & Graeme Trousdale
2013Constructionalization and Constructional Change. (= Oxford Studies in Diachronic and Historical Linguistics, 6). Oxford: OUP.
Van de Velde, Freek
2014 “Degeneracy: the maintainance of constructional networks.” The Extending Scope of Construction Grammar, ed. by Ronny Boogaart, Timothy Colleman & Gijsbert Rutten. (= Cognitive Linguistic Research, 54), 141–179. Berlin; Boston: Mouton de Gruyter.
Vincent, Nigel
1995 “Exaptation and grammaticalization.” Historical Linguistics 1993: Selected Papers from the 11th International Conference on Historical Linguistics, Los Angeles, 16–20 August 1993, ed. by Henning Andersen. (= Amsterdam Studies in the Theory and history of Linguistic Science. Series IV: Current Issues in Linguistic Theory, 124), 433–445. Amsterdam; Philadelphia, Pa.: Benjamins.
Wegener, Heide
2008 “The regrammaticalization of linking elements in German.” Theoretical and Empirical Issues in Grammaticalization, ed. by Elena Seoane & María José López-Couso in collaboration with Teresa Fanego. (= Typological Studies in Language, 77), 333–355. Amsterdam; Philadelphia, Pa.: Benjamins. .
Winter-Froemel, Esme
2014 “Re(de)fining grammaticalization from a usage-based perspective: Discoursive ambiguity in innovation scenarios.” Folia Linguistica 48.503–556.
Zeige, Lars Erik
2011Sprachwandel und soziale Systeme. (= Germanistische Linguistik Monographien, 27). Hildesheim; Zürich; New York: Olms.
Žirmunskij, Viktor M.
1961 “O granicach slova.” Voprosy jazykoznanija 3.3–21.
Žirmunskij, Viktor M.
1966 [1961] “The word and its boundaries.” Linguistics 27.65–91.
Cited by
Cited by 7 other publications
Konvička, Martin
2017. Ars obligatoria: searching for the medieval roots of obligatoriness. Language & History 60:3 ► pp. 153 ff.
Konvička, Martin
2017. De opkomst van de Nederlandse grammatica. Over grammaticalisatie en andere verwante ontwikkelingen in de geschiedenis van het Nederlands,
2019. Verbal –s. In Linguistic Perspectives on a Variable English Morpheme, ► pp. 25 ff.
Rupp, Laura & David Britain
2019. Verbal –s in Existential there Sentences. In Linguistic Perspectives on a Variable English Morpheme, ► pp. 237 ff.
Van de Velde, Freek
2018. Iterated Exaptation. In The Construction of Words [Studies in Morphology, 4], ► pp. 519 ff.
von Mengden, Ferdinand & Anneliese Kuhle
2020. Recontextualization and language change. Folia Linguistica 54:s41-s1 ► pp. 253 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 12 april 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.