Resemblance in comments/posts interaction
Forms and functions of dialogicity
This paper studies dialogicity in posts and their comments. Focusing on political slogans in the Facebook page of Israel PM Binyamin Netanyahu, we examine the ways comments meta-represent the posts in various degrees of resemblance. Starting with the premise that comments/post interactions are dialogic in the Bakhtinian sense, we argue that comments are dialogic in yet another way, which is related to the form and degree of resemblance between them. The conceptualization draws on the notion of meta-representation supplemented by insights gained from accommodation theory and Bakhtin’s dialogism. We argue that through resemblance, the propositional content, ideology and viewpoint conveyed by the initiating slogan are incorporated in the comment, and a tacit dialogue is constructed between them. An additional layer of polyphony is added to the multiplicity of ratified voices otherwise manifest in the interaction between separate posts and comments.
Article outline
- 1.Introduction
- 2.Two approaches to resemblance
- 2.1Meta-representation through resemblance
- 2.2Accommodation theory
- 3.Data and context
- 3.1Data
- 3.2Netanyahu’s rhetoric
- 3.3Political slogans
- 4.Analysis
- 4.1A scale of resemblance
- 4.1.1Type A: Full resemblance: The chameleon effect
- 4.1.2Type B: Discursive resemblance
- 4.1.3Type C: Resemblance with stance explicitation
- 4.2Type D: Ironic echoic mention
- 4.3Ambiguity
- 5.Conclusion
- Acknowledgements
- Notes
-
References
References (51)
References
Atkin, Hila. 2019. Interactivity in Readers’ Ironic Comments to On-Line Op-Eds. on the Website of the “Haaretz” Newspaper: Threads and Ripples. Unpublished PhD dissertation, submitted to the Senate of Bar-Ilan University, supervised by Elda Weizman (in Hebrew).
Bakhtin, Mikhail M. 1981. In The Dialogic Imagination: Four Essays. ed. by Michael Holquist, trans. by Caryl Emerson. Austin: University of Texas Press.
Bakhtin, Mikhail M. 1984. Problems of Dostoevsky’s Poetics, ed. and trans. by Caryl Emerson. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Bakhtin, Mikhail M. 1986. Speech Genres and Other Late Essays, ed. by Caryl Emerson and Michael Holquist, trans. by Vern W. McGee. Austin: University of Texas Press.
Chartrand, Tanya L. and John L. Bargh. 1999. “The Chameleon Effect: The Perception-Behavior Link and Social Interaction.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 76 (6): 893–91.
Condit, Celeste and John Lucaites. 1993. Crafting Equality: America’s Anglo-African Word. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Danescu-Niculescu-Mizil, Cristian, Michael Gamon and Susan Dumais. 2011. “Mark my Words! Linguistic Style Accommodation in Social Media”. WWW 2011, March 28–April 1, 2011, Hyderabad, India. ACM 978-1-4503-0632-4/11/03.
Galois, Cindy, Tania Ogay and Howard Giles. 2006. “Communication Accommodation Theory: A Look Back and a Look Ahead.” In Theorizing about communication and culture, ed. by W. B. Gudykunst, 121–148. Thousand Oaks, Calif.: Sage.
Gitay, Yehoshua. 2016. “Netanyahu in the USA Congress”. Israel Studies in Language and Society 9 (1–2): 20–28 (in Hebrew).
Ireland, Molly E., Richard B. Slatcher, Paul W. Eastwick, Lauren E. Scissors, Eli J. Finkel and James W. Pennebaker. 2011. “Language Style Matching Predicts Relationship Initiation and Stability.” Psychological Science 22 (1): 39–44.
Ishak, Wan Irham and Shameem Rafik-Galea. 2015. “Speech Accommodation Strategies in the Selling of Life Insurance.” Pertanika, Journal of Social Sciences & Humanities 231: 143–157.
Kohn, A. 2003, “Comic strip, poem, and journal article: Three models of image/text.” In Hebrew – A Living Language 3, ed. by Rina Ben-Shahar and Gideon Toury, 167–189. Tel-Aviv: Hakibbutz Hamehuchad and the Porter Institute for Poetics and Semiotics. (in Hebrew).
Kohn, Ayelet. 2011. “From a slight smile to scathing sarcasm: Shades of humor as means of criticism in Israeli photojournalism.” Misgarot Media 71: 29–54. (in Hebrew).
Kohn, Ayelet. 2016. “The Polyphonic Framing of Ehud Olmert.” Israel studies in Language and Society 9 (1–2): 116–141. [In Hebrew.]
Kohn, Ayelet. 2019. “Iconic Televised Situations.” In Hebrew – A Living Language 8, ed. by Rina Ben-Shahar and Nitsa Ben-Ari, 153–176. Tel-Aviv: Hakibbutz Hamehuchad and the Porter Institute for Poetics and Semiotics. (in Hebrew).
Lakin, Jessica L., Valerie E. Jefferis, Clara Michelle Cheng, and Tanya L. Chartrand. 2003. “The Chameleon Effect as Social Glue: Evidence for the Evolutionary Significance of Nonconscious Mimicry.” Journal of Nonverbal Behavior 271:145–162.
Lerner, Anat, Oren Miara, Sarit Malayev, and Vered Silber-Varod. 2018. “The Influence of the Interlocutor’s Gender on the Speaker’s Role Identification”. In: Speech and Computer (SPECOM 2018). Lecture Notes in Computer Science, vol. 110961, ed. by Alexey Karpov, Oliver Jokisch and Rodmonga Potapova, 321–330. Cham: Springer.
Litt, Eden, and Eszter Hargittai. 2016. “The Imagined Audience on Social Network Sites.” Social Media and Society 2(1): 1–12.
