This paper discusses foundational issues in nominalization, focusing on empirical, conceptual, and theoretical problems that have plagued the field for years. Current definitions of nominalization are based on narrow observations on verbal-based nominalizations, while languages across the globe display nominal-based ones, many of which share morphology with the former. Nominalization morphology in many languages also applies to units larger than words, yielding grammatical nominalizations besides lexical nominalizations. The imbalance in the past studies, which have focused on so-called relative clauses at the expense of grammatical nominalizations, has resulted in a lopsided view on the relationship between the two. This, in turn, has led to the mishandling of different manifestations of nominalizations as if they are derivatives of relative clauses, as suggested by the widely used terms such as “headless relative clause” and “internally-headed relative clause”. We demonstrate that these, including the ordinary restrictive relative clause, are not independent grammatical structures but are epiphenomena arising from the uses of grammatical nominalizations. A clear distinction between structures and their use is a theoretical prerequisite in arriving at a satisfactory understanding of the nature of grammatical nominalizations and their role in grammar.
Article outline
1.Introduction
2.Defining nominalization
2.1Nominalization as a metonymic process
2.2Meaning range and the nature of lexical nominalizations
2.3Inputs to nominalization processes
2.4Outputs of nominalization processes
3.Verbal-based grammatical nominalization
3.1Event nominalizations
3.2Argument nominalizations
3.2.1Role markers
4.Formal representations of verbal-based nominalizations
5.Structures and their use
5.1NP-use and modification-use of grammatical nominalizations
5.2NP-use of event nominalizations: So-called “internally-headed RCs”
5.3NP-use of event nominalizations: So-called “complement clauses”
5.4NP-use of argument nominalizations: So-called “headless/free relative clauses”
5.5Modification-use of argument nominalizations: So-called “relative clauses”
6.Sentences, clauses, and nominalizations
6.1Tense and nominalization
6.2Functional definitions of clauses, sentences, and nominalizations
6.3Insubordination
6.4Evidence that nominalizations are not clauses or sentences
Adelaar, Willem. 2011. Participial clauses in Tarma Quechua. In van Gijn, Haude & Muysken (eds), 267–280.
Aikhenvald, Alexandra Y.2006. Classifiers and noun classes: Semantics. In Encyclopedia of Language and Linguistics, 2nd edn, Keith Brown (ed.), 463–471. Oxford: Elsevier.
Aikhenvald, Alexandra Y.2009. Complement clause types and complementation strategies in Tariana. In Robert M. W. Dixon & Alexandra Aikhenvald (eds), 178–203.
Ajiboye, Oladipo Jacob. 2005. Topics on Yoruba Nominal Expressions. PhD dissertation, University of British Columbia.
Allan, Keith. 1977. Classifiers. Language 53(2): 285–311.
Allan, Keith. 2001. Natural Language Semantics. Oxford: Blackwell.
Alvarez, Albert. 2012. Relative clauses and nominalizations. In Comrie & Estrada-Fernández (eds), 65–96.
Andrews, Avery. 2007. Relative clauses. In Language Typology and Syntactic Description, Vol. 2: Complex Constructions, Timothy Shopen (ed.), 206–236. Cambridge: CUP.
Bills, Garland, Vallejo, Bernardo & Troike, Rudolph. 1971. An Introduction to Spoken Bolivian Quechua. Austin TX: University of Texas Press.
Blake, Barry J.1979. A Kalkatungu Grammar [Pacific Linguistics Series B, No. 57]. Canberra: Research School of Pacific Studies, Australian National University.
Bugaeva, Anna. 2012. Southern Hokkaido Ainu. In The Languages of Japan and Korea, Nicolas Tranter (ed.), 799–845. London: Routledge.
Campbell, Akua Asantewaa. 2013. Grammatical nominalizations in Akan and Gã. Ms, Department of Linguistics, Rice University.
Campbell, Akua Asantewaa. 2017. A Grammar of Gã. PhD dissertation, Rice University.
Caponigro, Ivano, Torrence, Harold & Cisneros, Carlos. 2013. Free relative clauses in two Mixtec languages. International Journal of American Linguistics 79(1): 61–96.
