Cover not available
Part of
A Pragmatic Agenda for Healthcare: Fostering inclusion and active participation through shared understanding
Edited by Sarah Bigi and Maria Grazia Rossi
[Pragmatics & Beyond New Series 338] 2023
► pp. 359–372

Chapter 15
On indicating and dealing with uncertainty in healthcare dialogues

Questions and findings for medical practice and teaching

| Universitätsklinikum Hamburg-Eppendorf
| Universität Hamburg
| Universitätsklinikum Hamburg-Eppendorf
In the context of diagnostic uncertainty moments of irritation can arise, which linguistically disguise uncertainty of the physicians or result in uncertainty on the patient’s side. We investigated the occurrence of uncertainty in history-taking encounters by reconstructing the dealing with uncertainty within the interaction process. The analysis is based on data from a simulation where medical students in the physician’s role interact with simulated patients. In the case study, our hermeneutical in-depth-analysis of one interaction process between a medical student and a patient reveals a certain communication pattern by the medical student resulting from an emerging dilemma which consists of a diagnostically unreasonable procedure but an offer of ‘at least something’ to the desperate patient.
Keywords: physician-patient communication, uncertainty, clinical reasoning
Article outline
  • 1.Background
  • 2.Methods
  • 3.Results
    • The honest rejection
    • The battery
    • The renewal
    • The best possible way
  • 4.Discussion
  • References
  • Appendix
Published online: 17 November 2023
DOI logo
https://doi.org/10.1075/pbns.338.15gar
References (41)
References
Ariss, Steven M. 2009. “Asymmetrical Knowledge Claims in General Practice Consultations with Frequently Attending Patients: Limitations and Opportunities for Patient Participation.” Social Science & Medicine 69 (6): 908–919. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Bühler, Karl. 1934. Sprachtheorie. Zur Darstellungsfunktion der Sprache. München: Fink.Google Scholar
Bührig, Kristin. 2000. “Überlegungen zum Dialog in Georg Büchners Woyzeck – auch ein (dramatischer) Lesevorschlag.” Osnabrücker Beiträge zur Sprachtheorie (OBST) 61:43–66.Google Scholar
Cantarini, Sibilla, Abraham, Werner, and Elizabeth Leiss. 2014. Certainty-Uncertainty – and the Attitudinal Space in Between. Amsterdam, Philadelphia: Benjamins. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Delbanco, Tom, and Sigall K. Bell. 2007. “Guilty, Afraid, and Alone – Struggling with Medical Error.” New England Journal of Medicine 357 (17): 1682–1683. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Dockweiler, Christoph, and Claudia Hornberg. 2016. “Neue Technologien und alte Ungleichheiten?” In Ein sozialethischer Diskursbeitrag zur Einführung und Nutzung telemedizinischer Verfahren. In eHealth 2016: Informations- und Kommunikationstechnologien im Gesundheitswesen, edited by Frank Duesberg, 190–192. Solingen: Medical Future Verlag.Google Scholar
Ehlich, Konrad 1979. Verwendung der Deixis beim sprachlichen Handeln. Linguistisch-philologisch Untersuchungen zum hebräischen deiktischen System. Frankfurt am Main.: Lang.Google Scholar
. 1982. “Deiktische und phorische Prozeduren beim literarischen Erzählen.” In Erzählforschung, edited by Eberhard Lämmert, 112–129. Stuttgart: Metzler.Google Scholar
. 1987. “Kooperation und sprachliches Handeln.” In Kommunikation und Kooperation, edited by Frank Liedtke, and Rudi Keller, 19–32. Tübingen: Niemeyer. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Ehlich, Konrad, and Jochen Rehbein. 1976. “Halbinterpretative Arbeitstranskriptionen (HIAT).” Linguistische Berichte 45: 21–41.Google Scholar
. 1977a. “Batterien sprachlicher Handlungen.” Journal of Pragmatics 1: 393–406. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
. 1977b. “Wissen, kommunikatives Handeln und die Schule.” In Sprachverhalten im Unterricht, edited by Herma C. Goeppert., 36–114.” München: Fink.Google Scholar
. 1986. Muster und Institution. Untersuchungen zur schulischen Kommunikation. Tübingen: Narr.Google Scholar
Gärtner, Julia, Prediger, Sarah, and Sigrid Harendza. 2021a. “Development and Pilot Test of ComCare – a Questionnaire for Quick Assessment of Communicative and Social Competences in Medical Students after Interviews with Simulated Patients.” GMS Journal of Medical Education 38 (3): Doc68.Google Scholar
Gärtner, Julia, Bußenius, Lisa, Schick, Kristina, Prediger, Sarah, Kadmon, Martina, Berberat, Pascal O., and Sigrid Harendza. 2021b. “Validation of the ComCare Index for Rater-Based Assessment of Medical Communication and Interpersonal Skills.” Patient Education and Counseling Jul 30: S0738–3991 (21)00512–7.Google Scholar
Ghosh, Amit K. 2004a. “On the Challenges of Using Evidence-Based Information: The Role of Clinical Uncertainty.” The Journal of Laboratory and Clinical Medicine 144 (2): 60–64. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
2004b. “Understanding Medical Uncertainty: A Primer for Physicians.” JAPI 52: 739–742.Google Scholar
2004c. “Dealing with Medical Uncertainty: A Physician’s Perspective.” Minnesota Medicine. 87 (10):48–51.Google Scholar
Han, Paul K. J. (this volume) A Pragmatic Agenda for Understanding and Managing Uncertainty in Healthcare.
Harendza, Sigrid, and Christopher Herzog. 2022. “Intuitive Concepts in Internal Medicine and Their Occurrence in Undergraduate Medical Students in Different Semesters.” GMS Journal of Medical Education. 39 (1): Doc11.Google Scholar
