Article published In:
Journal of Language and Politics: Online-First ArticlesRevisiting the rhetorical construction of political consent
‘We-strategies’ and pronouns in British and Russian Covid-19 discourse
How political leaders construct consent is a constant theme of studies in political rhetoric and theories of
persuasion. We explore how populist linguistic strategies combine with traditional consensus-building to align populations with
the speakers’ messages. We observe similarities and differences in discourse strategies across two contrasting polities, the UK,
a foundational modern representative democracy and Russia, which is considered more autocratic. The data comes from speeches
given by Boris Johnson and Vladimir Putin during the Covid-19 crisis. They were analysed using Corpus Linguistics, compared in
qualitative analysis that identities key lexico-grammatical features. The findings show a convergence in some of the strategies
and linguistic styles, but also key differences which, we suggest, depend on cultural factors specific to the two nations. The
results contribute to our understanding of the operation of these resources in modern political discourse, highlighting the way
cultural factors influence rhetorical styles in very different political structures.
Keywords: political discourse, persuasion, strategy of involvement, English, Russian
Article outline
- 1.Introduction: Background and research aims
- 2.We-strategy and the pragmatics of pronoun use
- 3.Data and methodology
- 4.Analysis
- 4.1Use of ‘we’
- 4.2Use of ‘I’
- 4.3Other lexical/ discursive means of construing community/solidarity
- 4.4Emotive persuasion, distance reduction, informality and populism
- 5.Conclusions
- Notes
-
References
Published online: 29 March 2024
https://doi.org/10.1075/jlp.22199.pon
https://doi.org/10.1075/jlp.22199.pon
References (60)
Aiolfi, Théo. 2022. Populism
as a Transgressive Style. Global Studies
Quarterly 1, no. 2. [URL].
Al-Salman, Saleh, and Ahmad S. Haider. 2021. “Covid-19
Trending Neologisms and Word Formation Processes in English.” Russian Journal of
Linguistics 25, no. 1: 24–42. [URL].
Aristotle and Robert C. Bartlett. 2019. Aristotle’s
Art of Rhetoric. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Benwell, Bethan and Elizabeth Stokoe. 2006. Discourse
and Identity. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
Bilá, Magdalena, Alena Kačmárová and Ingrida Vaňková. 2020. “The
Encounter of Two Cultural Identities: The Case of Social Deixis.” Russian Journal of
Linguistics 24, no. 2: 344–365.
Blondel, Jean and Ferdinand Müller-Rommel. 2009. “Political
Elites.” In The Oxford Handbook of Political
Behavior, edited by Russell J. Dalton and Hans-Dieter Klingemann. 818–32. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Brown, Penelope, and Stephen C. Levinson. 1987. Politeness:
Some universals in language
usage. Vol. 41. Cambridge, Cambridge university press.
Busygina, Irina and Mikhail Filippov. 2015. “The
Calculus of Non-Protest in Russia: Redistributive Expectations from Political
Reforms.” Europe-Asia
Studies 67, no. 2: 209–223.
Castro Seixas, Eunice. 2021. “War
Metaphors in Political Communication on Covid-19.” Frontiers in
Sociology. 2020.
Charteris-Black, Jonathan. 2004. Politicians
and Rhetoric: The Persuasive Power of
Metaphor. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
Chen, Chinchih, Frey Carl, Benedikt and Giorgio Presidente. 20221. “Culture
and Contagion: Individualism and Compliance with Covid-19 Policy.” Journal of Economic Behavior
and
Organisation, no. 190 (October): 191–200.
Chilton, Paul A. 2004. Analysing Political Discourse: Theory
and Practice. London and New York: Routledge.
Chilton, Paul A., and Christina Schäffner. 2011. “Discourse
and Politics.” In Discourse Studies: A Multidisciplinary
Introduction, edited by Teun Van Dijk. 303–330. London: Sage.
Churchill, Winston. 1940. “First
Speech as Prime Minister to the House of Commons.” Accessed February 12, 2024. [URL]
De Fina, Anna. 1995. “Pronominal
Choice, Identity and Solidarity in Political Discourse.” Text – Interdisciplinary Journal for
the Study of
Discourse 15, no. 3: 379–410.