Ciccone, Florecia. 2008. Relative clauses and nominalization in Tapiete (Tupí-Guaraní). Term paper for the seminar “Typology and Functional Linguistics: Case studies on relative clauses, nominalization, serial verbs and complex predicates” by Masayoshi Shibatani, University of Buenos Aires, Argentina.
Cole, Peter. 1982. Imbabura Quechua. Amsterdam: North Holland.
Cole, Peter. 1987. The structure of internally headed relative clauses. Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 5: 277–302.
Comrie, Bernard. 1996. The unity of noun modifying clauses in Asian languages. Pan-Asiatic Linguistics: Proceedings of the Fourth International Symposium on Languages and Linguistics, 1077–1088. Salaya, Thailand: Mahidol University.
Comrie, Bernard. 1998a. Attributive clauses in Asian languages: Toward an areal typology. In Sprache in Raum und Zeit, In memoriam Johannes Bechert, Winfried Boeder, Christoph Schroeder, Karl Heinz Wagner & Wolfgang Wildgen (eds), 51–60. Tübingen: Gunter Narr.
Comrie, Bernard. 1998b. Rethinking the typology of relative clauses. Language Design 1: 59–86.
Comrie, Bernard. 2006. Syntactic typology: just how exotic ARE European-type relative clauses?’, In Linguistic Universals, Ricardo Mairal and Juana Gil (eds), 130–154. Cambridge: CUP.
Comrie, Bernard & Horie, Kaoru. 1995. Complement clauses versus relative clauses: Some Khmer evidence. In Discourse Grammar and Typology: Papers in Honor of John W. M. Verhaar [Studies in Language Companion Series 27] Werner Abraham, T. Givón & Sandra A. Thompson (eds), 65–75. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Comrie, Bernard & Keenan, Edward L.1979. Noun phrase accessibility revisited. Language 55: 649–664.
Comrie, Bernard & Thompson, Sandra A.1985/2007. Lexical nominalization. In Language Typology and Syntactic Description, Vol. 3: Grammatical Categories and the Lexicon, Timothy Shopen (ed.), 334–381. Cambridge: CUP.
Croft, William. 1991. Syntactic Categories and Grammatical Relations. Chicago IL: University of Chicago Press.
Cruz, Aline. 2011. Fonologia e gramática do Nheengatú. PhD dissertation, Free University Amsterdam.
Crystal, David. 1980. A Dictionary of Linguistics and Phonetics. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell.
Davis, Henry. 2010. A unified analysis of relative clauses in St’át’imcets. Northwest Journal of Linguistics 4(1): 1–43.
Dayley, Jon P. 1989. Tümpisa (Panamint) Shoshone Grammar. Berkeley CA: University of California Press.
DeLancey, Scott1986. Relativization as nominalization in Tibetan and Newari. Ms, presented at the 19th International Conference on Sino-Tibetan Languages and Linguistics.
DeLancey, Scott. 2002. Relativization and nominalization in Bodic. In Proceedings of the Twenty-eighth Annual Meeting of the Berkeley Linguistics Society: Special Session on Tibeto-Burman and Southeast Asian Linguistics: In Honor of Prof. James A. Matisoff, Patrick Chew (ed.), 55–72. Berkeley CA: BLS.
Derbyshire, Desmond. 1999. Carib. In The Amazonian Languages, Robert M. W. Dixon & Alexandra Y. Aikhenvald (eds), 23–64.
Dixon, Robert M. W. 2006. Complement clauses and complementation strategies in typological perspective. In Complementation: A Cross-linguistic Typology, Robert M. W. Dixon & Alexandra Y. Aikhenvald (eds), 1–48. Oxford: OUP.
Dixon, Robert M. W.2010. Basic Linguistic Theory, Vol 2. Oxford: OUP.
Dixon, Robert M. W. & Aikhenvald, Alexandra Y. (eds). 2009. The Amazonian Languages. Cambridge: CUP.
