An examination of the validity of metaphor analysis studies
Problems with metaphor elicitation techniques
Wan Wan | Department of Education, University of York (UK)
The last decade has seen a large number of studies employing metaphor elicitation techniques, especially using ‘X is (like) Y’ format to investigate language teachers’ and learners’ understandings of teaching and/or learning. Although a few recent studies have reported the proportion of unsuccessful answers to this type of task, and identified a number of issues connected with task difficulty, there appears to be little published work that has seriously addressed the validity of the method used. The aims of this paper are therefore to explore the discourse and contexts where failure/difficulty with the metaphor elicitation task occurs, to try and understand what causes the problems and to suggest approaches to resolving them. In so doing, this paper reports on two small-scale metaphor analysis studies that were primarily designed to reduce the incidence of difficulty with ‘X is (like) Y’ metaphor prompts, presenting the perceived reasons for the difficulties and discussing possible solutions by introducing training in the form of four ready-made metaphor related teaching sessions. Essentially, I argue that training both about metaphor and in using it are important, and that thought needs to be given to both the nature and the length of training. The hope is that the present paper can be a first step and will serve to shed light on the ways that can be employed by metaphor researchers to identify and then resolve their methodological problems.
2024. English learners’ beliefs about L2 speaking fluency: Insights from elicited metaphor analysis. The Modern Language Journal 108:3 ► pp. 719 ff.
Ewertowska, Tanya, Katherine Ravenswood & Julie Douglas
2023. Centring participant voices through metaphor in employment relations research. Labour and Industry► pp. 1 ff.
Tay, Dennis
2023. Turning metaphor on its head: a “target-to-source transformation” approach in statistics education. Frontiers in Psychology 14
Isobel, Sophie, Andrea McCloughen & Kim Foster
2020. A frog in boiling water? A qualitative analysis of psychiatrists’ use of metaphor in relation to psychological trauma. Australasian Psychiatry 28:6 ► pp. 656 ff.
2019. Map, Foundations, Recipe, Burden: Teachers’ Conceptual Metaphors on Lesson Planning. DELTA: Documentação de Estudos em Lingüística Teórica e Aplicada 35:4
Kelso, Josephine Meadows
2018. Boundaries and hybrid blends: How one multilingual narrator displays symbolic competence in a college writing class. Linguistics and Education 45 ► pp. 50 ff.
2014. Constructing and developing ESL students’ beliefs about writing through metaphor: An exploratory study. Journal of Second Language Writing 23 ► pp. 53 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 19 september 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.