Liu, Xing. 1999. “An Ideological/Cultural Analysis of Political Slogans in Communist China.” Discourse & Society 10(4): 487–508.
Mukherjee, Sankar, Alessandro D’Ausilio, Noël Nguyen, Luciano Fadiga, and Leonardo Badino. 2017. The Relationship Between F0 Synchrony and Speech Convergence in Dyadic Interaction. Interspeech, August 2017: 2341–2345.
Niederhoffer, Kate G. and James W. Pennebaker. 2002. “Linguistic style matching in social interaction.” Journal of language and Social Psychology 21(4): 337–360.
Pardo, Jennifer S. 2006. “On phonetic convergence during conversational interaction.” Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 19 (4): 2382–2393.
Pardo, Jennifer S., Adelya Urmanche, Sherilyn Wilman, Jaclyn Wiener, Nicholas Mason, Keagan Francis, and Melanie Ward. 2018. “A comparison of phonetic convergence in conversational interaction and speech shadowing.” Journal of Phonetics 691: 1–11.
Park-Fuller, Linda M. 1986. “Voices: Bakhtin’s Heteroglossia and Polyphony, and the Performance of Narrative Literature”, Literature in Performance 7 (1):1–12. Online at: [URL] (accessed 17 November 2020).
Perelman, Chaïm et Lucie Olbrechts-Tyteca. 1958. Le Traité de l’argumentation, la nouvelle rhétorique. Bruxelles: Editions de l’Université de Bruxelles.
Reddy, Michael. 1979. “The conduit metaphor: A case of frame conflict in our language about language.” In Metaphor and thought, ed. by Andrew Ortony, 284–310. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Shukrun-Nagar, Pnina. 2020a. “The Right to Speak and the Request to Remain Silent: Who Own Politicians’ Facebook Pages?” Israel Affairs 26 (1): 26–43.
Shukrun-Nagar, Pnina. 2021. “Constructed General Truths against Specific Political Rivals in Politicians’ Facebook Posts”. Journal of Pragmatics 1721: 79–88.
Silber-Varod, Vered, Sarit Malayev, and Anat Lerner. 2020. “Positioning oneself in different roles: Structural and lexical measures of power relations between speakers in map task corpus.” Speech Communication 1171:1 – 12.
Sperber, Dan. 2000. “Metarepresentations in an evolutionary perspective”. In Metarepresentations: A Multidisciplinary Perspective, ed. by Dan Sperber, 117–137. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Sperber, Dan, and Deirdre Wilson. 1981. “Irony and the Use-Mention Distinction.” In Peter Cole, ed., Radical Pragmatics, 295–318. New York: Academic Press.
Sperber, Dan and Deirdre Wilson. 1986. Relevance: Communication and Cognition. Oxford: Blackwell.
Szczepek Reed, Beatrice. 2020. “Reconceptualizing mirroring: Sound imitation and rapport in naturally occurring interaction”. Journal of Pragmatics 1671: 131–151.
Weise, Andreas and Rivka Levitan. 2018. “Looking for structure in lexical and acoustic-prosodic entrainment behaviors.” Proceedings of NAACL-HLT 2018, 297–302. New Orleans, Louisiana, June 1 – 6, 2018. Association for Computational Linguistics.
Weise, Andreas, Vered Silber-Varod, Anat Lerner, Julia Hirschberg and Rivka Levitan. 2021. “’Talk to me with left, right, and angles’: Lexical entrainment in spoken Hebrew dialogue”. Proceedings of the 16th Conference of the European Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics (EACL 2021), Online conference, 19–23 April, 2021.
Weizman, Elda. 1984. “Some register characteristics of discourse structure in journalisitic language.” Applied Linguistics V/11: 39-50.
Weizman, Elda. 2008. Positioning in Media Dialogue: The Case of News Interviews on Israeli Television. Amsterdam/Philadelphia John Benjamins.
Weizman, Elda. 2012. “Irony in news interviews: Dialogism and intertexuality”. In Slovo a Slovesnost, Special Issue on Intertexuality, Polyphony, Heteroglossia, ed. by Svetla Cmejrková and Jana Hoffmannová, 253–262. Prague: Charles University.
Weizman, Elda. 2016. “Ironic commenting on op-eds: obstructing discussion.” Israel Studies in Language and Society 9(1–2): 184–208 (in Hebrew).
Weizman, Elda. 2019. “The discursive pattern ‘claim+ indirect quotation in quotation marks’: Strategic uses in French and Hebrew online journalism.” Journal of Pragmatics 1571: 131–141.
Weizman, Elda and Gonen Dori-Hacohen. 2017. “Commenting on opinion editorials in on-line journals: A cross-cultural examination of face-work in the Washington Post (USA) and NRG (Israel).” Discourse, Context & Media 191: 39–48.
Weizman, Elda and Anita Fetzer (eds.). 2019. Follow-Ups in Political Discourse: Explorations Across Contexts and Discourse Domains. Amsterdam & Philadelphia: Benjamins.
Wilson, Deirdre. 2012. “Metarepresentation in linguistic communication.” in Meaning and Relevance, ed. by Deirdre Wilson and Dan Sperber, 230–258, Cambridge University Press. [First published in Dan Sperber (ed.). 2000. Metarepresentations: A Multidisciplinary Perspective. Oxford University Press, 2000, 411–48].
Wilson, Deirdre, and Dan Sperber. 1992. “On Verbal Irony.” Lingua 871: 53–76.
Wilson, Deirdre, and Dan Sperber. 2012. “Explaining irony”, in Meaning and Relevance, ed. by Deirdre Wilson and Dan Sperber, 123–146. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Cited by (1)
Cited by one other publication
Weizman, Elda
2023.
Recontextualization practices: A scale of directness.
Frontiers in Communication 7
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 5 july 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.