Dryer, Matthew S.2007. Noun phrase structure. In Language Typology and Syntactic Description, Vol. 2: Complex Constructions, Timothy Shopen (ed.), 151–205. Cambridge: CUP.
Evans, Nicholas. 2007. Insubordination and its uses. In Finiteness: Theoretical and Empirical Foundations, Irina Nikolaeva (ed.), 366–431. Oxford: OUP.
Everett, Daniel. 1986. Pirahã. In Handbook of Amazonian Languages, Vol. 1, Desmond Derbyshire & Geoffrey Pullum (eds), 200–326. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Everett, Daniel. 2005. Cultural constraints on grammar in Pirahã: Another look at the design features of human language. Current Anthropology 46: 621–646.
Everett, Daniel. 2009. Pirahã culture and grammar: A response to some criticisms. Language 85: 405–442.
Fillmore, Charles. 1976. Frame semantics and the nature of language. In Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences: Conference on the Origin and Development of Language and Speech. Volume 280: 20-32.
Fillmore, Charles. 1982. Frame semantics. In Linguistics in the Morning Calm. 111-137. Seoul: Hanshin Publishing Co.
Frellesvig, Bjarke. 2010. A History of the Japanese Language. Cambridge: CUP.
Galucio, Ana Vilacy. 2011. Subordinate adverbial constructions in Mekens. In van Gijn, Haude & Muysken (eds), 25–44.
Gerdts, Donna B. & Hinkson, Mercedes Q.2004. Salish numeral classifiers: A lexical means to a grammatical end. Language Typology and Universals 57: 247–279.
Graczyk, Randolph. 2007. A Grammar of Crow. Lincoln NE: University of Nebraska Press.
Guerrero, Lillián. 2012. On relative clauses and related constructions in Yaqui. In Comrie & Estrada-Fernández (eds), 97–126.
Gutièrrex-Bravo, Rodrigo. 2012. Relative clauses in Yucatec Maya: Light heads vs. null heads. In Comrie & Estrada-Fernández (eds), 253–268.
Hale, Ken. 1976. The adjoined relative clause in Australia. In Grammatical Categories in Australian Languages, Robert M. W. Dixon (ed.), 78–105. Atlantic Highlands NJ: Humanities Press.
Hale, Ken & Platero, Paul. 1973. Aspects of Navajo anaphora: Relativization and pronominalization. Diné Bizaad Náníl’iih 1: 9–28.
Huade, Katharina. 2006. A Grammar of Movima. PhD dissertation, Radboud University Nijmegen.
Huang, Chenglong. 2008. Relativization in Qiang. Language and Linguistics 9(4): 735–768.
Huang, Lillian M.1995. A Study of Mayrinax Syntax. Taipei: The Crane Publishing Co.
Hutchison, John P.1981. The Kanuri Language: A Reference Grammar. Madison WI: University of Wisconsin Press.
Iwasaki, Shoichi & Ingkaphirom, Preeya. 2005. A Reference Grammar of Thai. Cambridge: CUP.
Jacobson, Steven A.1984. Yup’ik Eskimo Dictionary. Fairbanks AK: Alaska Native Language Center, University of Alaska.
Jaisser, Annie. 1987. Hmong classifiers. Linguistics of the Tibeto-Burman Area10 (2): 169–176.
Jelinek, Eloise. 1987. Headless relatives and pronominal arguments: A typological perspective. In Native American Languages and Grammatical Typology. Papers from a Chicago Linguistics Society Parasession, Paul D. Kroeber & Robert E. Moore (eds). Bloomington IN: Indiana University Linguistics Club.
Jensen, Cheryl.1999. Tupí-Guaraní. In Robert M. W. Dixon & Alexandra Aikhenvald (eds), 125–164.
Johns, Alana. 1982. A unified analysis of relative clauses and questions in Rainy River Ojibway. In The Proceedings of the Thirteenth Algonquian Conference, William Cowan (ed.), 161–168. Ottawa: Carleton University.
Jones, Wendell & Jones, Paula. 1991. Barasano Syntax [Studies in the Languages of Colombia 2]. Arlington TX: Summer Institute of Linguistics and the University of Texas.