Duszak, Anna. 2002. Us
and Others: Social Identities Across Languages, Discourses and
Cultures. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Fairclough, Norman, and Ruth Wodak. 1997. “Critical
Discourse Analysis.” In Discourse Studies: A Multidisciplinary
Introduction Vol.
2
1, edited by Teun van Dijk. 258–284. London: Sage.
Fairclough, Norman, and Isabela Fairclough. 2012. Political
Discourse Analysis. New York: Routledge.
Fetzer, Anita. 2008. “And
I think that is a Very Straightforward Way of Dealing with it. The Communicative Function of Cognitive Verbs in Political
Discourse.” Journal of Language and Social
Psychology 27, no. 4 (December): 384–396.
Flinders, Matthew. 2020. “Not
a Brexit election? Pessimism, Promises and Populism UK-style.” Parliamentary
Affairs, no. 1 (September): 225–42.
Fuchs, Christian. 2021. “Everyday
life and everyday communication in coronavirus
capitalism.” In Communicating COVID-19: Everyday Life, Digital
Capitalism, and Conspiracy Theories in Pandemic Times. Emerald Publishing. 17–61. .
Gardelle, Laure, and Sandrine Sorlin. 2015. The
Pragmatics of Personal Pronouns. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Halmari, Helena. 2008. “On
the Language of the Clinton-Dole Presidential Campaign Debates. General Tendencies and Successful
Strategies.” Journal of Language and
Politics 7, no. 2: 247–270.
Hofstede, Guy. 2001. Culture’s
Consequences: Comparing Values, Behaviors, Institutions, and Organizations Across Nations, 2nd
ed. Thousand Oaks: Sage.
Hunston, Susan. 2007. “Semantic
Prosody Revisited.” International Journal of Corpus
Linguistics 12, no. 2: 249–68.
Kopytowska, Monika., and Radoslaw Krakowiak. 2020. “Online
Incivility in Times of Covid-19: Social Disunity and Misperceptions of Tourism Industry in
Poland.” Russian Journal of
Linguistics 24, no. 4: 743–773.
Krzyżanowski, Michal and Natalia Krzyżanowska. 2022. “Narrating
the ‘New Normal’ or Pre-Legitimising Media Control? Covid-19 and the Discursive Shifts in the Far-Right Imaginary of ‘Crisis’
as a Normalisation Strategy.” Discourse and
Society 33, no. 6: 805–18.
Krzyżanowski, Michał, Ekman, Mattias, Nilsson, Per-Erik, Gardell, Mattias and Christian Christensen. 2021. “Uncivility,
Racism, and Populism: Discourses and Interactive Practices in Anti- and Post-Democratic
Communication.” Nordicom Review 42 (Special
Issue): 3–15.
Krzyżanowski, Michal and Mats Ekstrom. 2022. “The
Normalization of Far-Right Populism and Nativist Authoritarianism: Discursive Practices in Media, Journalism and the Wider
Public Sphere/s” Discourse and
Society 33, no. 6.
Krzyżanowski, Michał, and Mats Ekström. 2022. “The
normalization of far-right populism and nativist authoritarianism: Discursive practices in media, journalism and the wider
public sphere/s.” Discourse &
Society 33 (6): 719–729.
Krämer, Benjamin, and Christina Holtz-Bacha. 2020. Perspectives
on Populism and the Media: Avenues for
Research. Baden-Baden: Nomos.
Kroenig, Matthew. 2020. The
Return of Great Power Rivalry: Democracy versus Autocracy from the Ancient World to the U.S. and
China. New York: Oxford University Press.
Larina, Tatiana. 2015. “Culture-specific
Communicative Styles as a Framework for Interpreting Linguistic and Cultural
Idiosyncrasies.” International Review of
Pragmatics 2, no. 7: 195–215.
Larina, Tatiana, Mustajoki Arto and Ekaterina Protassova. 2017. “Dimensions
of Russian Culture and Mind.” In Philosophical and Cultural
Interpretations of Russian Modernisation, edited by Katja Lehtisaari and Arto Mustajok. 7–19. London and New York: Routledge.
Larina, Tatiana and Douglas Mark Ponton. 2020. “Tact
or Frankness in English and Russian Blind Peer Reviews.” Intercultural
Pragmatics 4, no. 17: 471–96.
Lassila, Jussi. 2018. “Putin
as a Non-Populist Autocrat.” Russian
Politics 3, no. 2 (June): 175–195.
