Preverbal word order in Old English and Old French
Old English (OE) and Old French (OF) are often referred to as verb-second (V2) languages. While it is the case that the verb may appear in second clause position after a non-subject-initial element in both languages, they are dissimilar in a number of features. In this paper, we consider the preverbal elements of OE and OF main clauses in which the subject also precedes the verb. First we give an overview of the word order distribution of the preverbal elements. Then we go on to consider the syntactic implications of the empirical findings, showing that OF is a homogeneous language with true V2 syntax, whereas OE has a much looser syntax. In the last section, we show how the syntax of OE provides a frame within which contextual factors are allowed to play their part in a subtle manner, a possibility OF does not have. We conclude that using the tag ‘V2’ in a comparison of the two languages does more to mask their nature than to reveal it.
References
Primary sources
Bately, Janet
(ed)
1980
The Old English Orosius
. EETS s.s. 6. London: OUP.
Clark, Cecily
(ed)
1958
The Peterborough Chronicle
1070–1154. London: OUP.
Lalou, Elisabeth, Boutet, Dominique & Gaucher, Elisabeth
(eds)
2001
Le Roman de Tristan en Prose
, chapters 244–319, extracted from the database
Corpus de la Littérature Médiévale: En Langue d’Oil des Origines à la Fin du XVe Siècle: Prose Narrative – Poésie – Théâtre
. Paris: Champion Electronique.
La Mort Artu
data extracted from the ISWOC corpus (under construction).
[URL]>
Miller, Thomas
(ed)
1890
The Old English Version of Bede’s Ecclesiastical History of the English People
. EETS o.s 95, 96. London: Trübner & Co.
Skeat, Walter W
ed.). 1881–1885.
Ælfric’s Lives of Saints,
Vol. I, i & ii. EETS o.s. 76, 82. London: Trübner & Co.
Thorpe, Benjamin
(ed)
1834
The Anglo-Saxon Version of the Story of Apollonius of Tyre
. London: John and Arthur Arch.
Adams, Marianne
1987 From Old French to the theory of pro-drop.
Natural Language and Linguistic Theory
5: 1–32.
Adams, Marianne
1989 Verb second effects in Medieval French. In
Studies in Romance Linguistics: Selected Papers from the Seventeenth Linguistic Symposium on Romance Languages (xvii. lsrl), Rutgers University, 27–29 March
1987 [Current Issues in Linguistic Theory 60j],
Carl Kirschner &
Janet Ann DeCesaris (eds), 1–33. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Asher, Nicolas & Lascarides, Alex
2003
Logics of Conversation
. Cambridge: CUP.
Bech, Kristin
1998 Pragmatic factors in language change: XVS and XSV clauses in Old and Middle English.
Folia Linguistica Historica
XIX(1–2): 79–102.
Bech, Kristin
2001 Word Order Patterns in Old and Middle English: A Syntactic and Pragmatic Study. PhD dissertation, University of Bergen.
[URL]>
Bech, Kristin
2005 SXVX clauses in Old and Middle English. In
Contexts – Historical, Social, Linguistic. Studies in Celebration of Toril Swan
,
Kevin McCafferty,
Tove Bull &
Kristin Killie (eds), 145–162. Bern: Peter Lang.
Bech, Kristin
2008 Verb types and word order in Old and Middle English. In
English Historical Linguistics
2006, Vol. I:
Syntax and Morphology
,
Maurizio Gotti,
Marina Dossena &
Richard Dury, 49–67. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Bech, Kristin
2012 Word order, information structure, and discourse relations: a study of Old and Middle English verb-final clauses. In
Information Structure and Syntactic Change in the History of English
,
Anneli Meurman-Solin,
María José López-Couso &
Bettelou Los (eds), 66–86. Oxford: OUP.
Bech, Kristin
To appear.
Tracing the loss of boundedness in the history of English: the anaphoric status of initial prepositional phrases in Old English and late Middle English.
Anglia
.
Benincà, Paola
2006 A detailed map of the left periphery of Medieval Romance. In
Crosslinguistic Research in Syntax and Semantics: Negation, Tense, and Clausal Architecture
,
Raffaella Zanuttini,
Héctor Campos,
Elena Herburger &
Paul H. Portner (eds), 53–86. Washington DC: Georgetown University Press.
Benincà, Paola & Poletto, Cecilia
2004 Topic, focus, and V2. In
The Structure of CP and IP: Oxford Studies in Comparative Syntax
,
Luigi Rizzi (ed), 52–75. Oxford: OUP.