Keenan, Edward. 1985. Relative clauses. In Language Typology and Syntactic Description, Vol. 2: Complex Constructions, Timothy Shopen (ed.), 141–170. Cambridge: CUP.
Keenan, Edward & Comrie, Bernard. 1977. NP accessibility and universal grammar. Linguistic Inquiry 8: 63–100.
Klumpp, James & Burquest, Donald A.1983. Relative clauses in Piapoco. International Journal of American Linguistics 49(4): 388–399.
Koptjevskaja-Tamm, Maria. 1995. Possessive and relational forms in Chukchi. In Double Case: Agreement by Suffixaufnahme, Frans Plank (ed.), 301–321. Oxford: OUP.
Kroeber, Paul. 1997. Relativization in River Thompson Salish. Anthropological Linguistics 39: 376–422.
Kuroda, S.-Y.1992. Japanese Syntax and Semantics: Collected Papers. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
Lakoff, Geroge & Johnson, Mark. 2003. Metaphors We Live By. Chicago IL: University of Chicago Press.
Langacker, Ronald. 1987. Foundations of Cognitive Grammar, Vol. I. Stanford CA: Stanford University Press.
Langacker, Ronald. 1991. Foundations of Cognitive Grammar, Vol. II. Stanford CA: Stanford University Press.
Larsen, Thomas & Norman, William.1979. Correlates of ergativity in Mayan grammar. In Ergativity: Towards a Theory of Grammatical Relations, Frans Plank (ed.), 347–370. New York NY: Academic Press.
Lee, Sung-nyong. 1975. A study of the word Kes in Middle Korean. Cintan Hakpo 39: 105–138.
Lees, Robert. 1963. The Grammar of English Nominalizations. The Hague: Mouton.
Lefebvre, Claire & Muysken, Pieter. 1988. Mixed Categories: Nominalizations in Quechua. New York NY: Springer.
Lehmann, Christian. 1986. On the typology of relative clauses. Linguistics 24: 663–680.
Li, Charles N. & Thompson, Sandra A.1989. Mandarin Chinese: A Functional Reference Grammar. Berkeley CA: University of California Press.
Loos, Eugene. 1999. Pano. In Robert M. W. Dixon & Alexandra Y. Aikhenvald (eds), 227–250.
Malchukov, Andrej. 2004. Nominalization, Verbalization: Constraining a Typology of Transcategorial Operations. Munich: Lincom.
Martin, Jack. 2011. A Grammar of Creek (Muskogee). Lincoln NE: University of Nebraska Press.
Matisoff, James. 1972. Lahu nominalization, relativization, and genitivization. In Syntax and Semantics, Vol. 1, John Kimball (ed.), 237–258. New York NY: Seminar Press.
Matthews, Stephen & Yip, Virginia. 1994. Cantonese: A Comprehensive Grammar. London: Routledge.
Mchombo, Sam. 2004. The Syntax of Chichewa. Cambridge: CUP.
Messineo, Cristina. 2003. Lengua Toba (Guaycurú). Aspectos gramaticales y discursivos. Munich: Lincom.
Messineo, Cristina & Porta, Andrés. 2009. Cláusulas realtivas en Toba (Guaycurú). International Journal of American Linguistics 75(1): 49–68.
Miller, Amy. 2001. A Grammar of Jamul Tiipay. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Miyaoka, Osahito. 2012. A Grammar of Central Alaskan Yupik (CAY). Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Montgomery-Anderson, Brad. 2008. A Reference Grammar of Oklahoma Cherokee. PhD dissertation, University of Kansas.
Moore, Denny. 2012. Relative clauses in Gavião of Rondônia. In Comrie & Estrada-Fernández (eds), 243–252.
Moyse-Faurie, Claire. 2016. Referential markers in Oceanic nominalized constructions. In Finiteness and Nominalization [Typological Studies in Language 113], Claudine Chamoreau & Zarina Estrada Fernández (eds), 171–203. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Nagaya, Naonori. 2011. The Lamaholot Language of Eastern Indonesia. PhD dissertation, Rice University.