Harendza, Sigrid, Gärtner, Julia, Zelesniack, Elena, and Sarah Prediger. 2020. “Evaluation of a Telemedicine-Based Training for Final-Year Medical Students Including Simulated Patient Consultations, Documentation, and Case Presentation.” GMS Journal of Medical Education 37 (7): Doc94.Google Scholar
Hayward, Richard. 2005. “Balancing Certainty and Uncertainty in Clinical Medicine.” Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology 48: 74–77. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Henry, Michael S. 2006. “Uncertainty, Responsibility, and the Evolution of the Physician/Patient Relationship.” Journal of Medical Ethics 32 (6): 321–323. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Leonhardt, James M., Keller, Robin, and Cornelia Pechmann. 2011. “Avoiding the Risk of Responsibility by Seeking Uncertainty: Responsibility Aversion and Preference for Indirect Agency when Choosing for Others.” Journal of Consumer Psychology 21 (4): 405–413. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Li, Han Z., Koehn, Corinne, Desroches, Naghmeh G., Yum, Young-Ok, and George Deagle. 2007. “Asymmetrical Talk between Physicians and Patients: A Quantitative Discourse Analysis.” Canadian Journal of Communication 32: 417–433. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Lim, Jae-Young. 2007. “The Effect of Patient’s Asymmetric Information Problem on Elderly Use of Medical Care.” Applied Economics 39 (16): 2133–2142. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Lingard, Lorelei, Garwood, Kim, Schryer, Catherine F., and Marell M. Spafford. 2003. “A Certain Art of Uncertainty: Case Presentation and the Development of Professional Identity.” Social Science & Medicine 56 (3):603–16. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Norman, Geoffrey R., Monteiro, Sandra D., Sherbino, Jonathan, Ilgen, Jonathan S., Schmidt, Henk G., and Silvia Mamede. 2017. “The Causes of Errors in Clinical Reasoning: Cognitive Biases, Knowledge Deficits, and Dual Process Thinking.” Academic Medicine 92 (1):23–30. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Ohm, Friedemann, Vogel, Daniela, Sehner, Susanne, Wijnen-Meijer, Marjo, and Sigrid Harendza. 2013. “Details Acquired from Medical History and Patients’ Experience of Empathy – Two Sides of the Same Coin.” BMC Medical Education 13:67. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Patt, Anthony, and Richard Zeckhauser. 2000. “Action Bias and Environmental Decisions.” Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 21: 45–72. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Prediger, Sarah, Schick, Kristina, Fincke, Fabian, Fürstenberg, Sophie, Oubaid, Viktor, Kadmon Martina, Berberat, Pascal O., and Sigrid Harendza. 2020. “Validation of a Competence-Based Assessment of Medical Students‘ Performance in the Physician’s Role.” BMC Medical Education 20: 6. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Prediger, Sarah, and Sigrid Harendza. 2021. “Perspective Matters: Assessment of Medical Students’ Communication and Interpersonal Skills by Simulated Patients from the Internal and External Patient Perspective.” GMS Journal of Medical Education 38:Doc82.Google Scholar
Raglan, Greta B., Babush, Maxim, Farrow, Victoria A., Kruglansky, Arie W., and Jay Schulkin. 2014. “Need to Know: The Need for Cognitive Closure Impacts the Clinical Practice of Obstetrician/Gynecologists.” BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making 14:122. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Redder, Angelika. 1990. Grammatiktheorie und sprachliches Handeln: denn und da. Tübingen: Niemeyer. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Rehbein, Jochen. 1972. “Entschuldigungen und Rechtfertigungen. Zur Sequenzierung von kommunikativen Handlungen.” In Linguistische Pragmatik, edited by Dieter Wunderlich, 288–317. Frankfurt am Main: Athenäum.Google Scholar
Rehbein, Jochen, Schmidt, Thomas, Meyer, Bernd, Watzke, Franziska, and Annette Herkenrath. 2004. “Handbuch für das computergestützte Transkribieren nach HIAT.” In Arbeiten zur Mehrsprachigkeit – Folge B 56. Hamburg: Universität Hamburg – Sonderforschungsbereich 538.Google Scholar
Ryynänen, Katja. 2001. Constructing Physician’s Professional Identity. Explorations of Students’ Critical Experiences in Medical Education. Oulu: Oulun yliopisto.Google Scholar
Siegrist, Johannes. 1978. Arbeit und Interaktion im Krankenhaus. Stuttgart: Enke.Google Scholar
Simpkin, Arabella L., and Richard M. Schwartzstein. 2016. “Tolerating Uncertainty – The Next Medical Revolution?” New England Journal of Medicine 375 (18): 1713–1715. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Spiegel, Carmen. 1995. Streit. Eine linguistische Untersuchung verbaler Interaktion in alltäglichen Zusammenhängen. Tübingen: Narr.Google Scholar
West, Andrew F., and Robert R. West. 2002. “Clinical Decision-Making: Coping with Uncertainty.” Postgraduate Medical Journal 78: 319–321. DOI logoGoogle Scholar
Cited by (1)

Cited by one other publication

Han, Paul K.J.
2023. Chapter 13. Uncertainty in healthcare. In A Pragmatic Agenda for Healthcare [Pragmatics & Beyond New Series, 338], ► pp. 314 ff. DOI logo

This list is based on CrossRef data as of 5 july 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers. Any errors therein should be reported to them.