Buridant, Claude
2000
Grammaire nouvelle de l’ancien français
. Paris: Sedes.
Cardinaletti, Anna & Starke, Michael
1999 The typology of structural deficiency: A case study of the three classes of pronuns. In
Clitics in the Languages of Europe
,
Henk van Riemdsijk (ed.), 145–233. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Chafe, Wallace L
1976 Givenness, contrastiveness, definiteness, subjects, topics and point of view. In
Subject and Topic
,
Charles N. Li (ed.), 27–55. New York NY: Academic Press.
Cinque, Guglielmo
1997
Adverbs and Functional Heads: A Cross-Linguistic Perspective
[University of Venice: Working Papers in Linguistics 7, 1–2]. Venice: Università Ca’Foscari di Venezia.
Cinque, Guglielmo
1990
Types of A’-Dependencies
. Cambridge MA: The MIT Press.
Donaldson, Bryan
2012a Diachronic change in Old French clause structure: Effects on initial subordinate clauses. Ms.
Donaldson, Bryan
2012b Initial subordinate clauses in Old French: Syntactic variation and the clausal left periphery.
Lingua
122: 1021–1046.
Fiéis, Maria Alexandra
2003 Ordem de palavras, transitividade e inacusatividade. Reflexão teórica e análise do português dos séculos XIII a XVI. PhD dissertation, Universidade Nova de Lisboa.
Fischer, Olga
1992 Syntax. In
The Cambridge History of the English Language
,
Norman Blake (ed.), 207–408. Cambridge: CUP.
Fischer, Olga, van Kemenade, Ans, Koopman, Willem, & van der Wurff, Wim
2000
The Syntax of Early English
. Cambridge: CUP.
Foulet, Lucien
1930
Petite syntaxe de l’ancien francais
. Paris: Champion.
Frascarelli, Mara & Hinterhölzl, Roland
2007 Types of topics in German and Italian. In
On Information Structure, Meaning and Form
[Linguistik Aktuell/Linguistics Today 100],
Kerstin Schwabe &
Susanne Winkler (eds), 87–116. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Galves, Charlotte & de Sousa, Maria Clara Paixão
2005 Clitic placement and the position of subjects in the history of Portuguese. In
Romance Languages and Linguistic Theory
2003 [Current Issues in Linguistic Theory 270],
Twan Geerts,
Ivo van Ginneken &
Haike Jacobs (eds), 97–113. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Grohmann, Kleanthes K
2000 Copy left dislocation. In
Proceedings of the Nineteenth West Coast Conference on Formal Linguistics
,
Roger Billerey &
Brook Danielle Lillehaugen (eds), 139–152. Somerville MA: Cascadilla Press.
van Gelderen, Elly
Forthcoming.
Pro-drop and pronominal subjects: Reanalyzing features in the history of English.
Haeberli, Eric
2000 Adjuncts and the syntax of subjects in Old and Middle English. In
Diachronic Syntax: Models and Mechanisms
,
Susan Pintzuk,
George Tsoulas &
Anthony Warner (eds), 109–131. Oxford: OUP.
Haeberli, Eric
2002 Inflectional morphology and the loss of V2 in English. In
Syntactic Effects of Morphological Change
,
David Lightfoot (ed), 88–106. Oxford: OUP.
Hasselgård, Hilde
2010
Adjunct Adverbials in English
. Cambridge: CUP.
Heggelund, Øystein Imerslund
2009 Word Order in Old English and Middle English Subordinate Clauses. PhD dissertation, University of Bergen.
Holmberg, Anders
In press.
Verb second. In
Syntax – an International Handbook of Contemporary Syntactic Research
,
Tibor Kiss &
Artemis Alexiadou (eds). Berlin: Walter de Gruyter.
Holmberg, Anders & Platzack, Christer
1995
The Role of Inflection in Scandinavian Syntax
. Oxford: OUP.
Kayne, Richard S
1994
The Antisymmetry of Syntax
. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.
van Kemenade, Ans
1987
Syntactic Case and Morphological Case in the History of English
. Dordrecht: Foris.
van Kemenade, Ans & Mili?ev, Tanja
2012 Syntax and discourse in Old and Middle English word order. In
Grammatical Change: Origins, Nature, Outcomes
,
Dianne Jonas,
John Whitman &
Andrew Garrett (eds), 239–255. Oxford: OUP.
van Kemenade, Ans & Westergaard, Marit
2012 Syntax and information Structure: V2 variation in Middle English. In
Information Structure and Syntactic Change in the History of English
,
Anneli Meurman-Solin,
María José López-Couso &
Bettelou Los (eds), 87–118. Oxford: OUP.
van Kemenade, Ans, Mili?ev, Tanja & Baayen, R. Harald
2007 The balance between syntax and discourse in Old English. In
English Historical Linguistics
2006, Vol. I:
Syntax and Morphology [Current Issues in Linguistic Theory 295],
Maurizio Gotti,
Marina Dossena &
Richard Dury (eds), 3–21. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Koopman, Willem
1995 Verb-final main clauses in Old English prose.
Studia Neophilologica
67:129–144.