Nevis, Andrew, Pesetsky, David & Rodrigues, Cilene. 2009. Pirahã exceptionality: A reassessment. Language 85: 355–404.
Nicolle, Steve. 2013. A Grammar of Digo: A Bantu Language of Kenya and Tanzania. Dallas TX: SIL International.
Noonan, Michael. 1985. Complementation. In Language Typology and Syntax Description, Vol. 2: Complex Constructions, Timothy Shopen (ed.), 42–141. Cambridge: CUP.
Noonan, Michael. 1997. Versatile nominalizations. In Essays on Language Function and Language Type. Dedicated to T. Givón, Joan Bybee, John Haiman & Sandra A. Thompson (eds), 373–394. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Noonan, Michael. 2008. Nominalization in Bodic languages. In Rethinking Grammaticalization: New Perspectives [Typological Studies in Language 76], María José-López-Cruso & Elena Seoane (eds), 219–237. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
Payne, Doris. 1985. Aspects of the Grammar of Yagua: A Typological Perspective. PhD dissertation, University of California, Los Angeles.
Payne, Thomas. 1997. Describing Morphosyntax: A Guide for Field Linguists. Cambridge: CUP.
Rice, Keren. 1989. A Grammar of Slave. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Riddle, Elizabeth. 1989. White Hmong noun classifiers and referential salience. Paper presented at the Association of Asian Studies, inc. annual meeting, Washington DC.
Riddle, Elizabeth. 1993. The relative maker uas in Hmong. Linguistics of the Tibeto-Burman Area 16(2): 57–68.
Rodrigues, Aryon. 1999. Macro-Jê. In Robert M. W. Dixon & Alexandra Y. Aikhenvald (eds), 165–206.
Ross, John Robert. 1973. Nouniness. In Three Dimensions of Linguistic Theory, Osamu Fujimura (ed.), 137–257. Tokyo: The TEC Corporation.
Sakel, Jeanette. 2004. A Grammar of Mosetén. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Salanova, Andrés Pablo. 2011. Relative clauses in Mẽbengokre. In van Gijn, Haude & Myusken (eds), 45–78.
Schachter, Paul & Otanes, Fe T.1972/1983. Tagalog Reference Grammar. Berkeley CA: University of California Press.
Seki, Lucy. 2000. Gramática do Kamaiurá, Língua Tupi-Guarani do Alto Xingu. Campinas: Editora UNICAMP and São Paulo State Official Press.
Searle, John. 1969. Speech Acts: An Essay in the Philosophy of Language. Cambridge: CUP.
Shibatani, Masayoshi. 2008. Relativization in Sasak and Sumbawa, Eastern Indonesia. Language and Linguistics 9(4): 865–916.
Shibatani, Masayoshi. 2017. Nominalization. In Handbook of Japanese Syntax, Masayoshi Shibatani, Shigeru Miyagawa & Hisashi Noda (eds), 271–332. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Shibatani, Masayoshi. 2018a. Nominalization in crosslinguistic perspective. In Handbook of Japanese Contrastive Linguistics, Prashant Pardeshi & Taro Kageyama (eds), 345–410. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Shibatani, Masayoshi. 2018b. Nominalization. In Handbook of Japanese Linguistics, Yoko Hasegawa (ed.), 431–462. Cambridge: CUP.
Shibatani, Masayoshi & Awadh bin Makhashen, Khaled. 2009. Nominalization in Soqotri, a South Arabian language of Yemen. In Linguistics of Endangered Languages: Contributions to Morphology and Syntax, W. Leo Wetzels (ed.), 9–31. Leiden: Brill.
Shibatani, Masayoshi & Shigeno, Hiromi. 2013. Amami nominalizations. International Journal of Okinawan Studies 4(1): 107–138.
Shimoji, Michinori. 2008A Grammar of Irabu, A Southern Ryukyuan Language. PhD dissertation, Australian National University.
Sposato, Adam. 2012. Relative clauses in Xong (Miao-Yao). Journal of the Southeast Asian Linguistics Society 5: 49–66.