Macagno, Fabrizio. 2014. “Manipulating
Emotions: Value-Based Reasoning and Emotive Language.” Argumentation and
Advocacy 51, no. 2: 103–22.
Mamontov, Vladimir D., Tatiana M. Kozhevnikova, and Yana Y. Radyukova. 2014. “Collectivism
and Individualism in Modern Russia.” Asia Social
Science 10, no. 23 (November): 199–207.
Mehta, Jayur Madhusudan, Chakrabarti Choeeta, De Leon Jessica, Homan Patricia, Skipton Tara, and Rachel Sparkman. 2023. “Assessing
the Role of Collectivism and Individualism on Covid-19 Beliefs and Behaviors in the Southeastern United
States.” PLoS
ONE 18, no. 1 (January).
Naumov, Alexander, and Sheila Puffer. 2020. “Measuring
Russian Culture using Hofstede’s Dimensions.” Applied
Psychology 49, no. 4: 709–718.
Pavlina, Svetlana Y. 2022. “Pragmatic and Stylistic
Perspectives on British and American Covid-19 Cartoons.” Russian Journal of
Linguistics 26, no. 1: 162–193.
Ponton, Douglas Mark. 2021. “Never in my Life have I
Heard such a Load of absolute Nonsense. Wtf.” Political Satire on the Handling of the Covid-19
Crisis”. Russian Journal of
Linguistics 3, no. 25: 767–788.
Ponton, Douglas Mark, Ozyumenko Vladimir and Tatiana Larina. 2023. “Lingua-Cultural
Identity in Translation: ‘We’ vs ‘I’ Cultures.” Journal of Language and
Education 41, no. 91: 73–84.
Ponton, Douglas Mark and Davletshina, Dilyara. 2022. “Poems
in Lockdown: Cultural Aspects of English and Russian Coroneologisms.” Topics in
Linguistics 1, no. 23 (June): 24–38.
Purnell, Sonia. 2022. “Reality
is Closing in on Boris Johnson, a Narcissist Scared of What He has
Unleashed.” Accessed 12
February, 2022. [URL]
Schnepf, Julia, and Ursula Christmann. 2021. “It’s
a War! It’s a Battle! It’s a Fight!: Do Militaristic Metaphors Increase People’s Threat Perceptions and Support for Covid-19
Policies?” International Journal of
Psychology 57, no 1: 107–126.
Tower, Rupert Kinglake, Caroline Kelly, and Anne Richards. 1997. “Individualism,
collectivism and reward allocation: A cross-cultural study in Russia and Britain.” British
Journal of Social
Psychology 36(3): 331–345.
Van Dijk, Teun. 1993. “Principles
of Critical Discourse Analysis.” Discourse and
Society 4, no. 2 (April): 249–83.
. 2013. “Ideological
Discourse Analysis.” Accessed 12
Febraury 2024. [URL]
Van Leeuwen, Theo. 1996. “The
Representation of Social Actors.” In Texts and Practices: Readings in
Critical Discourse Analysis, edited by Malcolm Coulthard and Carmen Rosa Caldas-Coulthard. 32–70. London and New York: Routledge.
Waylen, Georgina. 2021. “Gendering
Political Leadership: Hypermasculine Leadership and Covid-19.” Journal of European Public
Policy 28, no. 8: 1153–73.
Wierzbicka, Anna. 2003/1991. Cross-Cultural
Pragmatics: The Semantics of Human Interaction. Berlin and New York: Mouton de Gruyter.
. 1994. Cultural
Scripts: A Semantic Approach to Cultural Analysis and Cross-Cultural Communication. Pragmatics
and Language
Learning 51: 1–25.
Wilson, John. 1990. Politically
Speaking: The Pragmatic Analysis of Political Language. Oxford, UK and Cambridge, Mass: Blackwell
Wilson, Nick. 2019. “When
we means you: The social meaning of English pseudoinclusive personal
pronouns”, in Paul Bouissac (ed), The
Social Dynamics of Pronominal Systems. A comparative
approach. Amsterdam, John Benjamins (ebook), .
Winter Eugene, O. 1977. “A
Clause-Relational Approach to English texts: A Study of Some Predictive Lexical Items in Written
Discourse.” Instructional
Science 6, no. 1: 1–92.