Krifka, Manfred
2007 Basic notions of information structure.
Interdisciplinary Studies on Information Structure
6: 13–55.
Labelle, Marie
2007 Clausal architecture in Early Old French.
Lingua
117: 289–316.
Labelle, Marie & Hirschbühler, Paul
2005 Changes in clausal organization and the position of clitics in Old French. In
Grammaticalization and Parametric Change
,
Montse Batllori,
Maria-Lluisa Hernanz,
Carme Picallo &
Francesc Roca (eds), 60–71. Oxford: OUP.
Lambrecht, Knud
1994
Information Structure and Sentence Form
. Cambridge: CUP.
Ledgeway, Adam
2008 Satisfying V2 in early Romance: Merge vs. Move.
Journal of Linguistics
44(2): 437–470.
Lightfoot, David
1979
Principles of Diachronic Syntax
. Cambridge: CUP.
Lightfoot, David
1999
The Development of Language. Acquisition, Change and Evolution
. Oxford: Blackwell.
Los, Bettelou
2009 The consequences of the loss of verb-second in English: information structure and syntax in interaction.
English Language and Linguistics
13(1): 97–125.
Los, Bettelou
2012 The loss of verb-second and the switch from bounded to unbounded systems. In
Information Structure and Syntactic Change in the History of English
,
Anneli Meurman-Solin,
María José López-Couso &
Bettelou Los (eds), 21–46. Oxford: OUP.
Los, Bettelou & Dreschler, Gea
2012 The loss of local anchoring: From adverbial local anchors to permissive subjects. In
The Oxford Handbook of the History of English
,
Terttu Nevalainen &
Elizabeth Closs Traugott (eds), 859–872. Oxford: OUP.
Marchello-Nizia, Christiane
2000 Le décumul du “thème” dans l’evolution du français.
Français Moderne
68(1): 31–40.
Mathieu, Éric
2006 Stylistic Fronting in Old French.
Probus
18: 219–266.
Mathieu, Éric
2012 The left-periphery in Old French. In
Research on Old French: The State of the Art
,
Deborah Arteaga (ed.), 327–350. Dordrecht: Springer.
Petrova, Svetlana & Solf, Michael
Petrova, Svetlana & Speyer, Augustin
2011 Focus movement and focus interpretation in Old English.
Lingua
121: 1751–1765.
Pintzuk, Susan
1993 Verb-seconding in Old English: verb movement to Infl.
The Linguistic Review
10: 5–35.
Pintzuk, Susan
1999
Phrase Structures in Competition: Variation and Change in Old English Word Order
. New York NY: Garland.
Pintzuk, Susan & Haeberli, Eric
2008 Structural variation in Old English root clauses.
Language Variation and Change
20: 367–407.
Platzack, Christer
1995 The loss of verb second in English and French. In
Clause Structure and Language Change
,
Adrian Battye &
Ian Roberts (eds), 200–226. Oxford: OUP.
Poletto, Cecilia
2002 The left-periphery of V2-Rhaetoromance dialects: a new view on V2 and V3. In
Syntactic Microvariation
[The Meertens Institute Electronic Publications in Linguistics (MIEPiL) 2],
Susanne van der Kleij,
Sjef Barbiers &
Leonie Cornips (eds). Amsterdam: Meertens Institute.
[URL]>
Poletto, Cecilia
2006 Parallel phases: A study on the high and low left periphery of Old Italian. In
Phases of Interpretation
,
Mara Frascarelli (ed.), 261–294. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Poletto, Cecilia
2011 Topics (and focus) in Old Italian Syntax. Ms.
Prévost, Sophie
2001
La postposition du sujet en français aux 15ème et 16ème siècles: Une approche sémantico-pragmatique
. Paris: Editions du CNRS.