Starosta, Stanley, Pawley, Andrew & Reid, Lawrence A.1982. The evolution of focus in Austronesian. In Papers from the 3rd International Conference on AustronesianLinguistics, Vol. 2, Amran Halim, Lois Carrington & Stephen A. Wurm (eds), 145–170. Canberra: Australian National University.
Tamura, Yuki-Shige. 2017. Grammaticalization and nominalization in Central Alaskan Yup’ik. Presentation at the Nominalization Festival III, Osaka University, 8July.
Thiesen, Wesley & Weber, David. 2012. A Grammar of Bora with Special Attention to Tone. Dallas TX: SIL International.
Thornes, Tim. 2003. A Northern Paiute Grammar with Texts. PhD dissertation, University of Oregon.
Thornes, Tim. 2012. The nominalization-relativization connection in Northen Paiute. In Comrie & Estrada-Fernández (eds), 147–170.
Treis, Yvonne. 2008. Relativization in Kambaata from a typological point of view. In Interaction of Morphology and Syntax: Case Studies in Afroasiatic [Typological Studies in Language 75], Zygmunt Frajzyngier & Erin Shay (eds), 161–206. Amsterdam: John Benjamins.
van der Voort, Hein. 2009. Possessive expressions in the Southwestern Amazon. In The Expression of Possession, William B. McGregor (ed.), 343–388. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Van Valin Jr., Robert D.1977. Aspects of Lakohta Syntax. PhD dissertation, University of California, Berkeley.
Vendler, Zeno.1967. Linguistics in Philosophy. Ithaca NY: Cornell University Press.
Watkins, Laurel J.1984. A Grammar of Kiowa. Lincoln NE: University of Nebraska Press.
Weber, David. 1989. A Grammar of Huallaga (Huánuco) Quechua. Berkeley CA: University of California Press.
Willie, Mary A.1989Why there is nothing missing in Navajo relative clauses? In Athapaskan Linguistics: Current Perspectives on a Language Family, Eung-Do Cook and Karen Rice (eds), 407–437. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Yamada, Yoshio. 1908. Nihonbunpōron (Theory of Japanese grammar). Tokyo: Hōbunkan.
Yaowapat, Natchanan & Prasithrathsint, Amara. 2009. A typology of relative clauses in mainland Southeast Asian languages. The Mon-Khmer Studies Journal 38: 1–23.
Yap, Foong Ha & Grunow-Hårsta, Karen. 2010. Non-referential uses of nominalization constructions: Asian perspectives. Language and Linguistics Compass 3(1): 1–22.
2023. On the L1 acquisition of recursive no in Japanese. Canadian Journal of Linguistics/Revue canadienne de linguistique 68:2 ► pp. 163 ff.
Chacon, Thiago Costa
2022. Gender and Noun Class Markers in Kubeo (Tukanoan). Faits de Langues 52:2 ► pp. 11 ff.
Juanatey, Mayra
2022. Nominalización en quichua santiagueño: del léxico a la cláusula. Cuadernos de Lingüística de El Colegio de México 9 ► pp. 1 ff.
Nagaya, Naonori
2022. Prashant Pardeshi and Kaoru Horie (eds.): Nihongo to sekai no gengo no meisisyuusyoku-hyoogen
. Journal of Japanese Linguistics 38:2 ► pp. 279 ff.
Shagal, Ksenia, Pavel Rudnev & Anna Volkova
2022. Multifunctionality and syncretism in non-finite forms: an introduction. Folia Linguistica 56:3 ► pp. 529 ff.
Ciucci, Luca
2021. From Fieldwork to Reconstruction: Historical Issues in Hotspots of Linguistic Diversity*. Studia Linguistica 75:2 ► pp. 165 ff.
Cúneo, Paola
2021. Foco estrecho y corrrección de expectativas. LIAMES: Línguas Indígenas Americanas 21 ► pp. e021006 ff.
This list is based on CrossRef data as of 30 december 2024. Please note that it may not be complete. Sources presented here have been supplied by the respective publishers.
Any errors therein should be reported to them.