Prévost, Sophie
2009 Topicalisation, focalisation et constructions syntaxiques en français médiéval. In
Les linguistiques du détachement: Actes du Colloque International de Nancy
,
Denis Apothéloz,
Bernard Combettes &
Franck Neveu (eds), 427–439. Bern: Peter Lang.
Radwan, Sonja
2011 L’ordre des mots en ancien français – La syntaxe et la structure informationnelle de la zone préverbale. MA thesis, University of Oslo.
Ribeiro, Ilza
1995 Evidence for a verb-second phase in Old Portuguese. In
Clause Structure and Language Change
,
Adrian Battye &
Ian Roberts (eds), 110–139. Oxford: OUP.
Rinke, Esther
2007
Syntaktische Variation aus synchronischer und diachronischer Perspektive: Die Entwicklung der Wortstellung im Portugiesischen
. Frankfurt: Vervuert.
Rinke, Esther & Meisel; Jürgen M
2009 Subject inversion in Old French: Syntax and information structure. In
Proceedings of the Workshop “Null-subjects, Expletives, and Locatives in Romance”
,
Georg A. Kaiser &
Eva Maria Remberger (eds), 93–130. Constance: Universität Konstanz.
Rizzi, Luigi
1997 The fine structure of the left periphery. In
Elements of Grammar: Handbook of Generative Syntax
,
Liliane Haegeman (ed.), 281–337. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Roberts, Ian G
1993
Verbs and Diachronic Syntax: A Comparative History of English and French
. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Salvesen, Christine Meklenborg
2009 Le CP interrogatif: Une étude diachronique du français. PhD dissertation, University of Oslo.
Salvesen, Christine Meklenborg
2011 Stylistic fronting and remnant movement in Old French. In
Romance Languages and Linguistic Theory 2009. Selected Papers from “Going Romance” Nice
2009 [Romance Languages and Linguistic Theory 3],
Janine Berns,
Haike Jacobs &
Tobias Scheer (eds), 323–342. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Salvi, Giampaolo
2004
La formazione della struttura di frase romanza: Ordine delle parole e clitici dal latino alle lingue romanze antiche
. Tübingen: Max Niemeyer.
Schwartz, Bonnie D. & Vikner, Sten
1996 The verb always leaves IP in V2 clauses. In
Parameters and Functional Heads: Essays in Comparative Syntax
,
Luigi Rizzi &
Adriana Belletti (eds), 244–302. Oxford: OUP.
Speyer, Augustin
2008 Topicalization and Clash Avoidance in the History of English, with a Few Glimpses at German. PhD dissertation, University of Pennsylvania.
Taylor, Ann & Pintzuk, Susan
2011 The interaction of syntactic change and information status in the change from OV to VO in English.
Catalan Journal of Linguistics
10: 71–94.
Taylor, Ann & Pintzuk, Susan
2012 The effect of information structure on object position in Old English. In
Information Structure and Syntactic Change in the History of English
,
Anneli Meurman-Solin,
María José López-Couso &
Bettelou Los (eds), 47–65. Oxford: OUP.
Taylor, Ann & Pintzuk, Susan
To appear. Verb order, object position and information status in Old English. In
Syntax over Time: Lexical, Morphological and Information-structural Interactions
,
Theresa Biberauer &
George Walkden (eds). Oxford: OUP.
Thurneysen, Rudolf
1892 Zur Stellung des Verbums im Altfranzösischen.
Zeitschrift für Romanische Philologie
XVI: 289–307.
Vance, Barbara S
1997
Syntactic Change in Medieval French: Verb-Second and Null Subjects
. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Walkden, George Lee
2012 Syntactic Reconstruction and Proto-Germanic. PhD dissertation, Cambridge University.
Walkden, George
In press.
Verb-third in early West Germanic: a comparative perspective. In
Peripheries Past and Present: The Interaction of Information Structure, Prosody and Syntax
,
Theresa Biberauer &
George Walkden (eds). Oxford: OUP.
Warner, Anthony
2007 Parameters of variation between verb-subject and subject-verb order in late Middle English.
English Language and Linguistics
11(1): 81–111.
Zwart, C
Jan-Wouter
1997
Morphosyntax of Verb Movement: A Minimalist Approach to the Syntax of Dutch
. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Cited by
Cited by 3 other publications
Jurczyk, Rafał
2021.
Between feature mapping and thematic prominence: Old englishse-demonstratives and pronouns in discourse.
Poznan Studies in Contemporary Linguistics 57:4
► pp. 573 ff.
Eric Mathieu & Robert Truswell
2017.
Micro-change and Macro-change in Diachronic Syntax,
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 20 april 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.